Celeb/parenting question

Posted By Message

jules
Changing everyday

Member since 1/08

2281 total posts

Name:
julia

Celeb/parenting question

So i have been seeing a lot of criticism about celeb parenting. I mean some stuff is just sooo inconsequential and probably wouldn't ever be a topic of convo is this was just the average person. Nor would it even be worthy of judgement.
BUT because they are celebs all of a sudden everyone has a nasty opinion on parenting skills.

Just today i saw on the cover of the Post the whole Britney, son, cigarette thing. He touched or went to grab the carton...

AND this is the cover of the post?????

I just didn't get it Chat Icon

WHAT IS THE BIG DEAL? Kids everyday grab things that they shouldn't. I am sure that happens a GAZILLION times a day in the houses of smokers...

I dunno i am just not seeing why celeb parenting skills are such a hot topic to discuss. AND WHY on earth are they held at a higher standard than the average person?

Posted 7/22/08 5:48 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

hbugal
Lesigh

Member since 2/07

15928 total posts

Name:

Re: Celeb/parenting question

It's crazy isnt it?

Posted 7/22/08 6:18 PM
 

MelToddJulia
Love my Family!

Member since 7/05

29064 total posts

Name:
Mel

Re: Celeb/parenting question

I agree with you, I think its crazy!

Posted 7/22/08 6:24 PM
 

nancy6485
So in love

Member since 10/05

3363 total posts

Name:
Nancy

Re: Celeb/parenting question

it IS crazy! All the negative attention is absurd

Posted 7/22/08 6:33 PM
 

Kerie-is-so-very
versatile!

Member since 5/05

13535 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Celeb/parenting question

I agree a thousand percent with your point. The scrutiny of being a celebrity drives many of them to the brink of insanity. However, my dad was a 3 pack a day smoker and my mom was an "every so often" smoker. Cigarettes were never, not even for a minute, within our reach even though we were exposed to a lot of second hand smoke.

Posted 7/22/08 7:18 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Celeb/parenting question

I think celebs are not held to a higher standard in terms of parenting. I think it's easier to criticize a stranger than someone you know. Celebrities are easy targets because they're out there with their kids - making mistakes like all parents only with paparazzi chronicling them.

For Britney Spears, I think she's made some huge parenting errors (driving with a baby in her lap, freaking out & breaking down in front of her kids & locking them in with her, etc.). Does she deserve to be front page of the Post? No, that should be the war or the election but people aren't interested in them & it's not going to sell papers.

I will say this:
Kate Hudson should cut her son's hair.
Suri should be off of the bottle at 2+ years old.
Britney needs higher walls at her house.
Jamie Lynn shouldn't be glorifying teen pregnancy, but is perfectly within her right to be thrilled, happy & overjoyed over her baby.

I'll offer the same advice as I do on this board...those are my opinions, but again, whatever works for them.Chat Icon

Now where are those $16million twins?Chat Icon

Posted 7/22/08 7:32 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Celeb/parenting question

Here's my issue with criticizing celebs' parenting abilities: In reality, it's not just celebs that people are criticizing, it's all of us. Like, when I read on the celeb board people saying to get Suri off the bottle already or get her hair out of her face, I know damn well those same people are thinking those things about every parent and child that age. Why would you say it about a celeb and not your friend whose 2 yr old still has a bottle?
So, to me, it just gives me insight as to how judgemental people are about everyday people, not just celebs.

Posted 7/22/08 7:42 PM
 

leighla
Support Cancer Research

Member since 5/05

16353 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Celeb/parenting question

Posted by prncss

Here's my issue with criticizing celebs' parenting abilities: In reality, it's not just celebs that people are criticizing, it's all of us. Like, when I read on the celeb board people saying to get Suri off the bottle already or get her hair out of her face, I know damn well those same people are thinking those things about every parent and child that age. Why would you say it about a celeb and not your friend whose 2 yr old still has a bottle?
So, to me, it just gives me insight as to how judgemental people are about everyday people, not just celebs.



