Deserter returns to US: Opinions

Posted By Message

Diva
I am what I am

Member since 12/05

2825 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Deserter returns to US: Opinions

Not sure if this has been discussed before,but did this young man do the right thing?

LOUISVILLE, Ky. - A soldier who fled to Canada rather than accept a second tour in Iraq turned himself over to military authorities at Fort Knox yesterday, his attorney said.

Kyle Snyder, a former combat engineer, left the U.S. in April 2005 while on leave. He said he worked as a welder and at a children's health clinic in Canada.

Snyder's lawyer, James Fennerty, said he had reached a deal with Army officials to allow Snyder to be processed back into uniform at Fort Knox, southwest of Louisville, and then be discharged.

But he said Snyder told him yesterday afternoon the Army wants to send him back to his original unit at Fort Leonard Wood, Mo., where commanders would determine his future.

"We wouldn't have brought him back here if we knew this was going to happen," Fennerty said.

A Fort Knox spokeswoman, Gini Sinclair, said deserters whose units are not fully deployed are returned to that unit.

Mike Alley, a Fort Leonard Wood spokesman, said Snyder was scheduled to be processed there.

Snyder, 23, was trained as an engineer but said that when he was sent to Iraq in 2004 he was put on patrol, something he said he wasn't trained to do.

He said he began to turn against the war when he saw an innocent Iraqi man seriously wounded by American gunfire. The shooting was inadequately investigated, he said.

Posted 11/1/06 10:43 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Ang-Rich
Beyond Compare

Member since 5/05

17988 total posts

Name:

Re: Deserter returns to US: Opinions

Personally, if he thought this was the right thing to do then who am I to judge...especially since I am not a soldier nor have any family serving in the war. I would think that his unit would be very disappointed in him and I think he should expect a hard time from them.

We keep hearing about all of these soldiers who are dying and getting injured and I get so confused as to how I feel when something like this comes up. Could his presence have saved a life...or could his presence have cost him his. I guess I have no opinion. Chat Icon

Posted 11/1/06 10:49 AM
 

LittleBlueBug
Happy Mommy

Member since 9/06

4074 total posts

Name:

Re: Deserter returns to US: Opinions

I think it's just time to send these troops home already. I can't say I blame him if wasn't properly trained and was put in that type of situation where he could lose his life. I just hope they let him out.

Posted 11/1/06 10:49 AM
 

Diva
I am what I am

Member since 12/05

2825 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Deserter returns to US: Opinions

Ang, you've got some very good points. I think in matters like this though, feelings should be put into consideration. If he was this fearful, would his performance been affected? Most soldiers feel it is their duty to go when called back, but if they have doubts, then they should be excused.

Posted 11/1/06 11:01 AM
 

Beth
The Key to your new home....

Member since 2/06

24849 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Deserter returns to US: Opinions

a deals a deal- if they made a deal with him to do soemthing- they should up hold it

they all should come home already! it just keeps getting worse- each month more and more of our troops get killed and injuried

Posted 11/1/06 11:08 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
need opinions on planning trip for out of state wedding Myrockette 3/24/06 2 Families Helping Families ™
So, I need opinions... LIPrincess 3/23/06 9 TTC
decided to at least start pumping...questions and opinions? mable 3/22/06 12 Parenting
Need your opinions ladies!! CityNYGirl 3/22/06 9 TTC
Dilemma, need your opinions. bee 3/21/06 8 Pregnancy
Vacation question...Need opinions... nov04libride 3/21/06 2 Families Helping Families ™