Crate? yes or no

Posted By Message

mrsh2010
To travel is to live.

Member since 7/09

1679 total posts

Name:
Celia

Crate? yes or no

DH and i will be getting our puppy sometime this summer. I am doing alot of reading and research on training a puppy while both of us work. Everything I have read have mentioned crates. When i brought that up to DH he said no way! He is afraid that a crated dog will be eventually become mean. Is it possible to train a puppy without a crate while we work? Dh is able to sometimes come home for lunch but not all the time.

I am starting to panic and my puppy isnt even here yet!

Posted 3/14/11 9:02 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

RadioLau
LIF Adult

Member since 4/07

2179 total posts

Name:
Laura

Re: Crate? yes or no

I am not sure where your DH is getting his information from but crate training a puppy does not make them mean. It teaches a puppy about where and when to potty as well as keeps them and your house safe while you aren't home. Dogs are den animals and a crate helps them to feel safe and secure. If you choose not to use a crate that is your choice but make sure your choice is based on informed decisions. You can section off your kitchen and keep the puppy in there. He/she will have accidents in the beginning until they learn about the right places to potty. A small puppy also cannot physically hold their bowels for a full work day.

Posted 3/14/11 9:08 AM
 

mrsh2010
To travel is to live.

Member since 7/09

1679 total posts

Name:
Celia

Re: Crate? yes or no

He said that an aunt of his crated her dog when he was a kid and that it was mean. I told him maybe thats why she kept it in a crate when you came over. He want to section off the kitchen and keep the puppy in there. I have no problems with that because that is how my mom always trained our dogs but I just needed some other opinions about crates.
Thank you

Posted 3/14/11 9:14 AM
 

wo0shply
LIF Adult

Member since 11/08

2702 total posts

Name:
Tass

Re: Crate? yes or no

When i got my first puppy I sectioned off the kitchen and put down news paper, I found that my pup was able to be paper trained but he had a hard time going outside. I did a lot of research and found crate training was very effective. So we got a crate for him and he was hesitant to go in but when I got in the crate he felt more comfortable and laid with me for a bit (he was a very large dog).

He was house broken in a week and whenever something scared him, when he knew he did something wrong or if it was bed time he knew to go in his crate. We never used the crate as punishment and never pushed my dog into the crate. We would just say Buddy go to your room and he would walk calmly into the crate and lay down.

I dont think a crate make a dog aggressive, but the way you use the crate can cause fear in a dog. If you do decide to crate train you puppy, never push them into the crate, slam the door and thing like that, they will associate negative with the crate and that may cause behavioral problems.

Posted 3/14/11 9:54 AM
 

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: Crate? yes or no

We've done it both ways. When I was younger, we had a dog that we would put sectioned off in the kitchen during the day. But honestly, it's the VERY same concept as crate training.

My dog personally LOVES her crate. She hung out in there all day yesterday napping even though the door to the crate was wide open. When I come home from work, she runs to her crate and waits for me to take my coat off then I come pet her, she comes in from our walks and runs to the crate and waits to be fed. It's amazing how much she loves it and she doesn't not have a mean bone in her body! I also know when she does something bad because she runs to the crate and "punishes" herself. Chat Icon Makes it easier for me.

The key I think with crate training is to make it your dog's home. Give them blankets and toys in there but make sure the crate isn't huge if your dog is small- otherwise they'll poop and pee in the back of the crate. You can always buy a bigger crate and section it off when he/she's a pup so the crate will basically grow with your puppy.

The other thing I think is a HUGE deal is you really shouldn't touch them or discipline them while they are in their crate. Their crate is their home, their safe place. Once their in the crate and the door is shut, that's their punishment. And that's it.

And eventually, you may come to find a crate isn't necessary. I've left Lucy out the past couple of days to see how well she'd do and she was a perfect angel! But for the puppy years, I think the crate is a must! Good luck Celia and if you ever have any questions, ask away! Chat Icon

Posted 3/14/11 9:56 AM
 

dctead
It's 5 o'clock somewhere!

Member since 11/10

2139 total posts

Name:
Emily

Re: Crate? yes or no

I've crate trained 4 of my dogs and honestly, in the puppy stages - there's no other way I would have it!!

My mom always sectioned off part of the kitchen when we had puppies as a kid, and that did work... so if that is something you both can agree on, then go for it.

But I found it's easier to house break the dogs with a crate as well. Two of my dogs loved their crates... we'd be home, crate doors open and they'd walk in there to sleep (as dogs are den animals...some feel very comforted by the crate). My current two didn't do that, they just went in the crates when we were leaving the house.

Keep in mind that Crates don't have to be a permanent thing - my current two were crate trained for only about a year - through the house breaking stages until we could trust them not to chew the house!

Feel free to FM me if you have any questions... I'm not an 'expert'..but with 30 years of dog experience... I can tell you stories!! Chat Icon

Posted 3/14/11 9:56 AM
 

Megs4
LIF Adult

Member since 11/08

1619 total posts

Name:
Megan

Re: Crate? yes or no

If used as a proper training tool, a crate will not make a dog aggressive. My family dog was crate trained (we got him as a puppy) and he did great with it. I adopted an adult dog who was not crated by her foster home so we did not get a crate for her, and she does great anyway.

