Can they do this??? *UPDATE

Posted By Message

maybeamommy
Blessed beyond belief

Member since 10/07

17048 total posts

Name:

Can they do this??? *UPDATE

We found a great apartment through craigslist. The apartment was listed by a property management company. We viewed the apartment - loved it - and applied (cost $70 application fee). We applied last week on Wednesday.

The property management company said that the owner said they were waiting to hear back from the bank about a loan modification or something of the sort, and they should have an answer for us within 2-3 days (I was told this yesterday).

Today, I'm on walkscore.com and I see the apartment we applied for listed for $350 MORE and not through the property management company.

Can they do this? The listing was posted on craigslist the day AFTER we applied!

Are we just screwed now?


***UPDATE:
Guess we're screwed. The property management company told me that the owner has decided to take the property off the rental market. They said we can have a copy of our report, so hopefully that will save us the cost of getting future credit reports for another place.

WAHHHH Chat Icon I'm so sad because we really loved that place! I thought I could finally have a nice, big kitchen (even just for a year)!

Message edited 2012-06-27 13:04:14.170000.

Posted 6/26/12 12:43 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Can they do this???

I don't know for sure, but I'm thinking that if you have paperwork and the listing showing the price at the cheaper amount and you get the apartment, they 'should' honor that price.

Posted 6/26/12 12:46 PM
 

tara73
carseat nerd

Member since 11/09

3669 total posts

Name:
Buttercup

Can they do this???

At the very least, you should have your application fee returned.

There may be some legal issues between the owners and property management company, but that wouldn't involve you. I would contact the property management company and ask them point blank why the apartment is listed for more.

Posted 6/26/12 12:51 PM
 

Pomegranate5
LIF Adult

Member since 2/11

4798 total posts

Name:
Pomegranate5

Re: Can they do this???

So it sounds like they are trying to see if they can get more for the apartment? Is the owner doing this without the property managers knowlege?

Unfortunately, you haven't signed a lease yet. You've only applied. So if they get another tenant willing to pay $350 more, you might be out of luck.

Posted 6/26/12 12:53 PM
 

jams92

Member since 1/12

6105 total posts

Name:

Re: Can they do this???

Posted by Pomegranate5
Unfortunately, you haven't signed a lease yet. You've only applied. So if they get another tenant willing to pay $350 more, you might be out of luck.



this! my sister just went through this recently....applied, viewed and was ready to sign a lease when they told her the rent was another $100 more per month. there was nothing she could do about it.
i would keep a copy of the listing you saw just to have and in case you get approved or are still interested show it to them and see what they say. i would not mention that you saw it for $350 more...i would just assume it was the same price you saw it posted for and continue with that mentality (just make sure you dont sign a lease with a higher amount)

Posted 6/26/12 12:57 PM
 

alli3131
Peanut is here!!!!!!

Member since 5/09

18388 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Can they do this???

Posted by maybeamommy

We found a great apartment through craigslist. The apartment was listed by a property management company. We viewed the apartment - loved it - and applied (cost $70 application fee). We applied last week on Wednesday.

The property management company said that the owner said they were waiting to hear back from the bank about a loan modification or something of the sort, and they should have an answer for us within 2-3 days (I was told this yesterday).

Today, I'm on walkscore.com and I see the apartment we applied for listed for $350 MORE and not through the property management company.

Can they do this? The listing was posted on craigslist the day AFTER we applied!

Are we just screwed now?



It could also be a scam. WHen I looked for apts there were people that would take other peoples listings and put them up as their own and for a different price and then try and rent them.

Posted 6/26/12 1:46 PM
 

MrsRinNY
LIF Infant

Member since 4/10

117 total posts

Name:
Gina

Re: Can they do this???

Posted by alli3131

Posted by maybeamommy

We found a great apartment through craigslist. The apartment was listed by a property management company. We viewed the apartment - loved it - and applied (cost $70 application fee). We applied last week on Wednesday.

The property management company said that the owner said they were waiting to hear back from the bank about a loan modification or something of the sort, and they should have an answer for us within 2-3 days (I was told this yesterday).

Today, I'm on walkscore.com and I see the apartment we applied for listed for $350 MORE and not through the property management company.

Can they do this? The listing was posted on craigslist the day AFTER we applied!

