Credit Card Balance Question

Posted By Message

CloudNine
My Baby Boy is Here!

Member since 2/09

2831 total posts

Name:
Jackie

Credit Card Balance Question

Does anyone know if its better to:
1. pay off a lower balance credit card first so that there is no outstanding balance on the card
2. pay off the higher balance card first because it is accumulating more interest

Posted 5/21/10 10:08 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: Credit Card Balance Question

Pay whichever one has the higher interest rate, regardless of the size of the balance.

Message edited 2010-05-21 10:12:21.567000.

Posted 5/21/10 10:12 AM
 

Katareen
5,000 Posts!

Member since 4/10

7180 total posts

Name:
Katherine

Re: Credit Card Balance Question

There are 2 theories on this and you have to see what method works best for you and your family.

Some say to pay off the highest interest rate first, b/c obviously that one is costing you more in interest payments every month.

Others say to pay off the lowest balance card first, then as they're paid off you mentally feel accomplished that you're totally paying off your cards. Then once each is paid off, take whatever payment that was and apply it to the next lowest balance card, and so on...

Whatever method you choose--it is hard--but you can do it!! Chat Icon

Posted 5/21/10 10:13 AM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: Credit Card Balance Question

Posted by Katareen

Others say to pay off the lowest balance card first, then as they're paid off you mentally feel accomplished that you're totally paying off your cards. Then once each is paid off, take whatever payment that was and apply it to the next lowest balance card, and so on...





I will never understand this. Mentally feel accomplished? Ridiculous. Chat Icon

I mentally feel accomplished knowing I am paying down my CC debt as QUICKLY and as CHEAPLY as possible. You only do this by paying down the highest rate cards first.

Is somebody really going to pay down a $1000 balance (at 5.99%) before paying down a $5000 balance (at 23.99%).

Posted 5/21/10 10:15 AM
 

LadyBug1209
Mommy to FOUR little men!

Member since 8/08

9655 total posts

Name:

Re: Credit Card Balance Question

Suzy Orman says to pay off credit cards in the order of interest rate - highest to lowerst.

Posted 5/21/10 10:22 AM
 

CloudNine
My Baby Boy is Here!

Member since 2/09

2831 total posts

Name:
Jackie

Re: Credit Card Balance Question

Posted by ave1024

Posted by Katareen

Others say to pay off the lowest balance card first, then as they're paid off you mentally feel accomplished that you're totally paying off your cards. Then once each is paid off, take whatever payment that was and apply it to the next lowest balance card, and so on...





I will never understand this. Mentally feel accomplished? Ridiculous. Chat Icon

I mentally feel accomplished knowing I am paying down my CC debt as QUICKLY and as CHEAPLY as possible. You only do this by paying down the highest rate cards first.

Is somebody really going to pay down a $1000 balance (at 5.99%) before paying down a $5000 balance (at 23.99%).



i understand what she means. i mean sure on paper it doesnt make sense because its costing you more but sometimes people need to feel productive and need that to feel like they are making progress.

Posted 5/21/10 10:24 AM
 

Katareen
5,000 Posts!

Member since 4/10

7180 total posts

Name:
Katherine

Re: Credit Card Balance Question

Posted by ave1024

Posted by Katareen

Others say to pay off the lowest balance card first, then as they're paid off you mentally feel accomplished that you're totally paying off your cards. Then once each is paid off, take whatever payment that was and apply it to the next lowest balance card, and so on...





I will never understand this. Mentally feel accomplished? Ridiculous. Chat Icon

I mentally feel accomplished knowing I am paying down my CC debt as QUICKLY and as CHEAPLY as possible. You only do this by paying down the highest rate cards first.

Is somebody really going to pay down a $1000 balance (at 5.99%) before paying down a $5000 balance (at 23.99%).



I don't personally agree with this method either, but I can see it working for some. If I have 5 credit card balances and for one year I keep paying and paying...and at the end of the year I STILL have 5 credit card balances, I might feel like there is no end in sight and just give up.

But, if at the end of the year, I only have 3 credit card balances left, I might feel like I'm working towards an end.

Like I said, you have to choose what's right for you.

Posted 5/21/10 10:27 AM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: Credit Card Balance Question

Posted by ave1024

Posted by Katareen

Others say to pay off the lowest balance card first, then as they're paid off you mentally feel accomplished that you're totally paying off your cards. Then once each is paid off, take whatever payment that was and apply it to the next lowest balance card, and so on...





I will never understand this. Mentally feel accomplished? Ridiculous. Chat Icon

I mentally feel accomplished knowing I am paying down my CC debt as QUICKLY and as CHEAPLY as possible. You only do this by paying down the highest rate cards first.

Is somebody really going to pay down a $1000 balance (at 5.99%) before paying down a $5000 balance (at 23.99%).