I suggest you read up on crate training and puppy raising and see what you think would work best for you. Good luck!

Posted 3/14/11 9:57 AM
 

mrsh2010
To travel is to live.

Member since 7/09

1679 total posts

Name:
Celia

Re: Crate? yes or no

Thank you all. Tonight I will have Jerry read all your comments and talk about it some more

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 3/14/11 10:07 AM
 

MillerTime424
LIF Adolescent

Member since 7/09

737 total posts

Name:
Colleen

Re: Crate? yes or no

Our dog Jake was crated from the day we brought him home up until 6 months. then he got free range of the house, and has slowly destroyed our house. so we have gated him in our kitchen and have a crate with the door open. Jake sleeps in the crate plays in the crate...etc. we have YET once had to lock him in the crate for being bad.

Posted 3/14/11 12:17 PM
 

JessInCA
live laugh love

Member since 8/06

5082 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: Crate? yes or no

We did not crate our puppies, so yes, you can absolutely train them without a crate - but we DID gate off the kitchen so they were on a tile floor (easy to clean just in case), and we got them a doggie door and taught them to use it to go out (goes to our fenced backyard), and we expected accidents the first few weeks. They took to it really easily, so we never needed to consider a crate.

That said, I know many people who have happy, healthy and well-adjusted dogs who have been crated. Crating does not automatically make a dog mean Chat Icon

Posted 3/14/11 1:15 PM
 

Nic27
LIF Zygote

Member since 3/11

41 total posts

Name:

Re: Crate? yes or no

My DH and I crate trained our dog from day 1 and he loves his crate. majority of the time he goes into his crate on his own to play and sleep.

Posted 3/14/11 1:58 PM
 

lucyloo
nope

Member since 1/06

9758 total posts

Name:

Re: Crate? yes or no

Our dog is 5 and loves her crate. She likes to go in there and sleep, despite having 5 beds throughout the house. It is her safety zone.
She was confined to it when we weren't home and she wasn't housebroken.

Posted 3/14/11 3:40 PM
 

Diana712
RIP my beloved Brother Richard

Member since 5/07

6710 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Crate? yes or no

YES YES YES YES YES YES YES .. Oh and Yes def invest in the crate!!! Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 3/14/11 6:45 PM
 

drwifettc
LIF Adult

Member since 6/10

2348 total posts

Name:

Re: Crate? yes or no

Total yes for us. We crate trained our lab from the beginning and she is one happy dog, not a mean bone in her body so I really doubt crate training a dog makes them mean. The crate is her safety zone and she keeps all her toys in there. She's a year now so I don't always keep her in her crate when we go out, but for some reason she gets more anxious if we leave her and she's not in her crate, she barks and whines at the door.

ETA: We don't punish her by putting her in her crate, if she does something bad (i.e. steal from the garbage) We punish her right there and then let it go. We wanted the crate to be her safe happy place, not a place she goes when she is bad.

Message edited 2011-03-15 13:29:59.933000.

Posted 3/15/11 1:27 PM
 

Lina
My angel is finally here

Member since 5/10

2559 total posts

Name:
Lindsay

Re: Crate? yes or no

Crate is a def yes IMO. Dh parents breed national and Canadian champion dogs and they have alway crate trained their dogs w no issue. I have also crate trained both my dogs and they actually love their crates, they even go in them on their own to nap. My best advice is to make sure you divide the crate so that it is just small enough that they can turn around and lay down. You don't want to give them enough room that they can go in one end to do their biz and then go lay in the other, at least while you are still training them. Most crates will come with a partition which will allow you to move it as the dog grows and once it's trained you can remove it completely. I would advise against newspaper training as well, it's just one more step. No need to train them to go on paper and then train them to go outside, it's just confusing for them. Good luck and have fun w the pup!

Posted 3/15/11 7:56 PM
 

Lina
My angel is finally here

Member since 5/10

2559 total posts

Name:
Lindsay

Re: Crate? yes or no

One more thing, just make sure you don't use their crate as a place they go when you are punishing them. You want this to be a safe place for them.

Posted 3/15/11 7:58 PM
 

danielle3203
LIF Adult

Member since 8/10

1446 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: Crate? yes or no

we have crated everyone of our dogs ever since i was little, and not one of them is mean. i think the crate is the way to go. make them feel like its their home and they like it, make it their safe place and you will have no problems.

Posted 3/15/11 9:16 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Those of you who crate their dogs...a question. mrswask 7/2/07 14 Pets
crate training... how long would you continue? aliwnec10 5/6/07 18 Pets
UPDATE: remind me why you should crate train? VENT aliwnec10 3/20/07 43 Pets
Any pics of crate and barrel or pottery barn style in their own homes? SeptBride 12/31/06 0 Home
Where on LI is there a Crate and Barrel? Alli06 12/26/06 4 Families Helping Families ™
Meh! Katie's two licks away from sleeping across the apartment in her crate VirginiaDeb 8/24/06 0 Pets