Bottled Water vs. Filtered Water

Posted By Message

guitargirl
LIF Zygote

Member since 7/10

31 total posts

Name:

Bottled Water vs. Filtered Water

Which do you think it safer to drink? I normally buy bottled water (usually the Wild by Nature brand), but DH has been complaining how it tastes like plastic. He says the filtered water that comes out of our fridge tastes better. To me, the filtered water is just tap water, I don't know how much junk the filter gets out of it, so I prefer the bottled water...but the plastic taste concerns me too.

Posted 8/16/10 11:36 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Bottled Water vs. Filtered Water

I think it's all crap and don't think any of it is safer than anything else.

I'd love to see a study though!

If anything, I would trust the filtered water more than the bottled water-I just don't trust that that stuff isn't coming out of an unfiltered tap.

Posted 8/16/10 11:48 AM
 

Acerone
I hate ants and ugly people.

Member since 3/07

6437 total posts

Name:
Chris

Re: Bottled Water vs. Filtered Water

Here's an old test I did a while back

Message edited 2010-08-16 12:39:19.850000.

Posted 8/16/10 11:57 AM
 

Kaitlyn747
LIF Toddler

Member since 6/10

399 total posts

Name:
Kaitlyn

Re: Bottled Water vs. Filtered Water

The bottled water is no safer/worse than tap.

Tap water actually should be better for you because it has fluorine in it.

But there have been NUMEROUS Studies about bottle v. tap.

Most of the Studies (IMHO) have come up that bottle water is the SAME thing you get from the tap.

Plus, living in NYC, we have the BEST water in the country.

Posted 8/16/10 11:58 AM
 

MockingJay
Ring out the old...

Member since 9/08

1312 total posts

Name:
Ring in the new!

Re: Bottled Water vs. Filtered Water

Tap water (depending on where you live) is most likely cleaner than bottled water as long as its filtered.

If you live on LI, there are rigorous standards for the tap water quality here and in most locations (you have to double check with your town) the LI Water company is providing your water. Where, with bottled water, its "natural spring" or "filtered water" (which is essentially bottled tap H20).

Spring water is not regulated like tap water is and could have a whole host of contaminants in it, then you have the plastic from the bottles to contend with, which when heated will release dioxin (MAJOR cancer causing bad guy) into the water and give you that "plastic" taste- this is also why you should never leave a plastic water bottle in your car when its hot and then drink it.

IMHO- filtered water hands down is the way to go. Its also better for the environment.

I would suggest you get yourselves an aluminum or BPA free plastic water bottle and fill up from your fridge daily instead of buying bottles. It'll save you $$ and probably some nasty crap entering your body.

HTHChat Icon

Posted 8/16/10 12:03 PM
 

Andrewz00
Look! I changed it!

Member since 4/10

1789 total posts

Name:
Andrew

Re: Bottled Water vs. Filtered Water

ever check the source of the water on some of the bottles?

Dasani for example...local municipal water supplies which is then filtered....

i would say they are probably about equal...

Posted 8/16/10 12:31 PM
 

HeatherRose
Life is Good :)

Member since 11/07

6605 total posts

Name:

Re: Bottled Water vs. Filtered Water




I remember this thread

do you know what those ppm actually are? or is there a test that tells us that? I think everoyne is assuming those ppm are bad, but they could be a mix of bad and good or all good for all we know, so maybe we actually want the number higher not lower??

Posted 8/16/10 12:38 PM
 

Acerone
I hate ants and ugly people.

Member since 3/07

6437 total posts

Name:
Chris

Re: Bottled Water vs. Filtered Water

Posted by HeatherRose




I remember this thread

do you know what those ppm actually are? or is there a test that tells us that? I think everoyne is assuming those ppm are bad, but they could be a mix of bad and good or all good for all we know, so maybe we actually want the number higher not lower??



No we don't so for me I don't like it... Are we taking a chance or not by them not listing what's really in that bottled water... BPA comes from plastic so does it come in those plastic water bottles? Who knows...

Posted 8/16/10 12:45 PM
 

HeatherRose
Life is Good :)

Member since 11/07

6605 total posts

Name:

Re: Bottled Water vs. Filtered Water

Posted by Acerone

Posted by HeatherRose




I remember this thread

do you know what those ppm actually are? or is there a test that tells us that? I think everoyne is assuming those ppm are bad, but they could be a mix of bad and good or all good for all we know, so maybe we actually want the number higher not lower??



No we don't so for me I don't like it... Are we taking a chance or not by them not listing what's really in that bottled water... BPA comes from plastic so does it come in those plastic water bottles? Who knows...



I agree. I don't understand how all foods have to list whats in them, but bottled water doesn't? any other drink you drink lists it.... odd
Ad for the BPA- you would think the FDA would ban this as well, isn't it banned in baby bottles?

Posted 8/16/10 12:59 PM
 

beachgirl
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

7967 total posts

Name:
sara

Re: Bottled Water vs. Filtered Water

I always wonder about this too and I end up going round and round in circles and then buying the bottled water. The thing that scares me about LI water is the high incidence of breast cancer on LI and the possible link - I know it might not be true but its always there in my head when I am trying to decide.

Also the filtered water that comes out of my fridge is never ice cold and I need my water to be ice cold - sure I could dispense some and put it in my fridge to get ice cold but thats a royal PITA.

Posted 8/16/10 4:55 PM
 

Andrewz00
Look! I changed it!

Member since 4/10

1789 total posts

Name:
Andrew

Re: Bottled Water vs. Filtered Water

Posted by beachgirl

I always wonder about this too and I end up going round and round in circles and then buying the bottled water. The thing that scares me about LI water is the high incidence of breast cancer on LI and the possible link - I know it might not be true but its always there in my head when I am trying to decide.

Also the filtered water that comes out of my fridge is never ice cold and I need my water to be ice cold - sure I could dispense some and put it in my fridge to get ice cold but thats a royal PITA.



ice cubes?? Chat Icon

Posted 8/16/10 5:00 PM
 

guitargirl
LIF Zygote

Member since 7/10

31 total posts

Name:

Re: Bottled Water vs. Filtered Water

Posted by beachgirl

The thing that scares me about LI water is the high incidence of breast cancer on LI and the possible link - I know it might not be true but its always there in my head when I am trying to decide.




I think about this too, plus when I was a kid we had gold fish that kept dying from odd diseases...when we used tap water for their fish tank. Once we switched to bottled spring water our fish lived long lives. Makes me wonder what it does to our insides if it can so easily kill gold fish. So ever since then my family never drank tap. But hearing the feedback here, makes me wonder how much safer the spring water is.

And now soda apparently causes cancer, so I guess we're screwed no matter what we drink, lol.

Posted 8/17/10 9:04 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Quick ? - If you use bottled water for your baby to drink do you boil it? Goobster 6/4/09 12 Parenting
Update: Water test from Bottled to LI Tap. Added Pur Water Dispenser Acerone 9/12/08 46 Families Helping Families ™
Do you notice this if you boil water for your DC? - Especially bottled water users itsbabytime 5/2/08 11 Parenting
Do you use bottled water to mix the formula? Cookiegobbler 6/23/07 16 Parenting
I KNOW it's been asked a million times but do you boil your filtered tap water? Goobster 8/5/09 16 Parenting
Silly poll about bottled water MsMBV 8/10/06 25 Families Helping Families ™