Exactly.

But I will say that I will openly criticize ANY parent who is careless enough to leave their cigarettes out in the reach of their child.

And she was smoking in front of him too.

I find both those things to be horrific.

Posted 7/22/08 7:48 PM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Celeb/parenting question

Posted by leighla

Posted by prncss

Here's my issue with criticizing celebs' parenting abilities: In reality, it's not just celebs that people are criticizing, it's all of us. Like, when I read on the celeb board people saying to get Suri off the bottle already or get her hair out of her face, I know damn well those same people are thinking those things about every parent and child that age. Why would you say it about a celeb and not your friend whose 2 yr old still has a bottle?
So, to me, it just gives me insight as to how judgemental people are about everyday people, not just celebs.



Exactly.

But I will say that I will openly criticize ANY parent who is careless enough to leave their cigarettes out in the reach of their child.

And she was smoking in front of him too.

I find both those things to be horrific.



Well, I agree with you. That is pretty bad!

Posted 7/22/08 8:03 PM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: Celeb/parenting question

I agree , must be hard to be so publicly judged on such a topic.

Posted 7/22/08 8:17 PM
 

annie
This is how I play basketball!

Member since 6/05

1980 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Celeb/parenting question

I don't find it surprising or wrong at all actually. I think it's gross for a child to grab at his parent's box of cigarettes. Celebrity or not. Friend or not. Humans criticize others, it's in our nature. At least it's in mine... Now complaining that Suri has hair in her face, that's a little silly. The fact that the Post has nothing better to report on their front page, well that's just the Post. Celebrities take all kinds of criticism/judgement from the world. That's the life of a celeb, tough as it is. I can imagine it totally sucks as a parent, but that's part of being famous.

Posted 7/22/08 8:28 PM
 

jules
Changing everyday

Member since 1/08

2281 total posts

Name:
julia

Re: Celeb/parenting question

Posted by nrthshgrl

I will say this:
Kate Hudson should cut her son's hair.
Suri should be off of the bottle at 2+ years old.
Britney needs higher walls at her house.
Jamie Lynn shouldn't be glorifying teen pregnancy, but is perfectly within her right to be thrilled, happy & overjoyed over her baby.

I'll offer the same advice as I do on this board...those are my opinions, but again, whatever works for them.Chat Icon

Now where are those $16million twins?Chat Icon




But that is it exactly...IT IS WHAT is working for THEM? Who the hell are we to judge or even really KNOW about their real parenting from a PHOTO???
Are we that naive? That a snapshot is truth? The whole picture?

I dunno...i just think it is just soo sad to the point of ignorance

Posted 7/22/08 9:00 PM
 

jules
Changing everyday

Member since 1/08

2281 total posts

Name:
julia

Re: Celeb/parenting question

Posted by prncss

Here's my issue with criticizing celebs' parenting abilities: In reality, it's not just celebs that people are criticizing, it's all of us. Like, when I read on the celeb board people saying to get Suri off the bottle already or get her hair out of her face, I know damn well those same people are thinking those things about every parent and child that age. Why would you say it about a celeb and not your friend whose 2 yr old still has a bottle?
So, to me, it just gives me insight as to how judgemental people are about everyday people, not just celebs.



I TOTALLY agree with this. And this bothers me even more i guess. That you see soo many people comment on the most miniscule, lamest things. As if we are ANYBODY to criticize?

God help us if there was a camera taking pics of every moment with our child.

And when did, as i said above, a snap shot explain anything?

