Bjorn vs Ergo?

Posted By Message

Sparrow
LIF Adult

Member since 11/10

6826 total posts

Name:

Bjorn vs Ergo?

I'm debating on getting a carrier for DD. She's almost 5 months old, do you think it's still worth it? What age do you normally use them until? I have a Moby but it just never really clicked for us. She tolerates it for a few minutes but then I think she feels too confined and starts fussing. I've only tired it around the house, not brave enough to try it in public.

I'm looking at the Bjorn and the Ergo, wondering which is better? I was almost sold on the Ergo but then noticed that LO can't face outwards . . . That seems like a major drawback BUT people seem to like them. I'd love to hear anyone's opinions that has used either.

Posted 8/22/11 9:14 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Bjorn vs Ergo?

Definitely the Ergo. The bjorn hurt my back after wearing it for 2 minutes. I can wear the ergo with no pain at all, it is so much more comfortable. Baby is fine facing in, she looks out at everything all around or falls asleep against my chest (she's also 5 months).
When my twins were around 1, I used it in the back carry which was awesome. I'll do the same with DD2.

Posted 8/22/11 9:37 PM
 

drwifettc
LIF Adult

Member since 6/10

2348 total posts

Name:

Re: Bjorn vs Ergo?

I have both, I personally like the Ergo better, I think it's more comfortable and I love the pocket! Unfortunately, despite my best efforts my DD hates facing inwards. She loves being in the Bjorn, but I can't imagine I'm going to able to keep her in that for very long.

Posted 8/22/11 9:41 PM
 

janedoe
3 GIRLS!!!!

Member since 8/09

3184 total posts

Name:

Re: Bjorn vs Ergo?

Haven't tried the ERgo but Love my bjorn - DH wanted this when we registered and I made fun of him but it has really come in handy. DD is 14 months old and on the petite side so we are still able to use it - we used it this summer for the Yankee game and the Bronx zoo.

Posted 8/22/11 9:45 PM
 

hdrd0411
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

1923 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: Bjorn vs Ergo?

I loved the Bjorn better b/c baby can face out. That was a big deal with both of my kids...hated facing in!

Posted 8/22/11 10:03 PM
 

Shelleybean11
Mommy of 2!

Member since 12/08

11013 total posts

Name:

Re: Bjorn vs Ergo?

DS def preferred the Bjorn. He liked to face out. I preferred the Ergo, much easier on my back!

Posted 8/22/11 10:31 PM
 

4PsInaPod
My Loves <3

Member since 7/07

10079 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Bjorn vs Ergo?

LOVED our bjorn! DS loved facing out, he was a nosy baby!

Posted 8/22/11 10:32 PM
 

hope316
LIF Adult

Member since 8/07

1085 total posts

Name:

Re: Bjorn vs Ergo?

I love my ergo my ds always ;oves to cuddle and sleep while in the ergo. it was nice to "hide" him from all the distractions. I actually wished i had it this weekend walking on the beach because I used a beach towel for my 2yr as a poor excuse for a wrap.

Funny about the moby wrap b/c I love my SIL and want it if I ever have another

Posted 8/22/11 11:01 PM
 

dmc
LIF Infant

Member since 4/06

133 total posts

Name:
DANIELLE 'D&D'

Re: Bjorn vs Ergo?

Don't know about the ergo but the bjorn is the only way I can get anything done in my house or do anything w/ my older dc....my dd constantly needs to be held Chat Icon

Posted 8/22/11 11:29 PM
 

Gertyrae
Peace out Homies!

Member since 5/05

20046 total posts

Name:
Gerty ®

Re: Bjorn vs Ergo?

Ergo all the way and I had both - still use the Ergo occasionally and DS is 2.
The biggest problem with the Bjorn is that it only holds them to 25 pounds - which is generally what they weigh at around a year. The Ergo holds them until they are 40 pounds and is so much easier on your back.

We still use the Ergo if we go for hikes in the woods to carry DS when he gets tired.

Posted 8/23/11 12:25 AM
 

maiden
Whoa!

Member since 5/08

1814 total posts

Name:
T

Re: Bjorn vs Ergo?

