Black Tie Wedding

Posted By Message

cupcake
LIF Infant

Member since 8/11

135 total posts

Name:

Black Tie Wedding

If a wedding invitation says "Black Tie", is it absolutely necessary to follow that dress code? In other words, is it rude for either a man or woman to wear what they normally would to a regular wedding?

Posted 1/11/15 8:23 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

GoodThoughts
Dreams do come true

Member since 2/12

2259 total posts

Name:

Re: Black Tie Wedding

If it says Black Tie, I would respect that and dress accordingly.

Black Tie optional is a different story and it's fine to wear regular wedding attire if you so choose.

Posted 1/11/15 8:25 PM
 

LuckyStar
LIF Adult

Member since 7/14

7274 total posts

Name:

Black Tie Wedding

I had a black tie wedding and the majority of guests wore regular wedding attire, which was fine with me. My motivation for putting black tie was that we had a lot of out of town guests who I am positive would not have known what to wear and I didn't want them to feel uncomfortable if they were underdressed (for example, DH and I went to a wedding in which a few of the girls who were also invited to our wedding were wearing flip flops).

A dark suit for a man and a cocktail dress for a woman are perfectly acceptable.

Posted 1/11/15 8:28 PM
 

JJ2014
LIF Adolescent

Member since 11/14

686 total posts

Name:

Re: Black Tie Wedding

Posted by GoodThoughts

If it says Black Tie, I would respect that and dress accordingly.

Black Tie optional is a different story and it's fine to wear regular wedding attire if you so choose.



I totally agree with this. I called my wedding "Black Tie" because I wanted to encourage guests to break out the Tux and Gowns. Granted many woman wore short because that is what was in style. I would say about 97% of the men wore a Tux or Black Suit, White Shirt and Black Tie and all the women wear dressed beautifully! The other 3% wore either a light colored suit or a blue shirt.

Posted 1/11/15 8:36 PM
 

EricaAlt
LIF Adult

Member since 7/08

22665 total posts

Name:
Erica

Re: Black Tie Wedding

Posted by JJ2014

Posted by GoodThoughts

If it says Black Tie, I would respect that and dress accordingly.

Black Tie optional is a different story and it's fine to wear regular wedding attire if you so choose.



I totally agree with this. I called my wedding "Black Tie" because I wanted to encourage guests to break out the Tux and Gowns. Granted many woman wore short because that is what was in style. I would say about 97% of the men wore a Tux or Black Suit, White Shirt and Black Tie and all the women wear dressed beautifully! The other 3% wore either a light colored suit or a blue shirt.



This. Exactly

It was s late Saturday night wedding. Surprisingly everyone pretty much dressed appropriately. I still love looking at pics and seeing everyone all decked out.

Posted 1/11/15 8:53 PM
 

JME78
LIF Adult

Member since 11/09

3672 total posts

Name:

Re: Black Tie Wedding

Posted by cupcake

If a wedding invitation says "Black Tie", is it absolutely necessary to follow that dress code? In other words, is it rude for either a man or woman to wear what they normally would to a regular wedding?



I think its rude to tell your guests how to dress - so I don't think its rude to wear what you normally would wear to a regular wedding.

Most folks in NY know how to dress for a wedding. Before he owned a tux my DH wore a suit to a black tie wedding, it was not an issue.

Posted 1/11/15 9:00 PM
 

EatingMyVeggies

Member since 1/12

6667 total posts

Name:

Black Tie Wedding

Many people list black tie, but don't really host a black tie event. I feel like unless an event is truly black tie, it shouldn't be on the invite.
Guests also know how to dress. You can't help the uncle who shows up in khakis (there is always one!)

Posted 1/11/15 9:45 PM
 

shellbebaby
So In Love!

Member since 8/11

1487 total posts

Name:
Michelle

Black Tie Wedding

I used the term black tie invited because my friends from PA, NH, etc would have shown up in sundresses if I hadn't. 90% of the women were in long gowns and looked beautiful. Most of my sundress friends were in short cocktail dresses which was fine with me. 20% of the men were in tuxes! mostly my parents friends who actually welcomed the chance yo pull their tuxes out. The rest of the men were in suits, mostly black but some lighter since it was August.

I did have a down time between the church and reception. I think that's necessary if your going black tie because no one wants to sit in church in a gown.

When I've seen black tie on wedding invites I follow it by usually wearing a long gown or a very fancy cocktail dress. If men don't have tuxes, black suits are acceptable. If you don't have a black suit break out your best one, but jackets and ties are a must.

One thing to watch out for, in NY it is common for many venues (if they are country clubs) to not allow men in without a jacket and tie. So if they are saying black tie, I'd make sure minimally the guys got a jacket and tie. I went to a wedding once at a club where one of the guests didn't wear a jacket and wasn't let in. Although most of these places will loan you a tie.

Message edited 2015-01-12 04:59:14.500000.

