Commuting on LIRR stress

Posted By Message

DrMeg
Back home!

Member since 5/08

1858 total posts

Name:
Meg

Commuting on LIRR stress

I don't get why people are so rude and inconsiderate on the train. And because it happens so often I wonder if I expect too much of people.
Earlier this week a girl who sat behind DH and I on the morning train was on her phone from the time she got on in Lindenhurst till she got cut off in the East river tunnel. No amount of stink eye from me, or loud comments to DH could shut her up.
Then tonight I get on the train and sit in a 3 seater (at the window). Guy sits down in the aisle seat. He's on the phone the whole time we are waiting to leave Penn and was on the phone well past Jamaica. I finally gave him the stink eye, sighed loudly, and when he looked at me began shaking my head (it was apparent I was trying to read). So he says to the person on the phone "I have to go, my neighbor is getting annoyed with me" I guess the person on the other end asked if he was being loud and he was like "no I am talking as low as I can, but people can get sensitive". I didn't open my mouth because I probably would have started cursing him out and I think he thought he was being cute. After he got off the phone he put his ipod on loud enough for the whole train to hear.

I mean I understand taking a quick call, I have done it before. But there is no reason to be on the phone for a half hour plus, and expect people to be OK with it. Am I wrong? Next time should I ask them to move? (which on a crowded train isn't gonna happen). I know I shouldn't let it annoy me, but the incident tonight made me so mad I must have read the same paragraph at least 10 times.
I need to find a way to de-stress on the train. Or maybe I just need some ear plugs.

Posted 4/9/10 10:34 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Commuting on LIRR stress

I used to commute on LIRR and people on the phone would drive me so insane. I'd make all kinds of comments and didn't care even though DH (who commuted with me) would tell me to shut up.

When I was 7 months pregnant with twins, no one gave me any kind of accommodation at all. They'd push right by me so they could get a seat and then stare right through my huge belly like it wasn't there.

I swear the rudest of the rude commute on the LIRR.

Posted 4/9/10 10:37 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Commuting on LIRR stress

That kind of thing only annoys me in the morning when I'm trying to sleep.

Instead of giving him the stink eye, why not ask him to go in the vestibule?

or you can do what I did one morning.

I emailed the guy's boss (he mentioned the president of his company to the guy was talking to), and asked him to tell his employee to be quiet on the trains or move to the vestibule - then to prove it wasn't bs, I added his user name & password that he gave over the phone.Chat Icon

Posted 4/9/10 10:38 PM
 

LightUpOurLife
Totally in love

Member since 8/06

12785 total posts

Name:
Bonnie-Jean

Re: Commuting on LIRR stress

Posted by nrthshgrl
or you can do what I did one morning.

I emailed the guy's boss (he mentioned the president of his company to the guy was talking to), and asked him to tell his employee to be quiet on the trains or move to the vestibule - then to prove it wasn't bs, I added his user name & password that he gave over the phone.Chat Icon



OMG, I Chat Icon you.

The eye rolling feels great to you, but they just don't care. I agree with Barb, if you ask them nicely to just go away to the vestibule or be quiet, it gets more results.
Another one I LOVE is to do the loud librarian SHHHHHHHHHH. I usually try that first and it works most of the time. DH takes the train more regularly and he saw me do that once. He thought I was bonkers, but you know what? IT WORKED. He does it now too. Chat Icon
I started wearing my iPod too with noise cancelling earbuds. I play slow beach/wave kinds of sounds. I can read or fall asleep with that.

Posted 4/9/10 11:00 PM
 

Christine
2nd verse same as the 1st

Member since 5/05

15287 total posts

Name:

Re: Commuting on LIRR stress

I don't know why people are rude or inconsiderate. We are all in the same boat commuting to work and I see no need to make it worse for other people.

Since there's absolutely nothing I can do to change what other people do - I changed how I react to it. I wasted too much energy being annoyed by things I can't control. I have been taking the same trains for 10+ years, I know where the big groups of talkers sit so I avoid those cars. When it gets too loud - I'll switch seats, go stand in the vestibule, wear ear cancelling ear buds, or just sit there and rest my eyes/look out the window - what ever it takes to make the trip more bearable.