This was actually the method that worked for me!! I was trying to pay off the highest % first and I felt like I was never going to be debt free. Once I started getting rid of the smaller balances - it really motivated me and I have been debt free for about 4-5 years now!

Posted 5/21/10 10:30 AM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: Credit Card Balance Question

Posted by Tilde

This was actually the method that worked for me!! I was trying to pay off the highest % first and I felt like I was never going to be debt free. Once I started getting rid of the smaller balances - it really motivated me and I have been debt free for about 4-5 years now!




That's because you can't treat your debt as individual, but as a total.

You should add up ALL your credit card debt, and as you make your payments just subtract the payment from the total.

If you need a "morale boost", at the end of each month, compare how much more debt you will have tacked on to each month to your total if you paid the highest interest rate card first vs. the lowest.

If you look at your debt as a total, and compare the savings of paying the highest interest rates first, you will feel more empowered.

Posted 5/21/10 11:16 AM
 

Cheeks24
Living a dream

Member since 1/08

8589 total posts

Name:
Cheeks

Re: Credit Card Balance Question

Posted by Maria31

Suzy Orman says to pay off credit cards in the order of interest rate - highest to lowerst.



What I was going to say!

Posted 5/21/10 11:21 AM
 

Christine
2nd verse same as the 1st

Member since 5/05

15287 total posts

Name:

Re: Credit Card Balance Question

Highest interest rate first! Google debt calculator spreadsheets and download one that will calculate your total interest payments if you pay in order of card balance or interest rate - the difference can be staggering depending on the balances you carry.

Posted 5/21/10 11:24 AM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: Credit Card Balance Question

Posted by ave1024

Posted by Tilde

This was actually the method that worked for me!! I was trying to pay off the highest % first and I felt like I was never going to be debt free. Once I started getting rid of the smaller balances - it really motivated me and I have been debt free for about 4-5 years now!




That's because you can't treat your debt as individual, but as a total.

You should add up ALL your credit card debt, and as you make your payments just subtract the payment from the total.

If you need a "morale boost", at the end of each month, compare how much more debt you will have tacked on to each month to your total if you paid the highest interest rate card first vs. the lowest.

If you look at your debt as a total, and compare the savings of paying the highest interest rates first, you will feel more empowered.



And you know what, if I just exercised and ate right I would get to my ideal weight. . .

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

There are lots of things my BRAIN knows all about, but the motivation isnt there - the "snowball" method has worked for MANY people.

Posted 5/21/10 12:16 PM
 

Superkat
More a stranger than a friend

Member since 5/06

9730 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Credit Card Balance Question

Higher interest rate first, always. You are going to accrue more debt, the longer you carry that higher balance.

Posted 5/21/10 12:18 PM
 

JenMarie
One day at a time

Member since 11/07

7397 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Credit Card Balance Question

Dave Ramsey's snowball method worked for me. Yes, many say paying off the highest interest rate is the "best" way. Maybe for some. But for me it was best to pay off the small balances and roll those payments into the larger balances.

Only you know your finances and what will work for you.

Posted 5/21/10 12:47 PM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Credit Card Balance Question

I much prefer the snowball method

pay the lowest balances first, pay the minimum to all others...once that low balance one is paid off, roll that payment into the next highest balance and so on

FOR ME, it works much better, I get more of a sense of accomplishment, etc

strictly financially speaking, it is better to pay the high interest rates first but I am doing the snowball and it works great for me Chat Icon

Posted 5/21/10 12:57 PM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Credit Card Balance Question

Posted by ave1024

Posted by Katareen

Others say to pay off the lowest balance card first, then as they're paid off you mentally feel accomplished that you're totally paying off your cards. Then once each is paid off, take whatever payment that was and apply it to the next lowest balance card, and so on...





I will never understand this. Mentally feel accomplished? Ridiculous. Chat Icon

I mentally feel accomplished knowing I am paying down my CC debt as QUICKLY and as CHEAPLY as possible. You only do this by paying down the highest rate cards first.

Is somebody really going to pay down a $1000 balance (at 5.99%) before paying down a $5000 balance (at 23.99%).



I do not think it is ridiculous at all, I think you should do what works for you and save the judgement

people need to do what works for THEM...not sure why you get so passionate about us "snowballers" Chat Icon

Posted 5/21/10 12:58 PM
 

tourist

Member since 5/05

10425 total posts

Name:

Re: Credit Card Balance Question

I agree with apying off the higher rate first, but if your rates are similar, then I would go with the snowball method if you find it helpful.

Obviously, in the example ave1024 posted, it makes a much bigger difference if you pay the higher one off first.

Message edited 2010-05-21 13:14:17.077000.

