CIO help

Posted By Message

HomeIsWithU
Baby #2 on the way!

Member since 9/07

7816 total posts

Name:
Jenn

CIO help

I need some serious CIO help. DS is 4 1/2 months old. I know its not recommended to do CIO this early usually. We saw the Ped last week and discussed DS' many sleeping problems. She suggested that we try it this week. She felt very strongly that CIO is the only way to resolve his issues and since they are getting worse and worse and creating day time napping and eating problems, she felt it was time. I'm definately hesitant, but at this point, I'm willing to try anything.

Here's my problem - DS cannot self soothe. He uses both the swaddle and paci every night. I started to do CIO with him tonight but the paci fell out and I keep feeling like I should go give it back to him. Then he broke out of the swaddle and I felt liek I should go fix it for him. I know if I do, it'll just make things harder, but when do I know when to go to him and when to just let him go?

Also, whats the LONGEST you ever let YOUR DC cry during CIO? Not even going based on my situation or my DS' age...I'm just curious how long it took others?? and for how many nights before you noticed a change?

Please dont flame...I kno how many mommies feel that this is too young and TRUST me, I'm on the fence myself. I'm just going with the Peds recommendation and we'll see how it goes. I have trust in my Ped as she's brought DS full circle from his reflux and allergy issues in the beginning, so I'm confident she would never give me bad advice. But this is SO hard Chat Icon

Posted 12/9/09 7:55 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: CIO help

I'm NOT flaming you, but I am telling you as a BTDT mom who tried to do CIO (at my ped's urging as well) at 5 months that it may not work at this age.

And at that age, since he is swaddled and needs the pacifier, I would go in and give it to him.

My DS did not sleep through the night until he was one year old. That is when CIO finally worked for usChat Icon

Posted 12/9/09 8:05 PM
 

pickles16
Real Estate Professional

Member since 11/07

17227 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: CIO help

Posted by KateDevine

I'm NOT flaming you, but I am telling you as a BTDT mom who tried to do CIO (at my ped's urging as well) at 5 months that it may not work at this age.

And at that age, since he is swaddled and needs the pacifier, I would go in and give it to him.

My DS did not sleep through the night until he was one year old. That is when CIO finally worked for usChat Icon




I have to agree with Kate, while DD didn't give us huuuge sleeping issues, she did start having issues with the paci and then when she stared rolling over..ped suggested CIO...I knew she wasn't ready for it...again, she has had her bouts of not sttn, but they are on and off, the longest one was when she was 8 mos and thats when we first did a modified method of CIO that I thought would work for us and it did...we still have to do it now and then when she gets into her week or two of bad habits, but I knew she wasn't ready that young...you have to do what instinct is telling you to do...I knew that DD was too young, and knew when she was ready!!!Chat Icon

Posted 12/9/09 8:09 PM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: CIO help

No flames here! I've been letting Yael CIO in stages for a week or two now, and she's just about 5 months old Chat Icon

This is when we decided to move Yael out of her FP rocker and into her crib. I knew it would be a HUGE challenge so I didn't want to do it until I knew she was ready, and until I was comfortable to let her fuss to sleep.

Personally, I try to get rid of all sleep crutches - cold turkey, all at the same time - no swaddle, no paci, no rocker, no vibrate, nothing. Just her, in the crib, on her back.

So, the way I went about it was to stick to a strict schedule - I follow the EASY method (Eat, Activity, Sleep and You time while they sleep). That way she doesn't fall into the habit of needing to eat to fall asleep. So, from the moment she wakes up in the morning, this is when I start her schedule. I immediately feed her, and then we play for about an hour or so.

Within an hour and a half I know she needs to nap - sometimes earlier, so I have to pay close attention to her sleep cues (yawning, rubbing eyes, turning away from toys, kicking legs, staring into the distance, etc.)

When I decided to let her start self-soothing to sleep, I started with naps. So when an hour and a half passed or when I noticed a sleep cue, immediately I brought her to her room. I put her in her crib, closed the blinds, turned on the noise machine and turned on her aquarium, kissed her and walked out.

First time I did it, she cried on and off for about 30 minutes. Next nap, about 20 minutes, next nap about 10 minutes. By the second day of doing this, I could put her down for a nap and she barely fussed. Though, even now, a few weeks later, she still does fuss a little sometimes - I think sometimes babies just need to let off a little steam as part of the self-soothing process.

After a week of her mastering self-soothing for naps, I tackled bedtime. I ALWAYS make sure I feed her about 30 minutes before bedtime, so that again, she doesn't associate eating with sleeping, and so I make sure she's fully burped. I go through our routine (feed, burp, change diaper and into PJ's). Then we play quietly for about 20 minutes, and then the same deal - I put her in her crib, turn on the noise machine, and turn on the aquarium.

First night - she cried on and off for 45 minutes. Second night, about 20 minutes. After that, most nights she goes down without a peep, as long as I time it right. WIth her, it really all comes down to timing - if I don't time it right, I miss that window of opportunity and that's when she ends up crying to sleep.