Are we just screwed now?



It could also be a scam. WHen I looked for apts there were people that would take other peoples listings and put them up as their own and for a different price and then try and rent them.



Be very careful about scams. The people YOU spoke to could be a scam!

Posted 6/26/12 2:18 PM
 

TiggerBounce
The Prince & Princess

Member since 7/05

4939 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Can they do this???

My MIL had an apartment to rent. She asked me to list it for her on Craigs List. The day I listed it a "realtor" called, looked at it and showed it to a few people.
He did not tell us to take our ad down. He made is own Craigs List ad for $100/mo more - b/c eh felt we could get more for it than what we listed it at.

Posted 6/26/12 2:19 PM
 

maybeamommy
Blessed beyond belief

Member since 10/07

17048 total posts

Name:

Re: Can they do this??? *UPDATE

Updated in O/P

Posted 6/27/12 1:04 PM
 

JandJ1224

Member since 6/06

5911 total posts

Name:
Jannette

Re: Can they do this??? *UPDATE

Posted by TiggerBounce

My MIL had an apartment to rent. She asked me to list it for her on Craigs List. The day I listed it a "realtor" called, looked at it and showed it to a few people.
He did not tell us to take our ad down. He made is own Craigs List ad for $100/mo more - b/c eh felt we could get more for it than what we listed it at.



That is insane. Did you sign an agreement with that agent to rent the property?

Posted 6/27/12 1:14 PM
 

dlj97
LIF Adult

Member since 7/10

4399 total posts

Name:

Re: Can they do this??? *UPDATE

Did you put the application fee on a credit card? I would try to stop the charge. That is total BS. I would definitely make more of an issue - they should absolutely be refunding your application fee. If you failed the background check, then fine, but if the owner just changed his mind that is not your problem. If they wont refund your money then it is definitely a scam.

Posted 6/27/12 1:40 PM
 

maybeamommy
Blessed beyond belief

Member since 10/07

17048 total posts

Name:

Re: Can they do this??? *UPDATE

Posted by dlj97

Did you put the application fee on a credit card? I would try to stop the charge. That is total BS. I would definitely make more of an issue - they should absolutely be refunding your application fee. If you failed the background check, then fine, but if the owner just changed his mind that is not your problem. If they wont refund your money then it is definitely a scam.



We paid the application fee to the rental agency though...

And now the owner is telling the rental agency that they do not want to list the property anymore (meanwhile I SAW it on craigslist for $350 more). The property management company is definitely a legitimate one... I think the owner is just screwing everyone over.

Posted 6/27/12 1:43 PM
 

TiggerBounce
The Prince & Princess

Member since 7/05

4939 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Can they do this??? *UPDATE

Posted by JandJ1224

Posted by TiggerBounce

My MIL had an apartment to rent. She asked me to list it for her on Craigs List. The day I listed it a "realtor" called, looked at it and showed it to a few people.
He did not tell us to take our ad down. He made is own Craigs List ad for $100/mo more - b/c eh felt we could get more for it than what we listed it at.



That is insane. Did you sign an agreement with that agent to rent the property?



No - he said he gets paid by the tenatt (ie: Broker fee)

Posted 6/27/12 1:50 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Can they do this??? *UPDATE

Posted by maybeamommy

Posted by dlj97

Did you put the application fee on a credit card? I would try to stop the charge. That is total BS. I would definitely make more of an issue - they should absolutely be refunding your application fee. If you failed the background check, then fine, but if the owner just changed his mind that is not your problem. If they wont refund your money then it is definitely a scam.



We paid the application fee to the rental agency though...

And now the owner is telling the rental agency that they do not want to list the property anymore (meanwhile I SAW it on craigslist for $350 more). The property management company is definitely a legitimate one... I think the owner is just screwing everyone over.



Unless I'm reading it wrong, the property management company charged you a fee for an apartment they don't have the right to rent out. The owner would have signed a contract with the property management office for a certain time period, no?

Posted 6/27/12 2:21 PM
 

maybeamommy
Blessed beyond belief

Member since 10/07

17048 total posts

Name:

Re: Can they do this??? *UPDATE

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by maybeamommy

Posted by dlj97

Did you put the application fee on a credit card? I would try to stop the charge. That is total BS. I would definitely make more of an issue - they should absolutely be refunding your application fee. If you failed the background check, then fine, but if the owner just changed his mind that is not your problem. If they wont refund your money then it is definitely a scam.