I would bet that if ANYONE of the moms here posted that they were such a bad mom today "I drove my DC home and TOTALLY forgot to lock her in the carseat". WOW how many people here would say "awwww you aren't a bad mom, mistakes happen" (and rightfully so, i would be one of them)

BUT...if there was a pic on the cover of the post of Jamie Lynns DC in the carseat without the belt locked HOLEY MOLEY boy would she be ripped to screds

just seem two faced to me

Posted 7/22/08 9:08 PM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: Celeb/parenting question

Posted by annie

I don't find it surprising or wrong at all actually. I think it's gross for a child to grab at his parent's box of cigarettes. Celebrity or not. Friend or not. Humans criticize others, it's in our nature. At least it's in mine... Now complaining that Suri has hair in her face, that's a little silly. The fact that the Post has nothing better to report on their front page, well that's just the Post. Celebrities take all kinds of criticism/judgement from the world. That's the life of a celeb, tough as it is. I can imagine it totally sucks as a parent, but that's part of being famous.



is it any more gross then grabbing at a beer? Which I know I have seen my son do and actually took a pic of it. Yes ciggerrettes will possibly kill you, but so can alcohol....SO CAN processed food for goodness sakes.

Its not something I condone but not something I would judge either.

I do judge celebs, I think sometimes they deserve it if they put themselves out there, but parenting skills, marriage skills, its too open and too easily judged over silly stuff.

I think they need to keep their public apperance up to judgements sure, but this is silly..Front page news? What does that say about US????

Posted 7/22/08 9:12 PM
 

jules
Changing everyday

Member since 1/08

2281 total posts

Name:
julia

Re: Celeb/parenting question

Posted by dm24angel

Posted by annie

I don't find it surprising or wrong at all actually. I think it's gross for a child to grab at his parent's box of cigarettes. Celebrity or not. Friend or not. Humans criticize others, it's in our nature. At least it's in mine... Now complaining that Suri has hair in her face, that's a little silly. The fact that the Post has nothing better to report on their front page, well that's just the Post. Celebrities take all kinds of criticism/judgement from the world. That's the life of a celeb, tough as it is. I can imagine it totally sucks as a parent, but that's part of being famous.



is it any more gross then grabbing at a beer? Which I know I have seen my son do and actually took a pic of it. Yes ciggerrettes will possibly kill you, but so can alcohol....SO CAN processed food for goodness sakes.

Its not something I condone but not something I would judge either.

I do judge celebs, I think sometimes they deserve it if they put themselves out there, but parenting skills, marriage skills, its too open and too easily judged over silly stuff.

I think they need to keep their public apperance up to judgements sure, but this is silly..Front page news? What does that say about US????

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 7/22/08 9:14 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Celeb/parenting question

Posted by jules

Posted by nrthshgrl

I will say this:
Kate Hudson should cut her son's hair.
Suri should be off of the bottle at 2+ years old.
Britney needs higher walls at her house.
Jamie Lynn shouldn't be glorifying teen pregnancy, but is perfectly within her right to be thrilled, happy & overjoyed over her baby.

I'll offer the same advice as I do on this board...those are my opinions, but again, whatever works for them.Chat Icon

Now where are those $16million twins?Chat Icon






But that is it exactly...IT IS WHAT is working for THEM? Who the hell are we to judge or even really KNOW about their real parenting from a PHOTO???
Are we that naive? That a snapshot is truth? The whole picture?

I dunno...i just think it is just soo sad to the point of ignorance



I'm pretty sure Britney driving with her son on her lap is pretty cut & dry. So yes, a snapshot is the whole picture for me on that case. It was absolutely poor judgement.

As for who the hell are we to judge? It is human nature to have an opinion or a preference for something. I'm sure I'm judged for letting my daughter dress her mismatched self in the morning or not fixing her hair. Does it mean I love her any less because her hair isn't up in a clip or she's not wearing a hat? No. I'm not questioning if they love their child or their parenting abilities. I'm merely stating my opinon or preference for a short-haired boy, that Suri should be off a bottle, etc...and if my friend's daughter was still on a bottle post 15 months, I would probably tell her that it's going to be a lot harder to give up the longer she waits. She can chose to listen or not. It's her kid.