Posted 5/21/10 1:12 PM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: Credit Card Balance Question

Posted by pinkandblue

Posted by ave1024

Posted by Katareen

Others say to pay off the lowest balance card first, then as they're paid off you mentally feel accomplished that you're totally paying off your cards. Then once each is paid off, take whatever payment that was and apply it to the next lowest balance card, and so on...





I will never understand this. Mentally feel accomplished? Ridiculous. Chat Icon

I mentally feel accomplished knowing I am paying down my CC debt as QUICKLY and as CHEAPLY as possible. You only do this by paying down the highest rate cards first.

Is somebody really going to pay down a $1000 balance (at 5.99%) before paying down a $5000 balance (at 23.99%).



I do not think it is ridiculous at all, I think you should do what works for you and save the judgement

people need to do what works for THEM...not sure why you get so passionate about us "snowballers" Chat Icon



Original poster asked which is better

99.9% of finance/business peolple would say to pay off the debt that costs you the most in rates

Posted 5/21/10 1:46 PM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Credit Card Balance Question

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by pinkandblue

Posted by ave1024

Posted by Katareen

Others say to pay off the lowest balance card first, then as they're paid off you mentally feel accomplished that you're totally paying off your cards. Then once each is paid off, take whatever payment that was and apply it to the next lowest balance card, and so on...





I will never understand this. Mentally feel accomplished? Ridiculous. Chat Icon

I mentally feel accomplished knowing I am paying down my CC debt as QUICKLY and as CHEAPLY as possible. You only do this by paying down the highest rate cards first.

Is somebody really going to pay down a $1000 balance (at 5.99%) before paying down a $5000 balance (at 23.99%).



I do not think it is ridiculous at all, I think you should do what works for you and save the judgement

people need to do what works for THEM...not sure why you get so passionate about us "snowballers" Chat Icon



Original poster asked which is better

99.9% of finance/business peolple would say to pay off the debt that costs you the most in rates




I understand that it makes more financial sense to do it that way but it is not the only way and people who have luck with the snowball plan (like ME) are not stupid or "ridiculous" for doing it that way

there is more than ONE way to pay down debt, that is my point

do what works for you

with the snowball plan, I have paid off EIGHT bills totally. THAT gives me motivation. If I were to take that same 5k that I used to pay down ONE bill, mentally, I would not feel as good

maybe I am nuts, who knows Chat Icon

Posted 5/21/10 1:52 PM
 

CkGm
They get so big, so fast :(

Member since 5/05

13848 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: Credit Card Balance Question

Pay off the higher interest card first- in fact, transfer the balance to the lower interest card if possible.

Posted 5/21/10 2:21 PM
 

debsabourin13
LIF Toddler

Member since 4/10

465 total posts

Name:
Debra

Re: Credit Card Balance Question

Posted by ave1024

Posted by Katareen

Others say to pay off the lowest balance card first, then as they're paid off you mentally feel accomplished that you're totally paying off your cards. Then once each is paid off, take whatever payment that was and apply it to the next lowest balance card, and so on...





I will never understand this. Mentally feel accomplished? Ridiculous. Chat Icon

I mentally feel accomplished knowing I am paying down my CC debt as QUICKLY and as CHEAPLY as possible. You only do this by paying down the highest rate cards first.

Is somebody really going to pay down a $1000 balance (at 5.99%) before paying down a $5000 balance (at 23.99%).



Sorry it seems ridiculous to you, but thats what I am doing and I will actually be done paying off 3 cards this year, out of 5 by doing it this way. They may not be the ones with the highest interest rate, but this way, my available credit goes up, my debt still goes down and with the boost in my credit score from available credit I can now call the higher interest cards and bargain about the interest rate. Plus, I am a very visual person - every one is different, being able to see that I went from having $13,000 dollars in debt to $8,000 in debt in 6 months really helps me stay motivated.

Posted 5/21/10 6:53 PM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Credit Card Balance Question

Posted by ave1024

Pay whichever one has the higher interest rate, regardless of the size of the balance.



ITA

Posted 5/21/10 11:01 PM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Credit Card Balance Question

Posted by debsabourin13

Posted by ave1024

Posted by Katareen

Others say to pay off the lowest balance card first, then as they're paid off you mentally feel accomplished that you're totally paying off your cards. Then once each is paid off, take whatever payment that was and apply it to the next lowest balance card, and so on...





I will never understand this. Mentally feel accomplished? Ridiculous. Chat Icon

I mentally feel accomplished knowing I am paying down my CC debt as QUICKLY and as CHEAPLY as possible. You only do this by paying down the highest rate cards first.

Is somebody really going to pay down a $1000 balance (at 5.99%) before paying down a $5000 balance (at 23.99%).



Sorry it seems ridiculous to you, but thats what I am doing and I will actually be done paying off 3 cards this year, out of 5 by doing it this way. They may not be the ones with the highest interest rate, but this way, my available credit goes up, my debt still goes down and with the boost in my credit score from available credit I can now call the higher interest cards and bargain about the interest rate. Plus, I am a very visual person - every one is different, being able to see that I went from having $13,000 dollars in debt to $8,000 in debt in 6 months really helps me stay motivated.



