CIO question

Posted By Message

MrsG
LIF Adolescent

Member since 8/06

552 total posts

Name:
M

CIO question

How long do you allow your DC to CIO before giving in and picking them up?

Also, is it too young to start trying this at 3 weeks?

DH & I are trying to let DD CIO, but it is so hard. But when we pick her up and she instantly stops crying, we feel like we are spoiling her and starting bad habits early.

I am not talking about in the middle of the nigh when I know she is hingry, but when she has eaten, burped, been changed and held and rocked, but still is crying.

Any tips would be greatly appreciated!!

Message edited 2007-04-16 21:44:34.483000.

Posted 4/16/07 9:41 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

ABCiverson
<3 my family

Member since 1/06

7465 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: CIO question

I have read that you aren't suppose to let them CIO untill they are 6 months old. I started letting DD CIO around 5 months old. IMO I think 3 weeks is way too early.


I forgot to say that you can't spoil a 3 week old baby. They need to cuddle at that age. You DD is so cute!

Message edited 2007-04-16 21:49:28.967000.

Posted 4/16/07 9:48 PM
 

nymommy2be
I love the summer

Member since 1/06

2063 total posts

Name:
Kara

Re: CIO question

3 weeks is way too early, newborns need to be held all the time. You really cannot spoil a newborn.

Posted 4/16/07 9:49 PM
 

groovypeg
:)

Member since 5/05

2423 total posts

Name:

Re: CIO question

in my opinion you cant spoil a 3 week old baby. i think that is way to young to try cio. alot of studies show that attending to your child's needs during the early months actually makes for a happier baby later on. hope that helpsChat Icon

Posted 4/16/07 9:50 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: CIO question

Oh God, please don't let your 3 week old CIO! She is barely used to the outside world! There is no way you can spoil a small baby that has no way of taking care of itself. For now, give her all the love and holding and coddling and feeding you can. I had to hold my daughter all day for the first 4 months of her life, and now, at 10 months, she wants nothing to do with being held. Just hold her and love her and know that this stage doesn't last very long, and once it's gone, you can never get it back!Chat Icon

Posted 4/16/07 10:02 PM
 

annie
This is how I play basketball!

Member since 6/05

1980 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: CIO question

babies that young are supposed to cry all the time. as a first time mom, i didn't know that & was worried that i was fostering bad habits as well. however, i quickly learned that babies cry even when they are well fed, rested, and comfortable. they just cry, and it always seems like a lot when it's your child- it hurts to see them upset. at this point, do anything you can to help her sleep well- even if you hold her, rock her, use the swing or bouncy seat, whatever it takes. deal with establishing good sleep habits when she's a little older. good luck!

Posted 4/16/07 10:06 PM
 

beachgirl
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

7967 total posts

Name:
sara

Re: CIO question

PLEASE dp not let your teeny tiny brand new baby CIO....she is way too young. ..think about it she has been tucked in nice and secure inside you for 9 mths and now bam...she is out in this strange world.

Hold her, cuddle her, pick her up when she cries...you will not spoil her ...IMO its vital at this age to attend to their every need. I read somewhere today that you cannot spoil a baby up until 1 year.

They grow up so fast this is the only time you will have to cuddle that little bundle..before you know it she will have the case of the "wiggles" and will be jumping out of your arms to get away from you.


Chat Icon

Posted 4/16/07 10:12 PM
 

MrsG
LIF Adolescent

Member since 8/06

552 total posts

Name:
M

Re: CIO question

Please girls, don't think am this terrible parent!!
I only mean when we have recently fed her, changed her , burped her, held , cuddled and rocked her for awhile, and she still just cries and cries. Is it ok then to let her CIO for 5-10 minutes to see if she will fall back to sleep? I read somewhere that some babies just need to cry themselves to sleep.

As a 1st time mom, thsi stuff is all so confusing and I just want to do the best thing for my baby!

Posted 4/16/07 10:31 PM
 

MrsG
LIF Adolescent

Member since 8/06

552 total posts

Name:
M

Re: CIO question

Posted by ABCiverson

I have read that you aren't suppose to let them CIO untill they are 6 months old. I started letting DD CIO around 5 months old. IMO I think 3 weeks is way too early.


I forgot to say that you can't spoil a 3 week old baby. They need to cuddle at that age. You DD is so cute!