Now, this week, I've been tackling the middle of the night wakings. Our Ped gave us the green light to let her cry/fuss through night wakings if she woke before 6 hours of sleep. She doesn't do it often, but in the few nights that she has, I don't even go into her room - I let her fuss back to sleep. Most nights it takes about 5 minutes and she goes back to sleep.

That's all I can think of for now... good luck!!

Posted 12/9/09 8:14 PM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: CIO help

Why don't you try graduated CIO?
The first time, you let him cry five minutes. Give him the paci, re-swaddle, then leave.
THe next time, let him cry ten minutes, the third time 15 minutes, and so on.
This will be a little easier for you to handle, and easier on him since he is pretty young to do CIO.
We did it with DS when he was 5.5 months, and let him cry for 30min. max. It only took a few days and he was sleeping for much longer periods of time.

Honestly though, if you are on the fence about it, don't do it yet, despite what your ped says. You are the mom, you make the decisions. Most babies at that age can't self-soothe, which is why it isn't recommended to do CIO until 6 months.

Posted 12/9/09 8:14 PM
 

ME75

Member since 10/06

4563 total posts

Name:

Re: CIO help

Posted by HomeIsWithU

I need some serious CIO help. DS is 4 1/2 months old. I know its not recommended to do CIO this early usually. We saw the Ped last week and discussed DS' many sleeping problems. She suggested that we try it this week. She felt very strongly that CIO is the only way to resolve his issues and since they are getting worse and worse and creating day time napping and eating problems, she felt it was time. I'm definately hesitant, but at this point, I'm willing to try anything.

Here's my problem - DS cannot self soothe. He uses both the swaddle and paci every night. I started to do CIO with him tonight but the paci fell out and I keep feeling like I should go give it back to him. Then he broke out of the swaddle and I felt liek I should go fix it for him. I know if I do, it'll just make things harder, but when do I know when to go to him and when to just let him go?

Also, whats the LONGEST you ever let YOUR DC cry during CIO? Not even going based on my situation or my DS' age...I'm just curious how long it took others?? and for how many nights before you noticed a change?

Please dont flame...I kno how many mommies feel that this is too young and TRUST me, I'm on the fence myself. I'm just going with the Peds recommendation and we'll see how it goes. I have trust in my Ped as she's brought DS full circle from his reflux and allergy issues in the beginning, so I'm confident she would never give me bad advice. But this is SO hard Chat Icon



first, don't think about what others might think of you or flame you. no one loves your boy more than you and you would never harm him-CIO does not mean you are harming your baby.
what i do think is that since your DS has 2 sleep crutches-the swaddle and binky that you need to eliminate one at a time. for us we took the swaddle away first. you might be surprised by how well your DS does without it. i was! my DS still has his binky so i'm no help there. but lately since he is almost 5 months we have been doing a little CIO during the overnight b/c the binky does become a problem sometimes.
i think the longest i ever let my DD CIO when we did it was an hour maybe? it really only took 3 nights or so. i can't say yet for DS though-some nights are great and some are not. still erratic.
if you don't want to do CIO cold turkey you could go in and keep reassuring your DS that you are there and then leave. repeat...
also, read the few pages about CIO in the healthy sleep habits book if you have it-it is very helpful and informative.
otherwise i'm sure you'll get more advice on here-good luck! and hang in there this phase is going to be over before you know it! you'll see!Chat Icon

edited to add that i think Bxgell gave you some great advice!

Message edited 2009-12-09 20:21:59.130000.

Posted 12/9/09 8:16 PM
 

ruby
you rang?

Member since 6/08

5573 total posts

Name:

Re: CIO help

I agree with Kate as well. I tried CIO with DS at 6 months....it didn't work then and in hindsight knowing him and how he is now, he wasn't ready then. I'm just now doing it again at almost 10 months. While you obviously don't have to wait as long as I did, I really urge you to wait at least a bit longer. He's still young, not being able to soothe himself at 4 1/2 months is not uncommon in the least.

I also trust my ped with his medical issues,but I look at CIO as more behavioral....she also recommended I do CIO with DS at 4 months, and I just smiled and nodded. Just because she's my ped and I think she's a great pediatrician does not mean she knows my son day in and day out and how he reacts to certain things. I do.

All that said, every single baby is different. I've read moms on here being successful with CIO after one night, some two, some three, some even more, etc. It's really a crapshoot. I'll tell you that we started on Friday night and as of last night (Tuesday) he was still waking up in the middle of the night a few times to cry so I'm going on night 6. We'll see how tonight goes. If you're going for true CIO (extinction method) then you let them cry as long as they cry, whether that be 5 minutes or 5 hours. However long it takes until they fally asleep on their own. DS has cried over an hour and I let him. For naps though just one hour, after that it's pointless, just pick them up and try again next nap. If you're doing a modified CIO where you go in after a few minutes and keep extending the time that's up to you the amount.

Posted 12/9/09 8:19 PM
 

maiden
Whoa!