Posted 4/10/10 7:55 AM
 

architectnycity
LIF Adult

Member since 1/06

2592 total posts

Name:

Re: Commuting on LIRR stress

When i commuted I hated the "groups" who sit in the five seaters and were excessively loud. It is annoying to have people on the phone but if people are allowed to talk on the train what difference does it make if they are on a phone or not.

Posted 4/10/10 9:12 AM
 

Peainapod
Peanuts are here!

Member since 1/09

13591 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Commuting on LIRR stress

I commute via NJ transit and i swear..one day it will drive me to kill someone. I always get stuck behind someone or next to that is so self involved and clueless and no amount of sighing or asking to shut up does anything.

people are just so into themselves and their gadgets these days that common courtesy is lost.

Posted 4/10/10 9:55 AM
 

Katareen
5,000 Posts!

Member since 4/10

7180 total posts

Name:
Katherine

Re: Commuting on LIRR stress

I don't so much mind the phone users, as long as they're speaking in a normal volume and not talking about things that shouldn't be discussed in public. IMO, what's the difference between being on the phone and having a conversation with the person next to you? I agree people should be respectful, but its part of the price you pay for taking public transportation.

Obviously, there are obnoxious people out there, but for some people this is their down time to catch up on calls with parents, friends, or make arrangements, appointments, etc.

Posted 4/10/10 10:05 AM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: Commuting on LIRR stress

I'm with you. The loud ipod folks are the bane of my existence.

I sat near 4 people blasting their ipods. It was a concert except they were all playing different tunes of course.

Then one guy decided he wanted to whistle to his song.

Really?

If I owned a gun....

The cell phone talkers don't bother me unless it's a long involved conversation and loud.

I have asked people to step into the vestibule. You know what? They fight me on it. So I take out my phone and take pictures of them and then record their conversation.

I'm going to write that book.

I have pictures and recordings of the most ridiculous stuff.

I wear ear plugs now. Never leave home without them.

Last week the ipod concert was accompanied by the woman who fell asleep on me.

Posted 4/10/10 10:24 AM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Commuting on LIRR stress

I don't work in the city anymore, so I rarely take the LIRR anymore (a few times a year for meetings and such).

I don't miss those days though. People eating greasy, smelly food next to me, the cell phones, loud ipods, loud guys drinking beer and being obnoxious........

The only thing I miss about riding the LIRR was the opportunity to read a book a week. Now I am lucky if I can finish a book every few months!

Posted 4/10/10 11:27 AM
 

Melimaup
love lockdown

Member since 11/07

1509 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Commuting on LIRR stress

These stories are a few of the many reasons why I HATE the LIRR and now drive into the city. It's amazing how many people don't have consideration for others Chat Icon

Posted 4/10/10 11:51 AM
 

maybesoon
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

5981 total posts

Name:

Re: Commuting on LIRR stress

it's public transportation so I don't expect it to be quiet. ppl are allowed to talk on their phones or whatever else. I keep my ipod on to drown out noise.
the thing that kills me is the pushing and shoving that goes on to get into the trains. are we cattle??!!! Feet on the seats? yuck! throwing garbage on the floor and not picking it up, that's what gets to me.

Posted 4/10/10 12:20 PM
 

DrMeg
Back home!

Member since 5/08

1858 total posts

Name:
Meg

Re: Commuting on LIRR stress

I don't expect the train to be completely quite but I also don't want to listen to someone talking about their most recent dr's appt and such for over a half hour.

Posted 4/10/10 12:37 PM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Commuting on LIRR stress

Posted by Katareen

I don't so much mind the phone users, as long as they're speaking in a normal volume and not talking about things that shouldn't be discussed in public. IMO, what's the difference between being on the phone and having a conversation with the person next to you? I agree people should be respectful, but its part of the price you pay for taking public transportation.

Obviously, there are obnoxious people out there, but for some people this is their down time to catch up on calls with parents, friends, or make arrangements, appointments, etc.



