| Posted By |
Message |
usuk2004
I'm ONE!
 Member since 5/05 5150 total posts
Name: Farah
|
Could use some advice - talking about hitting
Hi guys:
My little guy is 2 and usually pretty good, but we do have the normal toddler skirmishes at playdates. He always gets reprimanded if he does something to another child and if I feel it's particularly agressive, he'll get a time out. He's very good about time out, does his time without trying to escape too much, maybe some yelling/crying, but then when I get him out, I explain why he was in there, ask him if he understands the rules (no hitting!) and then he gives me a hug and apologizes to the other kid. So we don't have any problems with disciplining on the spot.
But, lately, at night when I'm putting him to bed or at another particularly quiet time, he'll talk about the hitting. "Mommy, Tristan hit Sally" and I'll say yes, I know you hit, Sally, that wasn't very nice, we don't hit other people, etc. Basically reinforcing the rules, but not reprimanding him again, because he's already been disciplined for it. But then he won't let it drop, he keeps talking about it, bringing it up days later, and more recently saying he's hit other children when I know he hasn't - sometimes even the younger siblings of his playmates (ie Tristan hit Baby Alice, etc).
So, I'm just not sure what to say to him anymore. Do I continue as I've been doing? I think it may be an attention thing that he keeps bringing the hitting up. I've tried to ignore it, but I'm sure as most of you know, there's no ignoring a toddler when they want to tell you something!
Any advice is much appreciated, thanks!
|
Posted 9/4/11 10:09 AM
|
| |
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
|
headoverheels
s'il vous plaît
 Member since 6/07 42079 total posts
Name: LB
|
Re: Could use some advice - talking about hitting
You know, my son does this a lot too, but he's usually talking about it in reference to the punishment he received (time out, no books, etc).
Any time he brings it up we discuss how hitting isn't nice, it hurts people, how we play nicely, hands are for hugs and high fives, stuff like that. I try not to ignore his apparent obsession when it arises because I don't want to give him the impression that it isn't important to me or I don't care about him hitting (not saying you are doing this, just giving my own reasons why )
I'm not a teacher or a child psychologist but him bringing it up constantly seems to show that he is starting to understand empathy - he knows that what he did to Sally affected her somehow (and him as well) and he wants to talk about it. I say keep talking about it in addition to reinforcing good behavior, but then again, I am new at this too
|
Posted 9/4/11 1:02 PM
|
| |
|
usuk2004
I'm ONE!
 Member since 5/05 5150 total posts
Name: Farah
|
Re: Could use some advice - talking about hitting
Thanks, LB. I guess I was trying to ignore it for a bit because I was worried that I was giving too much attention to it by letting him engage me about it, you know? And also because I felt I had already tried to talk about it, but that wasn't "helping" the situation either, KWIM? Another "technique" maybe
But I suppose what we're doing now might be the best for the long term - and hopefully discouraging the hitting? I hope!
|
Posted 9/4/11 4:13 PM
|
| |
|
mommyIam
 Member since 7/09 9209 total posts
Name: Shana
|
Re: Could use some advice - talking about hitting
since you wont let him hit to express himself by hitting, and he has no other outlet, that he knows of to express himself, so my guess is that he's bringing it up to try to figure this out
Have you tried to ask him, why he hit, was he upset? Did another child do something? Did a parent do something? Maybe he wants to discuss the situation that lead up to it, and maybe he wants another way to resolve it, without hitting.
Just throwing out some ideas...
|
Posted 9/4/11 11:42 PM
|
| |
|
BnBdreamin
Gonna be a BIG Bro in April!
 Member since 10/06 5913 total posts
Name: Denise
|
Re: Could use some advice - talking about hitting
This is what I do, as I have similar situations with DS.
I do carry on the discussion that he's engaged briefly then casually redirect conversation away from the topic of hitting.
I personally do this because I think he's still a little young to fully understand why he's hitting or really that he's hitting on purpose. It's kind of like if I'd swat at a fly in my personal space because it was bugging me. Sometimes, I can tolerate a fly buzzing around my head until it decides to buzz off. Other times I have to squash it to say leave me alone, I'm not in the mood! It looks to be natural reflex if someone takes his toy. Understandable. In the grand scheme of what a toy is to a child, if you take my car without my offering or asking nicely, I'm going to hit you! Of course I do not want him doing it and get involved.
What I've noticed.... he does the hitting (and it's not pummeling) when he's in need of a nap or hungry so I try to be more aware and involved in his playing while on the cusp of those situations.
He does not hit kids bigger than he is. He takes "no hitting" dicsipline better from the other parent than me. So it's helpful if your friends are on board to work with this phase together.
I do my best to discipline him in the moment and redirect. If I dwell on it too much, the hitting continues or he gets too upset to know what it was even about anymore. But really, I do my best to watch his cues of being ready for a nap or meal and he'll play great.
I also occassionaly will let him watch the Yo Gabba Gabba no hitting episode, I think it's the "play" one. It does help.
|
Posted 9/5/11 12:29 AM
|
| |
|