Posted 1/12/15 4:56 AM
 

shellbebaby
So In Love!

Member since 8/11

1487 total posts

Name:
Michelle

Re: Black Tie Wedding

Duplicate post

Message edited 2015-01-12 04:58:33.757000.

Posted 1/12/15 4:58 AM
 

Lillykat
going along for the ride...

Member since 5/05

16253 total posts

Name:

Re: Black Tie Wedding

Where is the wedding?

My personally feeling is that it is the couples' special day, not the guests. If they want a certain dress/feel that is their choice. Their party/their dime. It is not rude as some have stated to want a certain type of party dress. A guest can choose to not attend if they do not want to wear black tie. You are not required to go. If it said black tie preferred/optional then I see that as optional but a suggestion to help those who might not be used to NY dress. Just as some people want an adult only wedding, or a white party, the host has every right to request certain dress, just as a guest can choose not to attend.

Posted 1/12/15 8:43 AM
 

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: Black Tie Wedding

Posted by Lillykat

Where is the wedding?

My personally feeling is that it is the couples' special day, not the guests. If they want a certain dress/feel that is their choice. Their party/their dime. It is not rude as some have stated to want a certain type of party dress. A guest can choose to not attend if they do not want to wear black tie. You are not required to go. If it said black tie preferred/optional then I see that as optional but a suggestion to help those who might not be used to NY dress. Just as some people want an adult only wedding, or a white party, the host has every right to request certain dress, just as a guest can choose not to attend.



But when you say it's their dime- it really isn't in this case because you are forcing men to rent a tux- at a cost.
Most men don't own tuxes.
I don't mind if you want people to dress a certain way at your wedding, I get it, but not if it costs me more to attend.
Unless they should deduct the price of the tux rental from the gift.
Then it's the couples' dime.
Otherwise it's the guests' dime.

Posted 1/12/15 8:47 AM
 

Lillykat
going along for the ride...

Member since 5/05

16253 total posts

Name:

Re: Black Tie Wedding

Posted by NervousNell

Posted by Lillykat

Where is the wedding?

My personally feeling is that it is the couples' special day, not the guests. If they want a certain dress/feel that is their choice. Their party/their dime. It is not rude as some have stated to want a certain type of party dress. A guest can choose to not attend if they do not want to wear black tie. You are not required to go. If it said black tie preferred/optional then I see that as optional but a suggestion to help those who might not be used to NY dress. Just as some people want an adult only wedding, or a white party, the host has every right to request certain dress, just as a guest can choose not to attend.



But when you say it's their dime- it really isn't in this case because you are forcing men to rent a tux- at a cost.
Most men don't own tuxes.
I don't mind if you want people to dress a certain way at your wedding, I get it, but not if it costs me more to attend.
Unless they should deduct the price of the tux rental from the gift.
Then it's the couples' dime.
Otherwise it's the guests' dime.



I respectfully disagree. One is not forced to do anything. By accepting the invitation you are making a choice to attend the wedding and whatever goes along with that (maybe a plane ticket, a hotel night, a babysitter, appropriate dress). If you don't want to rent, you politely decline the invitation. There is no requirement that one attend a wedding, unless you are in it, then you would be renting or buying a dress anyway. Many shop for a dress to wear to a wedding I see it as part of accepting the invitation. Yes a wedding is fun, but I think by saying yes, you accept whatever it is that goes with it. Just like if you were invited to a costume party or say a white party you would need to get a costume or an outfit, if you didn't want to do that you would decline right?

I think it is wrong to deduct gift money thereby penalizing the host, but then I think people should give what they can afford. Only on here have I heard of covering your plate. I just don't see the issue. I understand people don't want to rent or get a tux, I have been there, but then politely decline, we have. Btw I had a black tie preferred wedding because I wanted people to dress, but knew some wouldn't and didn't want to lose them. But I know some put black tie hoping to reduce some of their numbers because they know some won't rent one.

Posted 1/12/15 10:23 AM
 

chilltocam
LIF Adult

Member since 11/11

9141 total posts

Name:

Re: Black Tie Wedding

Posted by NervousNell

Posted by Lillykat

Where is the wedding?

My personally feeling is that it is the couples' special day, not the guests. If they want a certain dress/feel that is their choice. Their party/their dime. It is not rude as some have stated to want a certain type of party dress. A guest can choose to not attend if they do not want to wear black tie. You are not required to go. If it said black tie preferred/optional then I see that as optional but a suggestion to help those who might not be used to NY dress. Just as some people want an adult only wedding, or a white party, the host has every right to request certain dress, just as a guest can choose not to attend.



But when you say it's their dime- it really isn't in this case because you are forcing men to rent a tux- at a cost.
Most men don't own tuxes.
I don't mind if you want people to dress a certain way at your wedding, I get it, but not if it costs me more to attend.
Unless they should deduct the price of the tux rental from the gift.
Then it's the couples' dime.
Otherwise it's the guests' dime.