Thanks! I love your avatar pic - adorable!

Posted 4/16/07 10:32 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: CIO question

Posted by MrsG

Please girls, don't think am this terrible parent!!
I only mean when we have recently fed her, changed her , burped her, held , cuddled and rocked her for awhile, and she still just cries and cries. Is it ok then to let her CIO for 5-10 minutes to see if she will fall back to sleep? I read somewhere that some babies just need to cry themselves to sleep.

As a 1st time mom, thsi stuff is all so confusing and I just want to do the best thing for my baby!



NO NO NO! Don't let her cry for 10 minutes. You're not a bad parent but the baby is 3 weeks old. You need to hold her, soothe her, rock her, whatever it takes. I'm crying just reading this. If you can't handle it right now because of sleep deprivation please, please get a family member to help you. Don't let your baby CIO any time soon. And whatever book your reading throw it out if it doesn't explain that a baby that young shouldn't CIO.

Posted 4/16/07 10:48 PM
 

MrsG
LIF Adolescent

Member since 8/06

552 total posts

Name:
M

Re: CIO question

Posted by monkeybride

Posted by MrsG

Please girls, don't think am this terrible parent!!
I only mean when we have recently fed her, changed her , burped her, held , cuddled and rocked her for awhile, and she still just cries and cries. Is it ok then to let her CIO for 5-10 minutes to see if she will fall back to sleep? I read somewhere that some babies just need to cry themselves to sleep.

As a 1st time mom, thsi stuff is all so confusing and I just want to do the best thing for my baby!



NO NO NO! Don't let her cry for 10 minutes. You're not a bad parent but the baby is 3 weeks old. You need to hold her, soothe her, rock her, whatever it takes. I'm crying just reading this. If you can't handle it right now because of sleep deprivation please, please get a family member to help you. Don't let your baby CIO any time soon. And whatever book your reading throw it out if it doesn't explain that a baby that young shouldn't CIO.




Now I am crying thinking that I am causing harm to my baby by letting her cry for a few minutes.
It's not sleep deprivation - she actually sleeps great during the night. But often during the day or early evening we have done everything we can with her several times over, so we thought we would try just letting her cry for a few minutes and see if she falls back to sleep, which she often does, never more than 5-10 minutes and then I pick her up.

So many people have told us that we shouldn't pick her up the second she stats crying, but to wait a few minutes. Guess I should think about who I am listening to from now on...Chat Icon

Posted 4/16/07 11:02 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: CIO question

Aww, I definitely don't think you're a bad parent! Just hold her. Hold her until she falls asleep and then put her down, and if she wakes up and cries, hold her some more. I know it's hard, but it's what she needs. How about getting a sling? I'm sure she would love that and it would free up your hands. Hang in there. Chat Icon

Posted 4/16/07 11:03 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: CIO question

Just remember that by picking her up when she starts to cry, you're reinforcing the fact that she is safe and sound. She's too little to know anything else. Your job is to provide security for her, so if anyone tells you not to pick her up, tell them to shove it!

Posted 4/16/07 11:05 PM
 

MrsG
LIF Adolescent

Member since 8/06

552 total posts

Name:
M

Re: CIO question

She's not too young for a sling? Do they have enough support for her neck? Does anyone have any brand that they recommend?

Thanks for all the advice. You girls really help calm the fears and worries of a new mom! Chat Icon

Message edited 2007-04-16 23:06:19.013000.

Posted 4/16/07 11:06 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: CIO question

Posted by MrsG

She's not too young for a sling? Do they have enough support for her neck? Does anyone have any brand that they recommend?

Thanks for all the advice. You girls really help calm the fears and worries of a new mom! Chat Icon




Definitely not to small for a sling, but I would say too small for a carrier. I dont' even remember what type I had. The girls here would know better. I completely forget.

Posted 4/16/07 11:07 PM
 

05mommy09
Family of 5!

Member since 5/05

15364 total posts

Name:
<3 Mommy <3

Re: CIO question

The true ferber method is not intended for babies under 4 months old...

What is your def. of crying? Is your baby restless for a few seconds- or full blown crying?

I wouldnt say you have to jump up the second DC makes a peep... but certainly dont let her cry...

