bottle dilemma

Posted By Message

CoutureMaMa
nicholas is one!!

Member since 9/07

6081 total posts

Name:
Michelle

bottle dilemma

ok so i registered for dr browns bottles; got the newborn starter kit and then a bunch of extra bottles and nipples. then i saw on here that people were raving about the tommee tippee bottles so i went to bru and i got the newborn starter kit for these bottles as well. figured i'd try both. so what do i do? do i open both starter kits and wash/sterilize both and try them? and if i decide to go with the tommee tippee, return the extra dr browns stuff i have?

Posted 3/19/10 5:41 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: bottle dilemma

Posted by CoutureMaMa

ok so i registered for dr browns bottles; got the newborn starter kit and then a bunch of extra bottles and nipples. then i saw on here that people were raving about the tommee tippee bottles so i went to bru and i got the newborn starter kit for these bottles as well. figured i'd try both. so what do i do? do i open both starter kits and wash/sterilize both and try them? and if i decide to go with the tommee tippee, return the extra dr browns stuff i have?




this is EXACTLY my situation. unless i LOVE one over the other, ill use both interchangably Chat Icon

Posted 3/19/10 5:44 PM
 

Tine73

Member since 3/06

22093 total posts

Name:
*********

Re: bottle dilemma

I would open/sterilze one brand first. If he doesn't take to them, then open the second brand.

OR go buy a couple individual bottles from both since they are cheaper then the set and then return the set and extras of the brand you don't use.

I used Dr. Brown's last time with no problem. I did get some Tommy Tippee bottles bc of all the raves. We'll see what happens!

Posted 3/19/10 5:49 PM
 

OrganicMama
So in love with my little man!

Member since 6/08

5172 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: bottle dilemma

It's been suggested to me by other BTDT moms to buy individuals bottles of different brands to find out what DC takes to. The sets seem to be pretty expensive to shell out money for if it's something that you'll only use once (if DC doesn't like them).

For me, I registered for the Born Free glass bottle set, but will buy an individual bottle to try it. I'm BFing exclusively so I don't really need them starting at day 1.

Posted 3/19/10 8:58 PM
 

munchkinbugs
My little loves!

Member since 1/06

8093 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: bottle dilemma

Posted by Tine73


OR go buy a couple individual bottles from both since they are cheaper then the set and then return the set and extras of the brand you don't use.



I would do this. I got the gift set of Avent bottles for DD and wound up hating them. Total waste.

Posted 3/19/10 9:41 PM
 

CoutureMaMa
nicholas is one!!

Member since 9/07

6081 total posts

Name:
Michelle

Re: bottle dilemma

and what makes you or dc like or dislike a bottle? or like one better than the other? how do u know this? Chat Icon

Posted 3/19/10 9:50 PM
 

MamaB17
Back for baby #3

Member since 5/09

4065 total posts

Name:
N

Re: bottle dilemma

I was going to get a few different types of bottles but decided against it. I went with the tommee tippe only. If Chat Icon doesn't like them I will then try something else. I am only going to wash/sterlize a single one to see how it works, that way I can return everything else that is not opened.

Posted 3/19/10 10:17 PM
 

munchkinfacemama
LOVE

Member since 11/07

15800 total posts

Name:
<FONT COLOR="#FF0099">Michelle</FONT>

Re: bottle dilemma

Mich, i agree with PPs who said buy a single or double of both brands and try that first. Tommee Tippee do have less parts and we love them-but more so because Miss Bean is BFing and it is closer to breast. I know that is not so much a concern, but I love them!

Posted 3/20/10 6:23 AM
 

BabysMomma29
Due with Baby #2!

Member since 10/08

2004 total posts

Name:
Tricia aka MattandTricia07

Re: bottle dilemma

I only registered for Tommee Tippee since they were recommended for people who are going to BF as well. If Chat Icon doesn't like them, then I will return the rest. I don't plan on opening all of the bottles.

Posted 3/20/10 8:52 AM
 

skprmiss
Loud is fun!!

Member since 5/05

1504 total posts

Name:
M

Re: bottle dilemma

I used the Dr browns with my 2 yr old...had no prob other then the clean and all the parts, then the whole bpa scare and ended up throwing them away and changing to the advent with dropins. With this baby i got the tommee's but the anti colic and in my bru that did not come in a starter kit. I would return the tommee starter kit and get some 5 oz's and 9 oz's with the anti colic tubing. If dd#2 doesn't go for these I will just resort to the advents that i still have from dd#1.

Posted 3/20/10 9:18 AM
 

CucumberGirl
You give the best smiles!

Member since 1/09

2398 total posts

Name:
M~

Re: bottle dilemma

I had also heard that you should try a few different types of bottles, but IMO that was impractical once I tried to do that. A newborn eats every 2-3 hours and the starter packs only have 3 bottles in them. So... if you open one hoping to try them out, you'd be washing bottles all day on top of being exhausted and sleep-deprived and feeding every few hours. Also, it may take a few weeks before you discover a problem so you could be trying a few bottles out for weeks. Some issues you can catch right away - leaky bottles, too fast or too slow flow, etc., but others, like gas or fussiness may take awhile to show themselves. Anyway, I ended up opening my entire Dr. Brown's box and the 3-pack of 4 ounce bottles I got and when I thought DD might have an issue, I tried out the Ventaire (opened two packs - one wasn't enough bottles to not be a pain - but fyi, two 3-packs are the same price as the deluxe box for this brand), which she seemed to like and which made her a little less gassy but the flow was way too slow (she'd fall asleep after getting maybe an ounce in 30 minutes so she was constantly hungry) and the fast nipple was too fast (she was drowning) so I stopped using them. I went back to the Dr. Brown's, started using Mylicon for a little while to see if it helped. In the meantime, DD's system matured and she became a better eater, more skilled if you will, took in less air, and now the original bottles are fine. The Ventaire won't go to waste though - I plan on using them both once she can handle the fast flow nipple since she did not appear to have a preference in terms of the nipple between the two. Since having her, I've also read in several books that FF/bottle-fed babies generally don't have a preference - they'll pretty much take any bottle and tolerate switches. BF babies tend to be more particular so if you're FF or pumping, this is also much less of an issue and all you'll be looking out for are things like leaks and the speed of the flow, ease of use for you (some people complain about all the parts for the Dr. Brown's). And even BF babies get less particular as time goes on and as they become better at BF so my advice would be not to drive yourself crazy with the search for the perfect bottle and figuring out DC's preference. It may be more trouble than it's worth since the worst is you'll end up with some bottles that you may not use until DC's a bit older and doesn't care so much. HTH.

Posted 3/20/10 11:05 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
BF & Bottle Questions... AndreaLMT 9/7/05 8 Parenting
Dr. Browns bottle leaking dree 8/24/05 8 Parenting
Bottle warmers Sp4747 8/15/05 10 Parenting
how old to hold own bottle? momoftwins 8/5/05 10 Parenting
Bedtime Bottle? ddunne2 8/3/05 0 Families Helping Families ™
Breastfeeding/bottle feeding in the hospital Eireann 6/29/05 4 Parenting