Exactly! Not eveyone has a tux or gown just sitting in their closet. If you're doing it (putting "black tie") on an invite, just kow that you are very often requiring your guests to spend extra money to attend your event.

Posted 1/12/15 10:24 AM
 

Paramount
Sweet!

Member since 7/12

4289 total posts

Name:

Black Tie Wedding

My wedding was Black Tie optional. I know a lot of my FIL/MIL friends owned tuxedos, and we thought it might be fun and elegant to let those who owned break them out.

I had plenty of people in regular suits and that was just fine.

If someone showed up in flip flops and sun dress so be it. It would have been their choice and would not ruin my day...

We have friends who had a black tie wedding. I bought a dress and DH rented a tux. That's what they wanted, we accepted the invite and therefor accepted their request on how to dress.

The answer to your question is this: If you have a cute cocktail type dress then wear that. A woman can get a way with a lot of stuff that is black tie-esq. If you can afford to rent a tux then do it. If you cant have your DH wear a dark suit. Basically if you can afford it then do it. If you cant then go dressed nicely and elegantly.

Posted 1/12/15 10:58 AM
 

AllyMally
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/13

881 total posts

Name:
Alyson

Black Tie Wedding

Yes I think it's rude. Attire on an invitation, in my opinion, is there for a reason. When I get a wonky invite I try to think back to my wedding and how in my wedding bubble I was wrapped up in everything being perfect. Looking back years later it seems silly, but it's their day not yours. Black tie is black tie for a reason.

Posted 1/12/15 11:24 AM
 

jams92

Member since 1/12

6105 total posts

Name:

Re: Black Tie Wedding

if your normal wedding attire is a nice dress (cocktail or gown) and a dark suit for your DH - i think you are fine.
We put black tie on our wedding invite (or maybe it was optional - i dont recall) but it was bc DH had many out of town family members who have warn jeans, khakis and flip flops to weddings. we by no means wanted people to rent tuxedos but we didnt want jeans either.

Posted 1/12/15 11:36 AM
 

EatingMyVeggies

Member since 1/12

6667 total posts

Name:

Black Tie Wedding

The wedding day, IMO, isn't all about the couple once they invite people. In fact, they are hosting the event and receiving guests. Etiquette dictates that the comfort of guests be attended to. Would you rather have a loved one their in a suit and tie or have them decline because they don't own a tuxedo? Essentially, what would you want there more? A loved one or a tuxedo? (Not directed to anyone per se, but just general commentary).

I can't find the list online at the moment, but from
What I recall, unless I'm incorrect ...black tie means plated meal (not buffet), Saturday evening after 6, live band (not dj), white glove service,
Top shelf liquor, etc .. That said, many people misuse the term black tie.

Posted 1/12/15 11:45 AM
 

chilltocam
LIF Adult

Member since 11/11

9141 total posts

Name:

Re: Black Tie Wedding

Posted by EatingMyVeggies

The wedding day, IMO, isn't all about the couple once they invite people. In fact, they are hosting the event and receiving guests. Etiquette dictates that the comfort of guests be attended to. Would you rather have a loved one their in a suit and tie or have them decline because they don't own a tuxedo? Essentially, what would you want there more? A loved one or a tuxedo? (Not directed to anyone per se, but just general commentary).




Was just coming on to say the same thing. To me, if you've invited someone to your wedding it's because having them celebrate with you is important. I would have hated for someone to not accept an invitation to my wedding because they couldn't afford the "proper" attire. It was way more imprortant for me to have the people I love there, than to worry about what they were wearing.

Posted 1/12/15 11:57 AM
 

Pumpkin1
LIF Adult

Member since 12/05

3715 total posts

Name:

Re: Black Tie Wedding

I never see the point of "Black Tie Required" because it is placing an additional cost upon your guests. If I saw that, I would think my husband needed to rent a tux and, in turn, unless it was someone really close, I would decline the invitation because it adds an additional $100 to the cost of the night.

If you want people to wear formal attire, then say "Formal Attire Required" or "Black Tie Optional." IMHO, it is pretentious.

Posted 1/12/15 12:13 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Black tie optional - Sunday night wedding....what is appropriate to wear? to wear? quasi3 4/19/12 1 Fashion & Beauty!
Black Tie Wedding! (now with a picture of the dress I want to wear) jozieb0925 6/16/11 15 Fashion & Beauty!
Black Tie Wedding - Does the dress have to be floor length? Calla 9/14/08 5 Fashion & Beauty!
What do I wear to a wedding that is "Black Tie Invited"? Rycois 9/1/08 12 Fashion & Beauty!
Attire to Black Tie wedding at The Breakers in Florida UPDATE: I bought a dress! johnsae 10/3/07 36 Fashion & Beauty!
Can I wear a knee length kimono dress to a black tie wedding? randella 3/15/07 17 Fashion & Beauty!