birthday party vent

Posted By Message

Mags1227
Just a mommy ...

Member since 10/10

2665 total posts

Name:
M

birthday party vent

sorry that this will be long but soo annoyed!

DS will be turning 1 on labor day weekend.

it took me weeks to convince DH to have three small parties instead of one huge one since i am unemployed and money is very tight. (one for his fmaily the day before, a bbq for our friends and their kids the day of, and one for my family the day after.) he didn't like the separation but agreed it was a good choice since we could never fit everyone together in our apartment.

MIL was very unhappy but pretended to go along with it. then the comments started. she even went so far as to get SIL to talk to us about it. after many hours of discussion and crying (and wine) i had no choice but to give in. we were not going to have one huge party.

it took us weeks to find a suitable catering hall. we booked it. need to guarantee at least 50 people for a sunday afternoon. at $50 a person, we're looking at at least $2500 spent on this party just for the hall. MIL is like don't worry you'll get it all back. i didn't bother explaining that i was not going to reimburse myself with money DS got for his birthday. that money is his not mine. (JMO)

it's 1 week before rsvp's are due. almost 2/3 of people have yet to rsvp. and a lot of the ones that did, said no! people who we were SURE were coming! like DHs close cousins and friends. 1st birthdays are apparently a HUGE deal in DHs culture. yet it seems that applies to everyone but my son!!! i feel like i just wasted so much money doing something i never wanted to do to begin with. i'm also disappointed in these so called friends and family. i'm ready to just cut them all out.

thanks for reading. just really frustrated!

Posted 7/28/11 9:49 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: birthday party vent

oh no!!!!!!!

ughhhh what is the deal with people? My DH has missed so many events due to work and yet, he STILL came to my cousin's daughter's first birthday party - that is how important we feel it is!

but i guess we are in the minority, sorry that this is happening to you.

Chat Icon

Posted 7/28/11 9:58 AM
 

MrsA714
Baby #2 is here!

Member since 8/07

8806 total posts

Name:

Re: birthday party vent

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 7/28/11 10:00 AM
 

Newly1
I love my baby boy!

Member since 6/08

2804 total posts

Name:
H

Re: birthday party vent

I'm so sorry! If MIL was that adamant about having a big party, SHE should have helped to foot the bill! Hopefully people have just forgotten to RSVP, people are terrible about that!

Posted 7/28/11 10:03 AM
 

tara73
carseat nerd

Member since 11/09

3669 total posts

Name:
Buttercup

Re: birthday party vent

2500 for a 1st birthday? That's insane. If MIL wanted this so badly SHE should be footing the bill! The way you had it set up, it would have cost you a fraction of that!

Posted 7/28/11 10:38 AM
 

lbw
I am ONE !!!!!

Member since 5/07

1560 total posts

Name:
Lisette

Re: birthday party vent

I agree with the pp, if they want to be so involved, then they should offer to contribute. Honestly, I dont know how some people feel the need to interfere with your decisions over you DC. I know about having to give in, and I have, but I am now starting to put my foot down on a lot of things...it's hard, but I have to stand my ground.

Posted 7/28/11 11:39 AM
 

Mags1227
Just a mommy ...

Member since 10/10

2665 total posts

Name:
M

Re: birthday party vent

thanks ladies!
i'm thinking this is the last birthday i'm doing for a looong time! since DS was born labor day weekend, i'm thinking from now on the three of us will go away for the long weekend. just us. not caring how MIL feels about it.

the real problem i have is that many of these people had a baby the same year (or soon after) as i did. I'm thinking they will also be having first birthday parties and will expect us to show up. i hate being petty, but i really am thinking of not attending any of them. why should i? their child is more important than mine?

besides, i have no job and my unemployment will most likely be ending in september. i can't afford to shell out $200-300 a party. (that's right. that's how much you give to a one year old. or rather the parents since they keep the money for themselves!)

