Has anyone bought a new cell phone and had problems with it past the 30 day return time?

I have had this Samsung AT&T phone for two months. Had problems since day one, but only went back to store the other day. It drops calls, speaker comes on easily while talking ( I guess face hits it), so in public everyone can hear what the other person is saying. The other day it turned off while I was on with my boss. Has turned off many times. I read many reviews online with the same problem. I went in store today and they gave me same phone as a replacement. I asked what if I have problems with this phone too, as I read reviews online with the same problem, and was told they will only replace with the same phone I have. So I took the new phone. An hour later, work related call, got cut off again, speaker turned on in middle of call. Unless I spend full price on new phone, I cannot get any deals on a phone until 11/12. If I buy an AT&T new phone elsewhere, is it cheaper without entering a contract? I am only 2 months into my two year plan. Geez..I have so many other things to do, hate dealing with this, but cannot deal with a phone that is not reliable.