You CAN NOT spoil a newborn- they dont even have that thought process yet... They are not capable of it... There is no such thing as cause and effect to them!

Tell everyone who tells you differently to go shove it! Your baby is used to being in a warm, tight, dark, place.. and is now thrown into somewhere where he/she has lots of space, there is light, and noise etc... Seriously think how scary that is???.... All your child needs is you- you to hold them, comfort them, keep them warm and snuggly...

Do you swaddle? If your child is crying resltlessly while sleeping- swaddling may help!

Message edited 2007-04-16 23:13:09.030000.

Posted 4/16/07 11:11 PM
 

Diane
Hope is Contagious....catch it

Member since 5/05

30683 total posts

Name:
D

Re: CIO question

3 weeks is WAY TOO early to CIO

Posted 4/16/07 11:15 PM
 

MrsG
LIF Adolescent

Member since 8/06

552 total posts

Name:
M

Re: CIO question

Posted by Princessmaris

The true ferber method is not intended for babies under 4 months old...

What is your def. of crying? Is your baby restless for a few seconds- or full blown crying?

I wouldnt say you have to jump up the second DC makes a peep... but certainly dont let her cry...

You CAN NOT spoil a newborn- they dont even have that thought process yet... They are not capable of it... There is no such thing as cause and effect to them!

Tell everyone who tells you differently to go shove it! Your baby is used to being in a warm, tight, dark, place.. and is now thrown into somewhere where he/she has lots of space, there is light, and noise etc... Seriously think how scary that is???.... All your child needs is you- you to hold them, comfort them, keep them warm and snuggly...

Do you swaddle? If your child is crying resltlessly while sleeping- swaddling may help!




I usually wait about 5 minutes to see if she calms herself and then I pick her up. I hold her and rock her until she falls asleep and then wait a little while to make sure she is deep asleep before putting her down again. Often, as soon as I put her down again she stars crying and then stops when i pick her up - which is where I got the feeling tha it was "spoiling" her (besides bad advice from some family members)

We always keep her swaddled and she seems to love it.

Posted 4/16/07 11:30 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: CIO question

Posted by MrsG

She's not too young for a sling? Do they have enough support for her neck? Does anyone have any brand that they recommend?

Thanks for all the advice. You girls really help calm the fears and worries of a new mom! Chat Icon



No definitely not too young. Check out
www.lucky-baby.com you can get an inexpensive one on their sale page and they have directions for use.

Posted 4/16/07 11:33 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: CIO question

Posted by MrsG

Posted by monkeybride

Posted by MrsG

Please girls, don't think am this terrible parent!!
I only mean when we have recently fed her, changed her , burped her, held , cuddled and rocked her for awhile, and she still just cries and cries. Is it ok then to let her CIO for 5-10 minutes to see if she will fall back to sleep? I read somewhere that some babies just need to cry themselves to sleep.

As a 1st time mom, thsi stuff is all so confusing and I just want to do the best thing for my baby!



NO NO NO! Don't let her cry for 10 minutes. You're not a bad parent but the baby is 3 weeks old. You need to hold her, soothe her, rock her, whatever it takes. I'm crying just reading this. If you can't handle it right now because of sleep deprivation please, please get a family member to help you. Don't let your baby CIO any time soon. And whatever book your reading throw it out if it doesn't explain that a baby that young shouldn't CIO.




Now I am crying thinking that I am causing harm to my baby by letting her cry for a few minutes.
It's not sleep deprivation - she actually sleeps great during the night. But often during the day or early evening we have done everything we can with her several times over, so we thought we would try just letting her cry for a few minutes and see if she falls back to sleep, which she often does, never more than 5-10 minutes and then I pick her up.

So many people have told us that we shouldn't pick her up the second she stats crying, but to wait a few minutes. Guess I should think about who I am listening to from now on...Chat Icon



OK I know none of us wanted to make you cry. We want to help. Many, many studies have been done that babies that are held, soothed, calmed etc from a young age actually end up happier in the end. Their are studies on Reactive Attachement Disorder in babies left to CIO at a very young age. NOT saying you are doing this to your baby just saying this is what has brought on the whole trent of holding our babies and meeting all their needs which is not how it was necessarily done back when our parents had us.
Being a new mom is so overwhelmig and so many people are telling you what to do and what not to do but honestly I find the girls on this forum give pretty straight forward good advice that is always in the best interest of the baby so definitely use these moms as a resource.
Also every baby is different but a newborn is still adjusting to life outside the womb. It's overwhelming for them. Cold, big, too open, etc.
Have you tried swaddling DD? That was a lifesaver for us. She was swaddled constantly during the day, not only at bedtime for a long time. Being loose was just too much for her.
Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Don't cry. We're here to help.