Posted 7/28/11 12:47 PM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: birthday party vent

Posted by Mags1227

thanks ladies!
i'm thinking this is the last birthday i'm doing for a looong time! since DS was born labor day weekend, i'm thinking from now on the three of us will go away for the long weekend. just us. not caring how MIL feels about it.

the real problem i have is that many of these people had a baby the same year (or soon after) as i did. I'm thinking they will also be having first birthday parties and will expect us to show up. i hate being petty, but i really am thinking of not attending any of them. why should i? their child is more important than mine?

besides, i have no job and my unemployment will most likely be ending in september. i can't afford to shell out $200-300 a party. (that's right. that's how much you give to a one year old. or rather the parents since they keep the money for themselves!)



I was wondering how you would "get back" teh cost of the party!! Chat Icon

I know we invited 100 people to the baptism and "got back" more than we paid for hte party - but it didnt matter since of course we just put it in the bank for DD!

Even our at home party, I bet it is coming out to about $1000 Chat Icon


ETA: This is her last party until her communion. On the Saturday closest to her birthday we will have cake with one set of grandparents, on the Sunday near her birthday we will have cake with my parents and on the actual day we will go out and do something just me DH and DD.

Message edited 2011-07-28 12:51:05.677000.

Posted 7/28/11 12:50 PM
 

nycgirl
Angels!

Member since 3/09

7721 total posts

Name:

Re: birthday party vent

I had this fight too:

DH wanted a mega-party with about 200 people. His family spent about $10,000 for their kid's baptisms.

It was an ugly fight. Screaming, yelling, ect.

I won! We are having a small party for immediate family & a handful of friends in our backyard.

What I use (for your future) is MY KID, MY DECISION.

Posted 7/28/11 1:55 PM
 

ajsmomliz
LIF Infant

Member since 5/11

107 total posts

Name:

Re: birthday party vent

I am so sorry you have to go through this. At the end of the day, your child is not going to remember anything about their first birthday and to go through all of this to appease an inlaw is a shame. In the future, remind yourself that the day is about your DS. I wish someone would have offered a backyard for you to at least save you some $$$$. Good Luck!

Posted 7/28/11 10:29 PM
 

lynnd126
LIF Adult

Member since 3/11

2630 total posts

Name:

Re: birthday party vent

Sorry this happened but I'm a little confused why you went from one EXTREME to another.

IMO if you were going to give in to the party with everyone at once idea maybe you should have considered borrowing a friend's big backyard or renting a k of c for a few hundred bucks?

Posted 7/28/11 10:32 PM
 

Mags1227
Just a mommy ...

Member since 10/10

2665 total posts

Name:
M

Re: birthday party vent

Posted by lynnd126

Sorry this happened but I'm a little confused why you went from one EXTREME to another.

IMO if you were going to give in to the party with everyone at once idea maybe you should have considered borrowing a friend's big backyard or renting a k of c for a few hundred bucks?




i don't think they were extremes necessarily. it went from three small parties to one big one.

we don't really have a friend with a backyard big enough to accommodate all the people we had to invite (85) so we didn't go that route. (there was one possibility but all the way in commack and almost everybody lives in brooklyn so the drive was too much. plus i doubt the yard would fit everyone anyway)

k of c type of places- they are not really an option for us because of the problems that would involve with catering. ils would want russian food, my parents would want polish food and it would be one big fight AGAIN. plus the set-up, clean-up aspect would be killer on me. (i know it sounds silly, but there is a certain standard to these parties and buffet is usually not an option. it's considered tacky and cheap. don't get mad at me! just letting you know what i've got to deal with! Chat Icon )

i don't think $50 a person for a 4 hr affair with a full open bar, centerpieces, cake included is that tragic though? Chat Icon

Posted 7/29/11 6:05 AM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: birthday party vent

Posted by Mags1227

Posted by lynnd126

Sorry this happened but I'm a little confused why you went from one EXTREME to another.

