CIO - how long is too long? Please Please help.

Posted By Message

JessT
LIF Infant

Member since 6/08

323 total posts

Name:

CIO - how long is too long? Please Please help.

I am not sure if we started this too soon with my DS, he is 5.5 months. Dr. gave the ok and here is the way it went:
Thursday-Saturday he slept from 730-12 had a bottle and then went back to sleep. Woke at around 2 and i let him CIO. It went from 20 min on thursday to basically nothing by saturday. Sunday and last night were a disaster. this morning he cried for 40 minutes and i had to get him. i was about to have a breakdown. even with me holding him, he couldnt calm down and now has been awake since 445 am. should i not have picked him up at all? how long can a baby cry for when he is that little? should i wait and try again after 6 months?

Posted 12/8/09 9:36 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: CIO - how long is too long? Please Please help.

We tried CIO at that age, and it didn't work, DS was hungry, so we fed himChat Icon

Posted 12/8/09 9:49 AM
 

JessT
LIF Infant

Member since 6/08

323 total posts

Name:

Re: CIO - how long is too long? Please Please help.

Thanks. No one ever replies to me. boo.
he does have like 27oz of formula during the day and food too! he is almost 18 lbs. i feel like it is easier just to get up and feed him than let him cry but is that doing more harm then good?

Posted 12/8/09 10:06 AM
 

MrsS2005
Mom of 3

Member since 11/05

13118 total posts

Name:
B

Re: CIO - how long is too long? Please Please help.

Posted by JessT

Thanks. No one ever replies to me. boo.
he does have like 27oz of formula during the day and food too! he is almost 18 lbs. i feel like it is easier just to get up and feed him than let him cry but is that doing more harm then good?


Food is really for practice and probably won't fill him up the way formula does. I BF so I'm not really sure about how much formula he should be getting, but do you think he's crying from hunger? DS was still waking up to nurse at night until he was 7 months old. He was hungry and needed to eat.

Posted 12/8/09 10:16 AM
 

jerseypanda
Life is good.

Member since 1/07

9164 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: CIO - how long is too long? Please Please help.

See, for us, we didn't start CIO until DS was completely done with eating in the middle of the night. If your DC is still getting a bottle at 12:00, I'm not sure I would start CIO yet.

When he got up at 4:45, did you feed him? I know when DS was around 5.5 months, he was still eating at 5 or 5:30 in the morning. If your DS is hungry, CIO probably won't work. Or at least I wouldn't do it at that time in the morning.

I can tell you that when we first started CIO, I think the longest DS cried when we put him down at night was about 45 minutes. Pure torture and we probably would have lasted longer if he continued to cry, but I'm not sure how long is too long. I do know that when you are ready to completely commit to CIO, you can't go in and rescue them if you think they are crying too long. They are smary (even at 6 months) and will learn very fast that if they just cry long enough you will cave in and get them. Chat Icon

Posted 12/8/09 10:20 AM
 

jambalady
Is it summer yet?

Member since 8/06

7392 total posts

Name:
Holly

Re: CIO - how long is too long? Please Please help.

We did CIO at around 5 months. The Ped said that once they surpass around 15 lbs, they no longer need to eat. They are waking for comfort and out of habit.

We also knew he wasn't waking out of hunger bc he was STTN at about 3 mos old, and then regressed at around 4 1/2 mos old. So we knew he was capable of STTN.

It took us about a week, one night he cried for almost an hour and half, then each night progressively less.

Posted 12/8/09 10:25 AM
 

Meggo613
im a big girl!

Member since 2/07

4536 total posts

Name:
Megan

Re: CIO - how long is too long? Please Please help.

Posted by jambalady

We did CIO at around 5 months. The Ped said that once they surpass around 15 lbs, they no longer need to eat. They are waking for comfort and out of habit.

We also knew he wasn't waking out of hunger bc he was STTN at about 3 mos old, and then regressed at around 4 1/2 mos old. So we knew he was capable of STTN.

It took us about a week, one night he cried for almost an hour and half, then each night progressively less.



i dontknow how much i agree with that statement that once they surpass 15lbs they are no longer hungry.

with my baby (im not flaming im just saying from my experience) my DD is 5 moths old and was STTN at 9 weeks 12 hours up untill she was 3.5 months old. and then stopped sttn. She had a MAJOR growth spurt and grew 4inches in 2 months and gained quite a bit of weight and was now waking in the middle of the night for a bottle. (shes just about 18lbs) It was clearly not out of habbit because when i would give her a bottle she would nearly choke on it because she was trying to eat so fast which she didnt do during the day. and was not falling asleep halfway through Shes now 5 months old some nights she STTN 12 hours and some nights she cant because shes starving by 3am. (which mind you is already after almost 9 hrs of sleep) If you baby is waking in the middle of the night and is HUNGRY feed them. i still think 5 months old is too young for CIO (especially if they are still waking due to hunger) but thats my own personal opinion and i know most dont agree with it. every baby is different i would go by what your dc needs are.

Posted 12/8/09 10:40 AM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: CIO - how long is too long? Please Please help.

Posted by jerseypanda

See, for us, we didn't start CIO until DS was completely done with eating in the middle of the night. If your DC is still getting a bottle at 12:00, I'm not sure I would start CIO yet.

