Can they do this?

Posted By Message

05mommy09
Family of 5!

Member since 5/05

15364 total posts

Name:
<3 Mommy <3

Can they do this?

My lease is up at the end of the month.

I just rec'd the correct renewal agreement last week, obviously it needs to be returned and signed asap (def. before the 28th of this month)

We recently put an offer in on a house, and are waiting to hear back before renweing our lease.

Yesterday I call the office to see if I have any other options, like 6 months or month to month. The woman replies with no, but if I want to write a letter to management I can see if it gets approved, she states it would be at least an extra $450/month to do so.

I explain my situation and in so many words, state that Im unsure If Ill be renewing.

She snaps back by saying, I have to give 60 days notice, and since 60 days have past, Im liable for another year...

I state that as of now, I have not signed a lease, they have NOTHING with my signature on it, and how the hell could I give 60 days notice, when I didnt even get 60 days notice on what my increase would be...

The woman got nasty and said she wasnt arguing with me, so I asked to speak to someone in management. She said they wont talk to you. You can put all this in writing and mail the letter to them.

I asked who to address the letter to, and she said "management". She refused to give the name or telephone number of someone above her. I refuse to put anything in writing.

Am I really liable for another year even though they dont have a contract with me?

They woman kept saying "how can you not know what you are doing, its 2 weeks away"

Ummm- dont you think I wish I knew what was going on????

In the grand scheme of things, Im more than likely going to have to renew- even if they except my offer, I dont think Ill know within the next few days...

I also asked about the penalty for breaking my lease, in the event I had to.

She said I still be responsible for the full years rent of 20k.

Chat Icon

I just dont get it...

Posted 6/20/08 7:09 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
  |   Prudential Douglas Elliman Real Estate

jax1023
LIF Adult

Member since 3/07

1165 total posts

Name:
Jackie

Re: Can they do this?

It all depends on what is says in your lease. I am in a similar situation, but it now appears our contract is going to go through.

Our lease states that if you do not notify the management company in writing of the fact that you are not renewing by 60 days before the end of the lease, it is assumed that you are renewing.

And if you do break the lease you are responsible for all rent on the remainder of your lease until they are able to re rent the apartment.

Read your lease, usually it is up to you to contact them for any changes. They word it as it is not their responsibility to contact you.

Posted 6/20/08 7:26 AM
 

05mommy09
Family of 5!

Member since 5/05

15364 total posts

Name:
<3 Mommy <3

Re: Can they do this?

Last years lease says to give 60 days notice, but it says nothing about what happens if you dont...

Posted 6/20/08 7:38 AM
 

TJLealand3
LIF Adolescent

Member since 6/07

839 total posts

Name:
Thomas

Re: Can they do this?

I say stay till they kick you out and let them take you to court to try and recoup the money. You are in and they can try to collect a years rent, if it's not in your contract, they are not gonna get it.

Posted 6/20/08 8:12 AM
 

TreAnt427
-

Member since 8/06

8652 total posts

Name:
Tracy

Re: Can they do this?

I was going through the same thing with my apt complex. We had to give 60 days notice to break the lease.

Don't worry about being responsible for the full year. I asked the same question when we moved in and got the same answer.

Then when it was time to break the lease, I read the lease agreement and it said that we would lose our security and pay a two month penalty and that's just what we did.

Check the copy of your lease, it should all be in there.

Posted 6/20/08 8:22 AM
 

qtdimps231
LIF Toddler

Member since 11/07

477 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Can they do this?

i just broke my lease and gave 30 days notice. legally 30 days notice is all you need to give. ask judge judy. Chat Icon as long as you stay in the apartment they would need to evict you which would cost them more money then you just living out your remaining days. What i did was renewed my lease, but got a letter from my management company saying i can leave as long as i give notice and i will get my security deposit back. i sent them a certified letter stating the on or about date ill be leaving and where to send my security deposit.

good luck!

Posted 6/20/08 8:40 AM
 

05mommy09
Family of 5!

Member since 5/05

15364 total posts

Name:
<3 Mommy <3

Re: Can they do this?

Posted by qtdimps23

i just broke my lease and gave 30 days notice. legally 30 days notice is all you need to give. ask judge judy. Chat Icon as long as you stay in the apartment they would need to evict you which would cost them more money then you just living out your remaining days. What i did was renewed my lease, but got a letter from my management company saying i can leave as long as i give notice and i will get my security deposit back. i sent them a certified letter stating the on or about date ill be leaving and where to send my security deposit.

good luck!



Ultimately this would be my best option, but unfortunately the mystery man behind the term management- is not reached....

Posted 6/20/08 9:14 AM
 

qtdimps231
LIF Toddler

Member since 11/07

477 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Can they do this?

did you try googling the company to see if there is another number you can call?

Posted 6/20/08 9:29 AM
 

HeatherRose
Life is Good :)

Member since 11/07

6605 total posts

Name:

Re: Can they do this?

I would try to call corporate, and find out your options. I know a complex we just looked at said if after your year lease is up and you need to do month to month its $500 additional on top of the monthly rent, but if you just need it for a month or so, its worth it rather then commiting to a year lease.

I would aslo look into NYS lease laws, and see what your rights are as a tenant, they can't just make up their own laws. And as for whatever you agreed to in your lease, its about to expire, so it doesn't matter anymore-I would think.

Good luckChat Icon

Edited to Add: heres a link I found
Link to NYS re: leasing apartments etc.

Message edited 2008-06-20 11:25:08.223000.

Posted 6/20/08 11:20 AM
 

EmmaNick
*

Member since 12/06

16001 total posts

Name:
*

Re: Can they do this?

Your current lease should specify a dollar amount to be paid each month for a "holdover" (the period of time you live there without a lease). Check that first. If it does, you can legally just pay that amount each month without signing a new lease. Most leases have that clause.

Posted 6/20/08 10:04 PM
 

KateDevine
*

Member since 6/06

24950 total posts

Name:

Re: Can they do this?

They can claim to do anything. But they can't even legally try to start eviction proceedings til you haven't paid rent for 30 days.

Check your last lease for things like security deposit, etc. Sometimes they say you forfeit that if you don't give x amount of time notice, but I can't imagine you haven't be pay for an entire year?Chat Icon

Posted 6/20/08 10:12 PM
 

DUCKS2001
Then there was 2

Member since 3/06

5696 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: Can they do this?

the place i rent at lets you break the lease BUT you have to give them 60 days and you have to give them an extra months rent and then after the 60 days we will get our deposit back.. i would read your lease.

Posted 6/20/08 10:44 PM