Car Seat ?

Posted By Message

donegal419
St. Gerard, pray for us.

Member since 7/07

7650 total posts

Name:
K

Car Seat ?

Which is safer if you only have one child in a carseat?

in the rear in the middle

or

in the rear on the side?

we initially had DD in the middle. We then had to move her to the side when we were moving some big items and had to put one side seat and the middle seat down. i have asked several people... some people say the middle is the safest in case you were hit from the side and other say that if you were hit from behind (which is more common) the side is safer as there is nothing in front of them in the middle to absorb impact.

What are you all doing? right now, she's behind the driver's seat, which makes it really handy when i have to put her in and out. also having to get myself all the way in and lug her and the seat out was a bit cumbersome when she was in the middle.
TIA!

Message edited 2009-10-17 02:15:06.967000.

Posted 10/17/09 2:13 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Car Seat ?

They say the middle is safest, but that isn't true for all cars, I'd check your manual to see what they say.

My DS was in the middle in his infant seat, but has been on the passenger since we switched him to the convertibleChat Icon Chat Icon

ETA-I just saw that you have her on the driver's side, I'd still check the manual, but I was always told (and my husband is an FDNY EMT and took a course on this ) to put DC on the passenger side so that when you are parked, it is easier to get her out on the street side...

Message edited 2009-10-17 07:27:26.053000.

Posted 10/17/09 7:26 AM
 

CarSeatSafety
LIF Adolescent

Member since 3/09

689 total posts

Name:
CarSeatChris

Re: Car Seat ?

Posted by donegal419

Which is safer if you only have one child in a carseat?

in the rear in the middle

or

in the rear on the side?

we initially had DD in the middle. We then had to move her to the side when we were moving some big items and had to put one side seat and the middle seat down. i have asked several people... some people say the middle is the safest in case you were hit from the side and other say that if you were hit from behind (which is more common) the side is safer as there is nothing in front of them in the middle to absorb impact.

What are you all doing? right now, she's behind the driver's seat, which makes it really handy when i have to put her in and out. also having to get myself all the way in and lug her and the seat out was a bit cumbersome when she was in the middle.
TIA!



This is one of the hardest questions to answer because there are factors that come into play that make the center not the best choice. The owners manual of the car is sometimes the worst place for an answer because many times it lists the center as the best location when in fact it is not.

A properly installed seat on the side is always better than a questionable center installation. But notice the terms I used. A PROPERLY installed seat.

When it come to problems in the center, the following must be considered before center installation, regardless of the owners manual.

Is ther center LATCH? The most common mistake with center installation is that the majority of cars on the road do not have center LATCH locations. You do not need to use LATCH to install a seat, but you cannot LATCH a seat in the center that does not have a dedicated center location. You will have to use the center seat belts to install the seat.

If using the seatbelt in the center, is the seat belt path wider than the seat base? The path is where the seatbelt comes out and where it buckles in. This must be wider than the base to allow proper installation.

For rear facing, does the seat interfere or hit the front seats? If you cannot adjust the front seat, especially the driver seat, to fit a rear facing seat, the center cannot be used.

How does the seat split in the rear? Does the seat fall into the crack of the spilt? If so, the seat cannot go in the middle.

For many SUV's, does the center seat have a hinge in the way? Does the seat sit on top of a fixed seat belt that does not allow the seat to be secured?

There are many other considerations that we use to decide on center installation. If you place the seat on the side, the passenger side is the best choice. There are fewer crashes on the passenger rear than the driver rear.

Posted 10/17/09 8:44 AM
 

donegal419
St. Gerard, pray for us.

Member since 7/07

7650 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Car Seat ?

Posted by CarSeatSafety

Posted by donegal419

Which is safer if you only have one child in a carseat?

in the rear in the middle

or

in the rear on the side?

we initially had DD in the middle. We then had to move her to the side when we were moving some big items and had to put one side seat and the middle seat down. i have asked several people... some people say the middle is the safest in case you were hit from the side and other say that if you were hit from behind (which is more common) the side is safer as there is nothing in front of them in the middle to absorb impact.

What are you all doing? right now, she's behind the driver's seat, which makes it really handy when i have to put her in and out. also having to get myself all the way in and lug her and the seat out was a bit cumbersome when she was in the middle.
TIA!



This is one of the hardest questions to answer because there are factors that come into play that make the center not the best choice. The owners manual of the car is sometimes the worst place for an answer because many times it lists the center as the best location when in fact it is not.

A properly installed seat on the side is always better than a questionable center installation. But notice the terms I used. A PROPERLY installed seat.

When it come to problems in the center, the following must be considered before center installation, regardless of the owners manual.

Is ther center LATCH? The most common mistake with center installation is that the majority of cars on the road do not have center LATCH locations. You do not need to use LATCH to install a seat, but you cannot LATCH a seat in the center that does not have a dedicated center location. You will have to use the center seat belts to install the seat.

If using the seatbelt in the center, is the seat belt path wider than the seat base? The path is where the seatbelt comes out and where it buckles in. This must be wider than the base to allow proper installation.

For rear facing, does the seat interfere or hit the front seats? If you cannot adjust the front seat, especially the driver seat, to fit a rear facing seat, the center cannot be used.

How does the seat split in the rear? Does the seat fall into the crack of the spilt? If so, the seat cannot go in the middle.

For many SUV's, does the center seat have a hinge in the way? Does the seat sit on top of a fixed seat belt that does not allow the seat to be secured?

There are many other considerations that we use to decide on center installation. If you place the seat on the side, the passenger side is the best choice. There are fewer crashes on the passenger rear than the driver rear.




wow...thanks so much for this. I will be doing a little investigating this afternoon and see what seems to be best for our car.

We have a 2009 Hyundai Elantra Touring (baby is most often in that) and a 2000 Dodge Stratus. Know anything about those cars and carseats? We have a Chicco Key Fit.

Posted 10/17/09 11:55 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
What side of the car is your convertible car seat on? MrsS2005 8/12/09 12 Parenting
website that tells you what car seat works with your car?? MrsBurtch525 5/2/09 3 Pregnancy
Car seat (for a CAR - NO SUV)... tell me why clwp 11/9/08 17 Parenting
Car Seat Question. Do you and DH have one in each car or... whyteach 5/17/08 26 Parenting
Since I am a city-girl and never owned a car, I have a car seat question.. BigB 11/9/07 1 Parenting
Car Seat spinoff--- when will you install yours in your car? Cookiegobbler 4/16/07 18 Pregnancy