C-Sections in the News Today...
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
C-Sections in the News Today... For anyone who didn't see on the news tonight: |
|
Posted 1/7/09 6:50 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: C-Sections in the News Today... there is so much I could say about this but I'll keep my mouthshut for fear of flaming daggers being thrown at me |
|
Posted 1/7/09 6:52 PM
|
|
|
Re: C-Sections in the News Today... good article!!! Thanks for posting!!! |
|
Posted 1/7/09 7:00 PM
|
|
|
Re: C-Sections in the News Today... Interesting article - although the article (or perhaps the study) does not seem to tell the whole story. It would be interesting to see if for that 1/3 that are performed too early how many are actual scheduled, elective c-sections (with no medical reason) and how many are more emergent situations. |
|
Posted 1/7/09 7:49 PM
|
|
|
Re: C-Sections in the News Today... Posted by stickydust Interesting article - although the article (or perhaps the study) does not seem to tell the whole story. It would be interesting to see if for that 1/3 that are performed too early how many are actual scheduled, elective c-sections (with no medical reason) and how many are more emergent situations. For instance, I delivered DD at just barely 38 weeks by c-section because of pre-eclampsia. I have 2 friends who had early c-sections (one at 34 weeks and one at 37 weeks) both because the went into pre-term labor with breech babies. I just do not know anyone who just said "hey I am just going to have a c-section at 37 weeks - just for the heck of it". So it would be interesting to see the entire study. ITA! There seems to be a lot of information missing from this article! I doubt many OBs today would perform purely elective c-sections before 39 weeks- mine certainly won't. |
|
Posted 1/7/09 7:57 PM
|
|
|
Re: C-Sections in the News Today... Posted by annie Posted by stickydust Interesting article - although the article (or perhaps the study) does not seem to tell the whole story. It would be interesting to see if for that 1/3 that are performed too early how many are actual scheduled, elective c-sections (with no medical reason) and how many are more emergent situations. For instance, I delivered DD at just barely 38 weeks by c-section because of pre-eclampsia. I have 2 friends who had early c-sections (one at 34 weeks and one at 37 weeks) both because the went into pre-term labor with breech babies. I just do not know anyone who just said "hey I am just going to have a c-section at 37 weeks - just for the heck of it". So it would be interesting to see the entire study. ITA! There seems to be a lot of information missing from this article! I doubt many OBs today would perform purely elective c-sections before 39 weeks- mine certainly won't. Unfortunately there are a lot of physicians that will perform elective c-sections and do them before 40 weeks.....Its really scary!! |
|
Posted 1/7/09 7:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: C-Sections in the News Today... Very interesting article -- thanks for posting |
|
Posted 1/7/09 8:00 PM
|
|
|
Re: C-Sections in the News Today... Posted by annie Posted by stickydust Interesting article - although the article (or perhaps the study) does not seem to tell the whole story. It would be interesting to see if for that 1/3 that are performed too early how many are actual scheduled, elective c-sections (with no medical reason) and how many are more emergent situations. For instance, I delivered DD at just barely 38 weeks by c-section because of pre-eclampsia. I have 2 friends who had early c-sections (one at 34 weeks and one at 37 weeks) both because the went into pre-term labor with breech babies. I just do not know anyone who just said "hey I am just going to have a c-section at 37 weeks - just for the heck of it". So it would be interesting to see the entire study. ITA! There seems to be a lot of information missing from this article! I doubt many OBs today would perform purely elective c-sections before 39 weeks- mine certainly won't. THATS FOR SURE! I had an emerg c and i know damn well i didnt say woooooooohoooooooooo open me up
|
|
Posted 1/7/09 8:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: C-Sections in the News Today... Well, from seeing this story on two different news broadcasts-- it was a little weird. Since *most* scheduled C's are due to medical necessity-- and some people NEED to have one before 39 weeks, as it would be too dangerous to wait any later. |
|
Posted 1/7/09 8:16 PM
|
|
|
Re: C-Sections in the News Today... I don't know why but I had thought many women elected to get c-sections because they didn't want to go through vaginal childbirth. I remember posting about it a few months ago and EVERYONE thought it was a very bad idea because recover/risk was so much worse. |
|
Posted 1/7/09 8:19 PM
|
|
|
Re: C-Sections in the News Today... I do not think that this article gave the whole story at all. The article talks about ACOG guidelines and implies that early deliveries are against the guidelines in a lot of cases. Well, I had a C-section at 36 weeks and, for my particular medical issue, this is the ACOG guideline. I have a huge issue with articles like this because so many people who had read things like this have suggested that I just did not want to carry my baby to term. My 36 weeker had some problems at the beginning. The thing to remember is that he is fine now and carrying to term posed a risk of fatality for both of us. I would never elect to have a 36 week baby if I did not have to. I had a very long talk with one of the NICU doctors and she told me what she has seen with people who had my condition and waited to deliver. 6 days in the NICU seemed like hell to me but it was nothing compared to what could have been. |
|
Posted 1/8/09 1:02 AM
|
|
|
Re: C-Sections in the News Today... A reputable OB would do an amnio to confirm maturation of the lungs prior to 39weeks. |
|
Posted 1/8/09 8:23 AM
|
|
|
Re: C-Sections in the News Today... Posted by randella They also didn't talk at all about women who deliver naturally earlier than 39 weeks either-- we see it on here ALL the time. Why would the babies be at a different risk based on how they deliver? The difference is that when you deliver vaginally that much of the fluid is squeezed out of the babies lungs when they come thru the vaginal canal. This was described to me when we thought DD might need surgery and they said it would be better for her to come via vaginally rather than csection if she needed surgery immediately. So I think the difference is that when you go naturally the baby might still have problems but it is coming on its own rather than with a section when you decide when it should make an appearance so between the fluid and the fact the baby might not be done cooking is what I think they are getting at. I think this article is missing a large part of the story. There are many people who had emergency sections with their 1st for medical reasons and they didn't choose when they had it. Also with the risks of VBAC these days many moms are not candidates for VBAC so they have to choose a csection even if it is not their desired method of delivery. Most doctors won't schedule you for a csection before 39 weeks unless there is a medical necessity. |
|
Posted 1/8/09 8:28 AM
|
|
|
Re: C-Sections in the News Today... Posted by randella They also didn't talk at all about women who deliver naturally earlier than 39 weeks either-- we see it on here ALL the time. Why would the babies be at a different risk based on how they deliver? I guess the presumption is that babies who are delivered naturally before 39 weeks are "ready" or else the mom would not have gone into labor. I agree that the article is missing some points and I'd like to read the whole thing. But since I am facing a scheduled section for this baby I'm glad this article came out and now I can do some more research before scheduling my date. Thanks for posting. |
|
Posted 1/8/09 8:31 AM
|
|
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Did anyone get their Nassau Dept. of Assessment 2010/2011 letter today? | Mommy2Boys | 1/7/09 | 53 | Home |
| I have my 1st pediatric interview today.. (Updated- We Found Our Pediatrician)) | ReiRei13 | 1/7/09 | 8 | Pregnancy |
| Got some news today... | Texas4Good | 3/1/06 | 9 | Parenting |
| Got such SAD news at work today!! | Mrs-Boop | 12/21/05 | 21 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| On to 100 mgs of Clomid....but a friend of mine had some good news today.... | BigB | 11/28/05 | 4 | Infertility |
| Got good news today | sunny | 10/21/05 | 9 | Pregnancy |