Youd still have paid off just as much debt if you paid it on the higher interest rate card, and you'd pay it off faster. I think Suze Orman has a calculator on her website about how much you save by paying the highest interest rate first, then applying that payment to the lwoer interest rates as time goes on.

I know what you mean though. I am always so tempted to pay down smaller bills, or my student loan, but I have to resist.

Actually, the best thing is to pay the minimum only on the lower rate cards and then apply ALL of the extra to the higher rate cards, but I can't mentally handle paying the mionimu, so I always pay a little more.

I guess we're all a little ridiculous Chat Icon

Posted 5/21/10 11:04 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: Credit Card Balance Question

Posted by debsabourin13

Sorry it seems ridiculous to you, but thats what I am doing and I will actually be done paying off 3 cards this year, out of 5 by doing it this way. They may not be the ones with the highest interest rate, but this way, my available credit goes up, my debt still goes down and with the boost in my credit score from available credit I can now call the higher interest cards and bargain about the interest rate. Plus, I am a very visual person - every one is different, being able to see that I went from having $13,000 dollars in debt to $8,000 in debt in 6 months really helps me stay motivated.




I am curious but what does paying down the smaller balance cards have to do with raising your credit score?

And why do you care about available credit going up? Surely you don't intend on charging MORE on your CCs when you are paying down debt. So why care about available credit?

There is only one way to really raise your credit score.... NOT HAVE DEBT! Chat Icon

If you want to drive from point A to point B, you typically want to take the fastest way possible. Thats why I think it's ridiculous to not take the fastest way possible in paying down debt. If you aren't going all-out... why bother?

You said you paid down three credit cards? Thats great! You could have paid down MORE debt by paying down the higher rate card first.

There is a reason why AnnoyedTTCer said 99.8% of financial EXPERTS say pay down the highest rate cards first.

In fact I can only think of one incredibly mis-guided financial "expert" that doesn't agree with this. And he cares more about church and morals (and selling books) than giving out ACCURATE financial advice.

Kudos to everyone who took the scenic route for paying down your debt. I applaud you because it sux to have debt. I once had a lot of debt when I was young and stupid so I know what it is like.

I get it... how you want to pay it down is your choice. Different strokes for different folks I suppose. Chat Icon

Posted 5/21/10 11:18 PM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Credit Card Balance Question

Posted by ave1024

Posted by debsabourin13

Sorry it seems ridiculous to you, but thats what I am doing and I will actually be done paying off 3 cards this year, out of 5 by doing it this way. They may not be the ones with the highest interest rate, but this way, my available credit goes up, my debt still goes down and with the boost in my credit score from available credit I can now call the higher interest cards and bargain about the interest rate. Plus, I am a very visual person - every one is different, being able to see that I went from having $13,000 dollars in debt to $8,000 in debt in 6 months really helps me stay motivated.




I am curious but what does paying down the smaller balance cards have to do with raising your credit score?

And why do you care about available credit going up? Surely you don't intend on charging MORE on your CCs when you are paying down debt. So why care about available credit?

There is only one way to really raise your credit score.... NOT HAVE DEBT! Chat Icon

If you want to drive from point A to point B, you typically want to take the fastest way possible. Thats why I think it's ridiculous to not take the fastest way possible in paying down debt. If you aren't going all-out... why bother?

You said you paid down three credit cards? Thats great! You could have paid down MORE debt by paying down the higher rate card first.

There is a reason why AnnoyedTTCer said 99.8% of financial EXPERTS say pay down the highest rate cards first.

In fact I can only think of one incredibly mis-guided financial "expert" that doesn't agree with this. And he cares more about church and morals (and selling books) than giving out ACCURATE financial advice.

Kudos to everyone who took the scenic route for paying down your debt. I applaud you because it sux to have debt. I once had a lot of debt when I was young and stupid so I know what it is like.

I get it... how you want to pay it down is your choice. Different strokes for different folks I suppose. Chat Icon



it definitely does not make sense to pay it down any other way than highest interest rate first

Posted 5/21/10 11:35 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
What is the lowest balance transfer fee for a credit card? metsgirlie 3/12/08 6 Families Helping Families ™
Credit Card Balance Transfer Question NewlyMrs 12/10/07 8 Families Helping Families ™
credit card question (annualfee) luvsbob4603 4/8/06 18 Families Helping Families ™
Another credit card question-What would you do? MissJones 3/12/06 5 Families Helping Families ™
Credit Card Question? chris605 3/7/06 3 Families Helping Families ™
I have a question about credit card fraud LauderLady 12/30/05 5 Families Helping Families ™