ITA-then again I never commuted daily...but like the poster above said-what is the difference between a phone convo and an in person one. I would probably tell someone off if they talked to me about talking on the phone

Posted 4/10/10 1:29 PM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: Commuting on LIRR stress

Posted by SweetTooth

I used to commute on LIRR and people on the phone would drive me so insane. I'd make all kinds of comments and didn't care even though DH (who commuted with me) would tell me to shut up.

When I was 7 months pregnant with twins, no one gave me any kind of accommodation at all. They'd push right by me so they could get a seat and then stare right through my huge belly like it wasn't there.

I swear the rudest of the rude commute on the LIRR.



Slightly OT, but my former neighbor was on the news last night because she got a ticket for walking between subway cars. The train was stopped, she 8 mos. pregnant and no one wanted to get up for her.

I ride Metro North and in a way I am glad I ride such an early train (5:51) because I am about one of the only people who is awake. Chat Icon I get a lot of work done. A few weeks ago, a woman was talking really loudly and she and this guy got into a screaming fight. I felt a little badly for her but come on, you see that nearly EVERYONE around you is asleep (it's almost comical, and it seems that 90% of the riders are men) so keep it down.

Posted 4/10/10 3:12 PM
 

seaside
LIF Adult

Member since 6/08

3101 total posts

Name:

Re: Commuting on LIRR stress

Posted by DRMom

Posted by Katareen

I don't so much mind the phone users, as long as they're speaking in a normal volume and not talking about things that shouldn't be discussed in public. IMO, what's the difference between being on the phone and having a conversation with the person next to you? I agree people should be respectful, but its part of the price you pay for taking public transportation.

Obviously, there are obnoxious people out there, but for some people this is their down time to catch up on calls with parents, friends, or make arrangements, appointments, etc.



ITA-then again I never commuted daily...but like the poster above said-what is the difference between a phone convo and an in person one. I would probably tell someone off if they talked to me about talking on the phone



ITA as well. I don't use my cell phone unless it's an emergency usually, but if I wanted to talk on the LIRR, Id never let someone who felt entitled to silence me on public transportation do so. I'm the first to follow a no talking rule---movies, shows, etc., but DO NOT invade my privacy by looking at the medium through which I'm speaking if I am allowed to speak.

I once overheard a woman calmly tell a man who told her (screaming) to get off the phone "I'm allowed to speak--same as you are. If my husband were with me, we'd be allowed to speak. But he's home recovering from a heart attack, and I'll exercise my right to talk to him as much as I want to. Hire a driver if you don't like it!"

I was loving her.

Posted 4/10/10 3:57 PM
 

KittyGags
LIF Adult

Member since 7/09

5614 total posts

Name:

Re: Commuting on LIRR stress

The LIRR NEEEEEEEEEEEEEDS quiet cars. These would also exclude IPOD blasters, similar to Amtrak.

As far as the chatty people, there is a group of 5 women who SCREAM in the morning, but act like they're in a bar on a Saturday night and I want to bludgeon them to death. Instead I run to the other side of the train.

I'm sorry, my best advice is put on an ipod or move seats.

Posted 4/10/10 4:40 PM
 

Christine
2nd verse same as the 1st

Member since 5/05

15287 total posts

Name:

Re: Commuting on LIRR stress

Posted by KittyGags

The LIRR NEEEEEEEEEEEEEDS quiet cars. These would also exclude IPOD blasters, similar to Amtrak.



I suggested this to them and the response was that "the overwhelming majority of riders want to be able to use their phones and/or talk."

Posted 4/10/10 4:47 PM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Commuting on LIRR stress

As much as I TRY to take it all in stride, commuting on the LIRR is draining. It's difficult NOT to be annoyed by so many different things. I find myself being especially annoyed by the loud chewers. Chat Icon

I find venting here to be therapeutic... but man, it's hard NOT to do the heavy sigh and eye roll when someone's just crazy annoying.

Posted 4/10/10 4:48 PM
 

KittyGags
LIF Adult

Member since 7/09

5614 total posts

Name:

Re: Commuting on LIRR stress

Posted by Christine

Posted by KittyGags

The LIRR NEEEEEEEEEEEEEDS quiet cars. These would also exclude IPOD blasters, similar to Amtrak.



I suggested this to them and the response was that "the overwhelming majority of riders want to be able to use their phones and/or talk."