Member since 5/08

1814 total posts

Name:
T

Re: CIO help

When DD was 4.5 months, I considered CIO b/c I like the sleep Healthy Sleep Habits, Happy Child and it recommends CIO at 4 months. DD was having some sleeping issues going to sleep at night and naps. She wasn't able to self soothe at that age, but I felt that she was just too young. I was right. Now, with some exceptions mostly because of teething, she is 6.5 months and sleeps very well and I never had to do any major CIO. I tried to encourage her independence, but also comfort her. I picked her up when she cried, but when she was soothed, i put her back in her crib. With some trial and error, I feel like we worked together to get a good rhythm going. It was tough sometimes, b/c it took awhile, but it was worth it. But I do feel every child is different and perhaps some children are ready for CIO at that age. If you feel DS is not ready, IMO there is no harm in waiting. You can always do CIO later if you want to. He is still young.

Posted 12/9/09 10:22 PM
 

bonitachyc
big sister status may 2012!!

Member since 5/08

3242 total posts

Name:
Lupe

Re: CIO help

ever since DD was a newborn i knew i'd have to sleep train her. she would never sleep more than an hour and a half stretch at night and i knew she just was waking up out of habit. i would've started at 5 months, but we were planning a vacation when she was going to be 6 months old so i decided to wait so that i wouldn't have to do CIO twice. when we came back from vaca, she got sick, so i had to wait for the antibiotics to wear off, i didn't have the heart to let her cry at night while sick. by the time she got better, she started learning how to pull up on the crib rails and would hurt herself so i had to wait until she learned how to get down. when it was all said and done, i did it at 7 months!! Chat Icon she was def ready then, but i feel like it would've been over alot faster had i done it at 5 months.

if i were you, i'd gradually try to eliminate the swaddle. my dd had fantastic head control and could sleep on her tummy w no problems, so that was our way out of the swaddle.

is your DS a full out crier or does he whine? i thought my DD was going to scream bloody murder but she ended up whining most of the times and she got the hint real fast that it was time to sleep and no one was going to come get her. the longest i ever let her cry/whine was probably half hour-45 minutes...but that was only cause DH woke up in the middle of the night in a stupor and FORGOT we were doing CIO and WENT INTO HER ROOM!!!!Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon once she saw him she freaked out and wanted to be picked up. that was the longest she's ever cried with CIO.

if going in to soothe him is only going to make your DS worse, you need to do full out CIO. some babies need to be soothed, others flip out. mine was the latter. once you decide which he is will determine how long you let him go on crying.

i noticed a change the very next night. night 1 with full out CIO was rough, she was up a good 4-5 times minimum. night two she was up two or three times i think. night three she would've been up only once but that's when DH pulled the "i forgot" crap and that night was bad. but after that, it all was great.

dd now sleeps 11 hours minimum each night with no interruptions. sleep deprivation is something wicked, i hope you're able to sleep train him (and yourself too) very soon! Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 12/10/09 12:18 AM
 

MrsPowers
So blessed!

Member since 11/06

10348 total posts

Name:
Ivelysse

Re: CIO help

What about giving DC a lovey to sleep with? They say if you sleep with the lovey and it gets your scent it will be better for DC.

For me, DS cried the first night for 15 min (2x) and the second night for 10 min (1x) and has slept 12 hours a night since 4 1/2 months.

Posted 12/10/09 5:57 AM
 

TaraHutch
True beauty

Member since 10/07

9888 total posts

Name:
Tara

Re: CIO help

Riley finally figured it out on her own around 4.5 months...once she found her thumb. Maybe CJ just needs a little more time to figure it out on his own?

I suggest taking him out of the swaddle first. Riley finally progressed once I took her out of the swaddle. You might be a little freaked to just go cold turkey off the swaddle...but I did it and it really made a huge difference. I decided to take her off the swaddle when I realized what was waking her was her mad fight to get out. Chat Icon She finally figured out how to soothe herself, once her hands were out. He may not need to suck his thumb, but he may need to stroke his hair, his sleepsack, a lovey, etc...

Sweetie, you do what you need to do.Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon My ped recommended CIO at 4 months as well... Just do what is right for you and CJ!Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Don't let ANYONE make you feel guilty for the choices you make...you are his Mom and you do what's right for you and CJ.Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Message edited 2009-12-10 06:46:38.443000.

Posted 12/10/09 6:44 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Terrible two's and getting abused by my daughter...AND I MADE HER CIO FOR THE FIRST TIME-EVER! aliasPook 2/24/07 7 Parenting
I give you CIO moms a lot of credit! CookiePuss 2/12/07 5 Parenting
So, Ava is currently CIO in her crib and.... BaroqueMama 12/26/06 6 Parenting
CIO Ladies, I have a few quick questions...not so much a long post, more a rambling post yankinmanc 7/22/06 7 Parenting
has anyone been successsful with CIO after age one? antoinette 7/15/06 4 Parenting
CIO...30 minutes of Screaming! But Now What do i do???? dree 3/1/06 13 Parenting