I LOVE the Ergo.

Posted 8/23/11 2:11 AM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: Bjorn vs Ergo?

Ergo...
we both hated the bjorn

Borrowed a friend's Ergo when baby was 15 mos old...love it.

Posted 8/23/11 6:46 AM
 

raspbrryswl
LIF Infant

Member since 7/10

248 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Bjorn vs Ergo?

Had the Ergo...DS hated it
Got the Bjorn and he has no problem with it. DH loves the Bjorn so much better. There are different Bjorn and some come with great back support. DH wore it for 3 hours straight with no back problems.

Posted 8/23/11 9:29 AM
 

DSLaff
Team One of Each

Member since 10/09

2150 total posts

Name:
Dana

Re: Bjorn vs Ergo?

love the bjorn so much , ds can face forward and enjoy looking at everything, the ergo is great for when they are newborns but its quite hot in these summer months. the bjorn was awesome for the beach this summer i would put ds in it and then load up the stroller (city select) with all the chairs umbrellas and beach bag. I was still hands free and able to carry things plus a good workout lugging my 24 lbs baby lol

the first 4 months I had ds in the bjorn everyday to do laundry or take a walk and had him face me, I am not sure why so many people have back pain but I had 0

Message edited 2011-08-23 09:44:22.563000.

Posted 8/23/11 9:43 AM
 

ABCiverson
<3 my family

Member since 1/06

7465 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: Bjorn vs Ergo?

I don't have either one of those but I recently ordered an Action Baby Carrier(ABC) from Lilroos.com. I love it! I carry my 20lb 4.5 month old for hours and it doesn't hurt my back at all. My DH also likes using it. Also comes in adorable prints.

Posted 8/23/11 9:44 AM
 

tara73
carseat nerd

Member since 11/09

3669 total posts

Name:
Buttercup

Re: Bjorn vs Ergo?

Love the Ergo, so much more versatile than the Bjorn.

DD2 is 20 lbs and doesn';t like facing in so I throw her on my back in the Ergo. She loves it and it's better for her hips.You can also do a hip carry in the Ergo, or wear baby on your front. And it can be used longer as another poster mentioned. I've also used it for DD1, she is 3.5

I have a friend with the ABC, she LOVES it. She had borrowed my Ergo and liked the ABC better.

I've also used a BabyHawk that was really comfy.

Article on why Bjorn/Snugli carriers aren't the best choice

Posted 8/23/11 9:51 AM
 

Tiggeruth
I am a mom :-)

Member since 6/06

3433 total posts

Name:
Heidi

Re: Bjorn vs Ergo?

I dont like my Bjorn and have been using the Moby wrap. I want to get the Ergo bc she can be on my back and it will hold up to a larger weight. THankfully DD doens't seem to mind being in either carrier.

Posted 8/23/11 11:08 AM
 

lucyloo
nope

Member since 1/06

9758 total posts

Name:

Re: Bjorn vs Ergo?

I had both. I used the Bjorn when DS was under 6 months. After that I used the Ergo and it was great. No back pain. I was still using it after his 1st bday!

Posted 8/23/11 11:48 AM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: Bjorn vs Ergo?

I have both and the Ergo wins IMO hands down.

The Bjorn killed my back, my moose of a DS outgrew it months ago but I still carry him now sometimes (14 months old and 27+ pounds) when I'd rather not bring a stroller. He doesn't seem to mind facing me.

Posted 8/23/11 12:52 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
If you have the Ergo carrier, which one do you have and why? Trying to figure out the best one for me & Aa. peabody 5/22/11 6 Parenting
Should I Keep these baby carriers or return one?? Moby Wrap and Ergo bride07 2/2/11 4 Parenting
which backpack? Ergo or Beco? dree 7/13/10 3 Parenting
Would you buy an Ergo carrier for a 9 month old... alisonggg 4/30/10 2 Parenting
Ergo Baby Carrier Users - Who Used it with the Infant Insert? mrswask 3/25/10 11 Parenting
ergo baby carriers? or any recs would be appreciated pickles16 11/2/09 8 Parenting