Great then THEY can sit in the "loud cars" and Ill sit in a quiet car! WTH?

ETA I can't remember the last time I took a phone call on the train. It was probably when I was wedding planning...

Message edited 2010-04-10 17:05:48.697000.

Posted 4/10/10 5:03 PM
 

ali120206
2 Boys

Member since 7/06

17796 total posts

Name:

Re: Commuting on LIRR stress

Posted by Christine

I don't know why people are rude or inconsiderate. We are all in the same boat commuting to work and I see no need to make it worse for other people.

Since there's absolutely nothing I can do to change what other people do - I changed how I react to it. I wasted too much energy being annoyed by things I can't control. I have been taking the same trains for 10+ years, I know where the big groups of talkers sit so I avoid those cars. When it gets too loud - I'll switch seats, go stand in the vestibule, wear ear cancelling ear buds, or just sit there and rest my eyes/look out the window - what ever it takes to make the trip more bearable.



I try to do the same thing but, sometimes I still let it get to me - I really don't need to hear your conversation if we are sitting 6 rows apart!

Posted 4/10/10 5:06 PM
 

OStewarts
LIF Adult

Member since 11/07

1096 total posts

Name:

Re: Commuting on LIRR stress

I dont mind it so much during the evening commute but I find it really annoying during the morning commute in to the city. I really wish they had quite cars.

Posted 4/11/10 3:22 AM
 

lilacwine
only love...

Member since 5/05

2034 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Commuting on LIRR stress

Posted by nrthshgrl

That kind of thing only annoys me in the morning when I'm trying to sleep.

Instead of giving him the stink eye, why not ask him to go in the vestibule?

or you can do what I did one morning.

I emailed the guy's boss (he mentioned the president of his company to the guy was talking to), and asked him to tell his employee to be quiet on the trains or move to the vestibule - then to prove it wasn't bs, I added his user name & password that he gave over the phone.Chat Icon



good one!

I like to tweet pertinent details of the phone call. LOVE it when people say their names and phone numbers.

There's a big difference between a whispered "hihoneyi'monthe701willyoulighttheovenwhatsinthemail" and 15 minutes of loud BS.

The LIRR makes announcements to remind people to talk softly and move to the vestibule when on the phone.

Posted 4/11/10 8:00 AM
 

lilacwine
only love...

Member since 5/05

2034 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Commuting on LIRR stress

Posted by KittyGags

As far as the chatty people, there is a group of 5 women who SCREAM in the morning, but act like they're in a bar on a Saturday night and I want to bludgeon them to death.






Chat Icon

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 4/11/10 8:01 AM
 

DrMeg
Back home!

Member since 5/08

1858 total posts

Name:
Meg

Re: Commuting on LIRR stress

Posted by KittyGags

The LIRR NEEEEEEEEEEEEEDS quiet cars. These would also exclude IPOD blasters, similar to Amtrak.

As far as the chatty people, there is a group of 5 women who SCREAM in the morning, but act like they're in a bar on a Saturday night and I want to bludgeon them to death. Instead I run to the other side of the train.

I'm sorry, my best advice is put on an ipod or move seats.



I agree that they need quite cars. I tend to try and sit away from the areas that have the seats facing each other, as that's where the "talkers" tend to sit.
For those who say that you have no right to tell people they can't talk on the phone, do they have the right to tell me I can't read or sleep because I can't concentrate while they yammer away next to me?
And as mentioned, they do make announcements on the train to keep your phone conversations short, and if they need to be long you should move to the vestibule. No one seems to listen though.

Posted 4/11/10 9:12 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
LIRR service suspended in both directions east of Farmingdale on the Ronkonkoma branch Jax430 8/1/05 8 Families Helping Families ™
LIRR question... Myrockette 6/21/05 0 Families Helping Families ™
I hate the LIRR Corinne 6/13/05 10 Families Helping Families ™
Question about the LIRR? preciouslove 6/6/05 4 Families Helping Families ™
OT: LIRR DELAYS MrsJ 5/11/05 1 TTC
LIRR DELAYS MrsJ 5/11/05 4 Families Helping Families ™