IMO if you were going to give in to the party with everyone at once idea maybe you should have considered borrowing a friend's big backyard or renting a k of c for a few hundred bucks?




i don't think they were extremes necessarily. it went from three small parties to one big one.

we don't really have a friend with a backyard big enough to accommodate all the people we had to invite (85) so we didn't go that route. (there was one possibility but all the way in commack and almost everybody lives in brooklyn so the drive was too much. plus i doubt the yard would fit everyone anyway)

k of c type of places- they are not really an option for us because of the problems that would involve with catering. ils would want russian food, my parents would want polish food and it would be one big fight AGAIN. plus the set-up, clean-up aspect would be killer on me. (i know it sounds silly, but there is a certain standard to these parties and buffet is usually not an option. it's considered tacky and cheap. don't get mad at me! just letting you know what i've got to deal with! Chat Icon )

i don't think $50 a person for a 4 hr affair with a full open bar, centerpieces, cake included is that tragic though? Chat Icon



I agree that's a good deal, but only when you have the money to spend. If things are tight I think it is a lot.

In any case, what's done is done-enjoy the party but I would try to stand your ground in the future so you don't get pushed around by your inlaws (or anyone for that matter-it starts now and if left unchecked they will keep imposing their way on you for the next 18 years, all the way to the poor houseChat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 7/29/11 8:21 AM
 

TessMike214
Gabriella Aubrey born 3/26!

Member since 5/10

2440 total posts

Name:
Tess

Re: birthday party vent

Family and friends can sometimes really disappoint when it comes to parties and it really does stink especially when you are throwing a big party...2/3 of the people didn't RSVP?? I'm guessing more than half of those 2/3 just assume that you know they are coming! Looks like you are going to have to track everyone down!Chat Icon good luck!!!
and I think $50 a person is an amazing deal for all that you are getting!!

Posted 7/29/11 9:46 AM
 

4PsInaPod
My Loves <3

Member since 7/07

10079 total posts

Name:
D

Re: birthday party vent

Posted by tarabelle99

2500 for a 1st birthday? That's insane. If MIL wanted this so badly SHE should be footing the bill! The way you had it set up, it would have cost you a fraction of that!



I agree and would not have caved.

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Hopefully everyone is just late in RSVPing!!!

Posted 7/29/11 9:53 AM
 

lynnd126
LIF Adult

Member since 3/11

2630 total posts

Name:

Re: birthday party vent

Posted by Mags1227

Posted by lynnd126

Sorry this happened but I'm a little confused why you went from one EXTREME to another.

IMO if you were going to give in to the party with everyone at once idea maybe you should have considered borrowing a friend's big backyard or renting a k of c for a few hundred bucks?




i don't think they were extremes necessarily. it went from three small parties to one big one.

we don't really have a friend with a backyard big enough to accommodate all the people we had to invite (85) so we didn't go that route. (there was one possibility but all the way in commack and almost everybody lives in brooklyn so the drive was too much. plus i doubt the yard would fit everyone anyway)

k of c type of places- they are not really an option for us because of the problems that would involve with catering. ils would want russian food, my parents would want polish food and it would be one big fight AGAIN. plus the set-up, clean-up aspect would be killer on me. (i know it sounds silly, but there is a certain standard to these parties and buffet is usually not an option. it's considered tacky and cheap. don't get mad at me! just letting you know what i've got to deal with! Chat Icon )

i don't think $50 a person for a 4 hr affair with a full open bar, centerpieces, cake included is that tragic though? Chat Icon



I guess that confuses me b/c you're the one that said you were unemployed and money is "very tight". I think you're family needs to reevaluate their priorities and judgement of others. You say that your family considers a buffet for a 1st birthday "tacky and cheap" but I think it's much worse for people to have such expectations of a young couple that are obviously struggling in this economy. I guess you'll know for next time not to worry so much about what they think since they don't seem to be worried about attending your party. I'm sorry that they couldn't just enjoy your dc's birthday for the milestone that it is instead of needing a sit down dinner and open barChat Icon

Posted 7/29/11 10:35 AM
 

Mags1227
Just a mommy ...