I posted that I didn't think Britney was a bad parent for giving sole custody of her kids to the more stable parent. I can't even fathom how much that would kill me to do the same if I didn't have my act together mentally, etc. To me, it was akin to a birthmom who loves her child enough to give it a better chance at life.

If anything, I think having a child has made me less judgemental about other moms. I don't know that people recognize the depths of parenting until they're a parent.

and for the record, I think people that smoke around their kids are using poor judgement. I can't imagine how powerful that addiction is as I know some many people that wish they could stop. I also detest photos of kids with beer bottles/alcoholic drinks. I'm sure many people think it's funny. It's not my taste or sense of humor.

eta. and no,it definitely doesn't warrant the cover of any newspaper.

Message edited 2008-07-23 00:50:22.767000.

Posted 7/23/08 12:48 AM
 

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Re: Celeb/parenting question

Posted by jules

Posted by nrthshgrl

I will say this:
Kate Hudson should cut her son's hair.
Suri should be off of the bottle at 2+ years old.
Britney needs higher walls at her house.
Jamie Lynn shouldn't be glorifying teen pregnancy, but is perfectly within her right to be thrilled, happy & overjoyed over her baby.

I'll offer the same advice as I do on this board...those are my opinions, but again, whatever works for them.Chat Icon

Now where are those $16million twins?Chat Icon




But that is it exactly...IT IS WHAT is working for THEM? Who the hell are we to judge or even really KNOW about their real parenting from a PHOTO???
Are we that naive? That a snapshot is truth? The whole picture?

I dunno...i just think it is just soo sad to the point of ignorance



We all have opinions - right or wrong/good or bad. Some express them easily and others keep them close to the vest.

Every day you open yourself up to judgement. When you step out your front door in the morning you are giving people opportunities to form opinions about you. Every now and then you will have someone smile and say "Great dress!" or you'll have someone tap you sheepishly and whisper "You have toilet paper stuck to your shoe!" But some will take a look and think you look fabulous and won't say anything. Other's will notice a stray hair out of place and will keep quiet. And some of those quiet ones will come onto LIF and say "I saw the a girl wearing the most amazing shoes at the store today.. where do you think I can find them" - or they will say "I can't believe there was a girl wearing jean shorts AND socks with sandals!" It's easier to talk about people when they don't have to hear you.

But your world is smaller than Britney's.. so the judgement and opinions that you are 'victim' too are on a MUCH smaller scale. Know what I mean? It's not DIFFERENT - it's just more visible - it's just louder.

I try not to judge - but I still like to share MY opinion. But there is always a caveat - which is that NOBODY has to live up to my standards except for me. So while I feel absolutely free in saying "I wouldn't let my son's hair get as long as Kate Hudson's son.." I also say "But he's not my son - so she can do whatever she feels is fit and best for him."

I certainly don't judge people for having opinions, sharing opinions or thinking that they know what is best for THEM. And yeah - there are some people who totally take a series of photos or rumors about the celeb du jour and decide that they love them or hate them based on that. But I think more people are making comments about the moment - not the person.

As for the post - here's my opinion. The paper is only a dog's ball above the Enquirer with regard to content. It doesn't surprise me that they think Britney Spears' kid grabbing for something is news. They aren't exactly known for their Pulitzer Prize winning articles and cutting edge stories.Chat Icon

ETA: You also open yourself up to opinions by posting on HERE. People tend to think I am much nicer than I actually am based on the things I have posted here.Chat Icon

Message edited 2008-07-23 07:25:12.280000.

Posted 7/23/08 7:22 AM
 

2PreciousBlessings
The Perfect Pair

Member since 5/06

19861 total posts

Name:
Best Wife & Mommy

Re: Celeb/parenting question

I agree with you. It is ridiculous.

Posted 7/23/08 7:28 AM
 

carolyns4cupcakes
C ♥'s F

Member since 2/07

6456 total posts

Name:

Re: Celeb/parenting question

Posted by MelToddJulia

I agree with you, I think its crazy!