ETA: There is also this thing called the witching hour in newborn from about 4-7pm. Crying for no reason pretty much. Especially in BF babies. Are you BFing. If so you may need to cluster feed during these hours.

Message edited 2007-04-16 23:39:27.140000.

Posted 4/16/07 11:38 PM
 

MrsG
LIF Adolescent

Member since 8/06

552 total posts

Name:
M

Re: CIO question

We do swaddle her, bt with her arms out. She doesn't seem to like her arms in b/c she does this adorable thing when she sleeps by flinging both her arms over to one side. I bought one of those swaddle me balnkets and she hated it so now we just use receiving blankets.

I am not BF'ing, but I have heard of the witching hour - maybe that is part of whats going on...

I really appreciate all the advice from everyone. Being a new mom is so hard - there is so much to know and so much margin for error. I know I am a very capable person, but this is just all so new and foreign to me. As succesful and smart and together as we think we are in our careers and our lives, it all seems to change once we have babies. I never second guessed myself so much as I have in these past few weeks.

Thanks again everyone for all your advice! Chat Icon Chat Icon

Message edited 2007-04-16 23:58:30.000000.

Posted 4/16/07 11:50 PM
 

laurabora
LIF Adult

Member since 4/07

2712 total posts

Name:
Laura

Re: CIO question

I haven't read all the posts, but pick up a copy of "Happiest Baby on the Block" by Dr. Harvey Karp. It works wonders for soothing babies.

I will say I'd try a full swaddle, even if you think she doesn't like it. I am a bit of a swaddle-pusher though. Chat Icon The Miracle Blanket was a life saver for us.

Don't cry, it will get easier. We all doubt ourselves when they are so little.

Posted 4/16/07 11:59 PM
 

ddunne2
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

4189 total posts

Name:
Doreen

Re: CIO question

I would recommend the book "Happiest Baby on the Block" It will really help. Also, try putting her in a sling or carrier during the day. It will work wonders!
At this age, don't let her cry for very long. Sure, if you need to jump in the shower and she wimpers a little that is ok, but overall at this age they need lots of cuddling.

Posted 4/17/07 8:01 AM
 

yankinmanc
Happy Days!

Member since 8/05

18208 total posts

Name:

Re: CIO question

Posted by ddunne2

I would recommend the book "Happiest Baby on the Block" It will really help. Also, try putting her in a sling or carrier during the day. It will work wonders!
At this age, don't let her cry for very long. Sure, if you need to jump in the shower and she wimpers a little that is ok, but overall at this age they need lots of cuddling.



I agree. Do not let her cry!!! Cuddle her! Soon she will be a toddler and you will ache for these times!!!

Posted 4/17/07 8:09 AM
 

nferrandi
too excited for words

Member since 10/05

18538 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: CIO question

The fact that she's sleeping pretty well at night is even more reason you shouldn't be letting her CIO. She obviously needs "something extra" when she's crying, whether that's just some warmth or to hear your heartbeat. My son was a big cry baby and we never let him CIO at that age, they just don't understand the point of it.
As she gets older and you would like to try CIO, that's fine, but she really is too young. We tried it around 3.5 months and even that was too early. Now at almost 6 months we have our own version of CIO- we will let him cry for 15-20 minutes before going to him in the middle of the night. You will learn to know the difference in cries- whether they will die out or just get worse.

Posted 4/17/07 9:30 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
What kind of vaccuum do you have? EDITED with another question! MissJones 4/15/07 22 Home
CIO Moms...I have a question yankinmanc 9/3/06 8 Parenting
CIO spinoff question ckdk 8/4/06 3 Parenting
CIO/Controlled Crying Question yankinmanc 7/11/06 4 Parenting
CIO last night...(question) CheeChee 5/9/06 6 Parenting
Need quick help with yet another cio question sunny 5/4/06 5 Parenting