Member since 10/10

2665 total posts

Name:
M

Re: birthday party vent

Posted by lynnd126

Posted by Mags1227

Posted by lynnd126

Sorry this happened but I'm a little confused why you went from one EXTREME to another.

IMO if you were going to give in to the party with everyone at once idea maybe you should have considered borrowing a friend's big backyard or renting a k of c for a few hundred bucks?




i don't think they were extremes necessarily. it went from three small parties to one big one.

we don't really have a friend with a backyard big enough to accommodate all the people we had to invite (85) so we didn't go that route. (there was one possibility but all the way in commack and almost everybody lives in brooklyn so the drive was too much. plus i doubt the yard would fit everyone anyway)

k of c type of places- they are not really an option for us because of the problems that would involve with catering. ils would want russian food, my parents would want polish food and it would be one big fight AGAIN. plus the set-up, clean-up aspect would be killer on me. (i know it sounds silly, but there is a certain standard to these parties and buffet is usually not an option. it's considered tacky and cheap. don't get mad at me! just letting you know what i've got to deal with! Chat Icon )

i don't think $50 a person for a 4 hr affair with a full open bar, centerpieces, cake included is that tragic though? Chat Icon



I guess that confuses me b/c you're the one that said you were unemployed and money is "very tight". I think you're family needs to reevaluate their priorities and judgement of others. You say that your family considers a buffet for a 1st birthday "tacky and cheap" but I think it's much worse for people to have such expectations of a young couple that are obviously struggling in this economy. I guess you'll know for next time not to worry so much about what they think since they don't seem to be worried about attending your party. I'm sorry that they couldn't just enjoy your dc's birthday for the milestone that it is instead of needing a sit down dinner and open barChat Icon




ouch. i gotta say that kind of hurt. Chat Icon

i'm not sure if i can explain it to you properly. it is a "cultural" thing. (how i hate using that but it's true in this case)
to my DH's side (and partially my side) a party is not a true celebration without liquor. no one gets drunk (or even tipsy) but the alcohol must be there. a buffet feels like you are at a cafeteria. a sit down dinner is more grand, more of a big deal, more of a celebration. that's why DH would also always always choose a sit down dinner. they are used to many courses of food (i'm talking seven to eight a dinner) so this is already a step down. if i were to do the "proper" birthday party, it would probably be like a wedding. that's just how things are done. i'm lucky to have curtailed it as far as i did.

yes, money is tight. we are using part of our savings to throw this party. I wish it could be otherwise. but for this one birthday, it can't be. money wise that means DH and i won't be going out for a while. we won't be ordering out for dinner. i may have to skip the next nail appointment or haircut for a while. we WILL be ok though. I would not be doing this if i couldn't pay for it. (i'd prefer to use that money in other ways, but it's being used for the party)
it just bothered me that no one even considered that i was unemployed. I guess i've done such a good job of not letting it affect our standard of living that no one noticed/remembered. Chat Icon

Posted 7/29/11 12:01 PM
 

sweetie101
you make me smile :o)

Member since 5/08

4419 total posts

Name:

Re: birthday party vent

Chat Icon

Posted 7/29/11 12:07 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Birthday Party Vent... yankinmanc 1/3/10 9 Parenting
I need help....Birthday Party ChristineR 8/2/05 6 Parenting
Another ~ BIRTHDAY PARTY ~ question TAD 6/29/05 1 Parenting
Birthday Party ~~~ Got an idea now to choose ~~~ TAD 6/29/05 3 Families Helping Families ™
Where to have a kiddie birthday party for adults JenniferEver 6/7/05 17 Families Helping Families ™
1st Year Birthday Party Entertainment CampisiMom 5/13/05 4 Families Helping Families ™