ITA

Posted 7/23/08 7:42 AM
 

Ang-Rich
Beyond Compare

Member since 5/05

17988 total posts

Name:

Re: Celeb/parenting question

I agree - I think it's overboard.

I have pictures of DH when he was about 1 or 2 sitting on his Dad's lap while FIL smoked a cigarette...also have one where he is holding the empty carton.

FIL is the BEST dad I know and we find these pictures hilarious...he feels bad seeing them but DH treasures these pictures.

Of course they don't make the cover of a magazine. I do feel bad for celebrities....when it comes to family I feel that they definitely deserve privacy...their kids should not be hounded by the media.

Posted 7/23/08 8:23 AM
 

Ang-Rich
Beyond Compare

Member since 5/05

17988 total posts

Name:

Re: Celeb/parenting question

Posted by rojerono

ETA: You also open yourself up to opinions by posting on HERE. People tend to think I am much nicer than I actually am based on the things I have posted here.Chat Icon




Nope - never would I believe that you are anything but sweet here or IRL.

Posted 7/23/08 8:28 AM
 

chelle
It's a Good Life

Member since 8/06

15404 total posts

Name:
Isn't it obvious?

Re: Celeb/parenting question

Posted by jules

Posted by prncss

Here's my issue with criticizing celebs' parenting abilities: In reality, it's not just celebs that people are criticizing, it's all of us. Like, when I read on the celeb board people saying to get Suri off the bottle already or get her hair out of her face, I know damn well those same people are thinking those things about every parent and child that age. Why would you say it about a celeb and not your friend whose 2 yr old still has a bottle?
So, to me, it just gives me insight as to how judgemental people are about everyday people, not just celebs.



I TOTALLY agree with this. And this bothers me even more i guess. That you see soo many people comment on the most miniscule, lamest things. As if we are ANYBODY to criticize?

God help us if there was a camera taking pics of every moment with our child.

And when did, as i said above, a snap shot explain anything?

I would bet that if ANYONE of the moms here posted that they were such a bad mom today "I drove my DC home and TOTALLY forgot to lock her in the carseat". WOW how many people here would say "awwww you aren't a bad mom, mistakes happen" (and rightfully so, i would be one of them)

BUT...if there was a pic on the cover of the post of Jamie Lynns DC in the carseat without the belt locked HOLEY MOLEY boy would she be ripped to screds

just seem two faced to me



ITA!!! Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 7/23/08 8:34 AM
 

HillW9608
Hello Summer!

Member since 5/08

5916 total posts

Name:
Hill

Re: Celeb/parenting question

ITA, FH and I are both smokers (me not as much anymore, but still when we go out) and when I saw that yesterday I felt so bad for her as a mother.

The fact that someone went out of there way to climb a tree or whatever to take the shot is sickening. She is obvoiusly trying hard to get her life back on the right track and its amazing the things that people will do to ruin that for her.

Honestly, I dont think the lttle kid grabbing the pack of cigarettes is anything to go crazy about. He's 2!!!! Do people think he's going to light them up and smoke them? Chat Icon

Posted 7/23/08 8:39 AM
 

annie
This is how I play basketball!

Member since 6/05

1980 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Celeb/parenting question

It's nice to see that the ladies here can have an open & honest discussion without actually judging each other in the process. I find all the responses very interesting.

Posted 7/23/08 10:35 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
HELP! I need a new BD plan. ***UPDATE and new question maybeamommy 7/21/08 18 TTC
shoes question... related to parenting JTK 10/11/06 8 Parenting
My first post on parenting! Question... NS1976 8/29/06 9 Parenting
Spinoff to a question on Parenting--money related Melbernai 8/13/06 1 Families Helping Families ™
Dumb question,, not parenting related pooh12 5/2/06 3 Parenting
My first parenting question- When did you take the baby to a store? Shelly 4/19/06 27 Parenting