When he got up at 4:45, did you feed him? I know when DS was around 5.5 months, he was still eating at 5 or 5:30 in the morning. If your DS is hungry, CIO probably won't work. Or at least I wouldn't do it at that time in the morning.

I can tell you that when we first started CIO, I think the longest DS cried when we put him down at night was about 45 minutes. Pure torture and we probably would have lasted longer if he continued to cry, but I'm not sure how long is too long. I do know that when you are ready to completely commit to CIO, you can't go in and rescue them if you think they are crying too long. They are smary (even at 6 months) and will learn very fast that if they just cry long enough you will cave in and get them. Chat Icon



I agree with this-but keep in mind I fed my kids until they were 8 months and they drank it. One night I decided no more bottles and went in and soothed but no bottles. That night was torture-they were up every hour or so, but the next night it wasn't bad at all and by the 3rd night they slept all night.

My personal limit for crying is 20 minutes. Decide what you are comfortable with and go with that. Good luck.

Posted 12/8/09 10:40 AM
 

JessT
LIF Infant

Member since 6/08

323 total posts

Name:

Re: CIO - how long is too long? Please Please help.

thanks to everyone who responded! maybe i will wait a little longer to try again.

One last question, did anyone try any of the No Cry training methods?

Posted 12/8/09 11:02 AM
 

tara73
carseat nerd

Member since 11/09

3669 total posts

Name:
Buttercup

Re: CIO - how long is too long? Please Please help.

With DD we weren't successful with CIO at 5-6 months and had to wait until she was about 11 months. She was very difficult to get to sleep without being held/rocked and was colicky

What worked finally was putting her down and sitting there with her and patting her back initially until she fell asleep. A few days later we left before she was asleep but while calm. Then we just sat in there for 10 minutes for a few days, then stood next to the crib for a few minutes and eventually stood at the door. Basically we eased her into it. Some nights were better than others, and if she was having a particularly rough night (teething or sick) then we didn't necessarily "stick" to it.

We always spoke to her in a calm voice and we would go in and give her some comfort (pat on the back, hug etc) if she cried more than 10 minutes.

I won't lie and say it was easy because it wasn't but she goes to bed just fine now (22 months) and has for a while.

I would follow your gut and do what you feel as a parent that your child needs. It may be that your DC isn't ready yet for CIO.

Good luck, I hope you find something that works soon!

Posted 12/8/09 12:50 PM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaƮt

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: CIO - how long is too long? Please Please help.

If your baby is waking and takes a bottle (more than an ounce or two), that means they are probably hungry, and not waking out of habit.

I know that for us, DS was STTN since he was 8 weeks old so when we did CIO at 5 months (due to sleep regression) he was ready, he didn't need to eat!

Posted 12/8/09 1:01 PM
 

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: CIO - how long is too long? Please Please help.

Honestly, I think you need to do what seems right for you and your child. I know some may disagree, but I really do not think CIO works for every child or every parent. Some just get too hysterical, I know mine did and the same happened with a couple of my friends. If it feels wrong, don't do it. Kids do manage to learn to sleep without CIO, though it takes longer.

There is a book called "Healthy Sleep Habits, Happy BAby," and the author advocates CIO, but there are other techniques he runs through that are useful even if you skip CIO. There is another one called "The No Cry Sleep Solution," which I didn't find useful, but I know parents who did.

At 5 months, DC may be too young for CIO and may indeed need food at night. I do think they need more when they are going through growth spurts, and though technically they aren't supposed to need food after 4 months, I really do not think this is 100% true.

Do what you think feels best for you and your baby. You need to be happy with the choices you make, or at least okay with them.

Posted 12/8/09 3:03 PM
 

nov04libride
big brother <3

Member since 5/05

14672 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: CIO - how long is too long? Please Please help.

DS is 5 months, 1 week and drinking 36 ounces during the day and eating, so your DC really may just need to eat during the night.

My personal CIO limit would only be 15-20 mins, but that's just me.

Posted 12/8/09 3:18 PM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: CIO - how long is too long? Please Please help.

We did CIO with DS when he was 5.5 months. He was still sleeping in the swing and we decided it was time for him to sleep in the crib.He would do ok falling alseep but then would wake up every half hour-hour.
We decided our limit was 30 minutes. We would go in, let him know we were there, and then leave. No picking him up, talking to him, just giving a binky and a few rubs on the head.


If your DS slept from 7:30 12, and then again until 4:45, that is pretty darn good. I don't think anything more could be expected at that age.
My DC STILL wake up around 5 or 6 for a feeding and then go back to sleep for another two hours. They are 11 months.
Feed him at 12 and then again around 5. I don't see why you even need to do CIO if these are the only times he is waking up IMHO.

Posted 12/8/09 3:33 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Terrible two's and getting abused by my daughter...AND I MADE HER CIO FOR THE FIRST TIME-EVER! aliasPook 2/24/07 7 Parenting
I give you CIO moms a lot of credit! CookiePuss 2/12/07 5 Parenting
So, Ava is currently CIO in her crib and.... BaroqueMama 12/26/06 6 Parenting
CIO Ladies, I have a few quick questions...not so much a long post, more a rambling post yankinmanc 7/22/06 7 Parenting
has anyone been successsful with CIO after age one? antoinette 7/15/06 4 Parenting
CIO...30 minutes of Screaming! But Now What do i do???? dree 3/1/06 13 Parenting