We paid the application fee to the rental agency though...

And now the owner is telling the rental agency that they do not want to list the property anymore (meanwhile I SAW it on craigslist for $350 more). The property management company is definitely a legitimate one... I think the owner is just screwing everyone over.



Unless I'm reading it wrong, the property management company charged you a fee for an apartment they don't have the right to rent out. The owner would have signed a contract with the property management office for a certain time period, no?



I honestly don't know about their contract or how that works. I'm sorry, I'm totally naive and incompetent when it comes to these sort of things! Should I be asking something to the property management company?

Posted 6/27/12 2:41 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Can they do this??? *UPDATE

Posted by maybeamommy

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by maybeamommy

Posted by dlj97

Did you put the application fee on a credit card? I would try to stop the charge. That is total BS. I would definitely make more of an issue - they should absolutely be refunding your application fee. If you failed the background check, then fine, but if the owner just changed his mind that is not your problem. If they wont refund your money then it is definitely a scam.



We paid the application fee to the rental agency though...

And now the owner is telling the rental agency that they do not want to list the property anymore (meanwhile I SAW it on craigslist for $350 more). The property management company is definitely a legitimate one... I think the owner is just screwing everyone over.



Unless I'm reading it wrong, the property management company charged you a fee for an apartment they don't have the right to rent out. The owner would have signed a contract with the property management office for a certain time period, no?



I honestly don't know about their contract or how that works. I'm sorry, I'm totally naive and incompetent when it comes to these sort of things! Should I be asking something to the property management company?



I don't really know how rental companies work but I would write a letter to whomever you paid the fee & tell them you need a full refund. It's not that you didn't qualify. It's that it's rented. It's that they aren't renting it - which means they didn't have a contract with start & end dates on it. Not your problem, theirs.

Make sure that letter is legal sounding.
Chat Icon

Message edited 2012-06-27 14:44:30.933000.

Posted 6/27/12 2:44 PM
 

dlj97
LIF Adult

Member since 7/10

4399 total posts

Name:

Re: Can they do this??? *UPDATE

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by maybeamommy

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by maybeamommy

Posted by dlj97

Did you put the application fee on a credit card? I would try to stop the charge. That is total BS. I would definitely make more of an issue - they should absolutely be refunding your application fee. If you failed the background check, then fine, but if the owner just changed his mind that is not your problem. If they wont refund your money then it is definitely a scam.



We paid the application fee to the rental agency though...

And now the owner is telling the rental agency that they do not want to list the property anymore (meanwhile I SAW it on craigslist for $350 more). The property management company is definitely a legitimate one... I think the owner is just screwing everyone over.



Unless I'm reading it wrong, the property management company charged you a fee for an apartment they don't have the right to rent out. The owner would have signed a contract with the property management office for a certain time period, no?



I honestly don't know about their contract or how that works. I'm sorry, I'm totally naive and incompetent when it comes to these sort of things! Should I be asking something to the property management company?



I don't really know how rental companies work but I would write a letter to whomever you paid the fee & tell them you need a full refund. It's not that you didn't qualify. It's that it's rented. It's that they aren't renting it - which means they didn't have a contract with start & end dates on it. Not your problem, theirs.

Make sure that letter is legal sounding.
Chat Icon



ITA. They can't charge a fee on an application for an apt they don't have the right to rent out.

Did you sign anything with them? Can you email it to me?

Posted 6/27/12 3:54 PM
 

Pomegranate5
LIF Adult

Member since 2/11

4798 total posts

Name:
Pomegranate5

Re: Can they do this??? *UPDATE

That sucks. I hope they refund your application fee, but it sounds like everyone is getting screwed by the owner in this situation.

Posted 6/27/12 4:00 PM
 

tara73
carseat nerd

Member since 11/09

3669 total posts

Name:
Buttercup

Can they do this??? *UPDATE

I agree, they owe you the app fee back. Also, in addition, they can take the credit inquiries off your report as well. This is important since inquiries lower your score.

The only only other thing I would accept would be them locating you a suitable replacement for a reduced broker's fee, IMO.

Posted 6/27/12 4:28 PM