Birthday Cake ?

Posted By Message

kris01
LIF Adult

Member since 10/06

1731 total posts

Name:
Kris

Birthday Cake ?

I am having a birthday party for DH at a restaurant. The package we have comes with choice of cake (cannoli/napoleon or chocolate) or a mixed dessert platter. DH told me he wants a lemon meringue cake. This is not one of the choices. Is it stupid to do the mixed dessert platters for the table and then get a small lemon meringue cake for DH?
also, any recommendations where to get a really good one?

Sorry...to clarify, the mixed dessert platters for the tables would be a combo of dessert cakes (cannoli/napoleon/chocolate/tartufo etc)

Thanks!

Message edited 2014-08-03 22:44:48.380000.

Posted 8/3/14 10:38 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

cj7305
=)

Member since 8/05

12296 total posts

Name:

Re: Birthday Cake ?

I do think it would be odd to only get fruit and no cake at a bday party. Unless you could get a large lemon meringue cake made up to feed the group. Is his party on his actual bday? If not maybe you could just get him the lemon cake and have it at home then and get the regular cake that comes with the package at the party (BTW I recommend napoleon lol it's my fave!)

Posted 8/3/14 10:42 PM
 

BaysideForever
LIF Adult

Member since 1/11

9976 total posts

Name:

Re: Birthday Cake ?

I would do dessert platter with the meringue

Posted 8/3/14 10:43 PM
 

MrsM84
LIF Adult

Member since 2/13

2352 total posts

Name:

Re: Birthday Cake ?

Posted by cj7305

I do think it would be odd to only get fruit and no cake at a bday party. Unless you could get a large lemon meringue cake made up to feed the group. Is his party on his actual bday? If not maybe you could just get him the lemon cake and have it at home then and get the regular cake that comes with the package at the party (BTW I recommend napoleon lol it's my fave!)



I read it quickly at first, and also thought it said a mixed fruit plate, but re-read it and its a mixed dessert plate -- maybe like a slice of cheesecake, a brownie, a mini fruit tart, etc?

If this is the case, I say dessert plate for everyone and a small dessert of DH's choice so that you can write "Happy Birthday" on it -- can't do that with a assortment plate!

Posted 8/3/14 10:48 PM
 

cj7305
=)

Member since 8/05

12296 total posts

Name:

Re: Birthday Cake ?

Posted by MrsM84

Posted by cj7305

I do think it would be odd to only get fruit and no cake at a bday party. Unless you could get a large lemon meringue cake made up to feed the group. Is his party on his actual bday? If not maybe you could just get him the lemon cake and have it at home then and get the regular cake that comes with the package at the party (BTW I recommend napoleon lol it's my fave!)



I read it quickly at first, and also thought it said a mixed fruit plate, but re-read it and its a mixed dessert plate -- maybe like a slice of cheesecake, a brownie, a mini fruit tart, etc?

If this is the case, I say dessert plate for everyone and a small dessert of DH's choice so that you can write "Happy Birthday" on it -- can't do that with a assortment plate!



Oh how funny, yes my mind totally read fruit plate!

Posted 8/3/14 11:29 PM
 

dlj97
LIF Adult

Member since 7/10

4399 total posts

Name:

Re: Birthday Cake ?

Posted by BaysideForever

I would do dessert platter with the meringue



ITA. I think a lot of people wouldn't want that type of cake anyway.

Posted 8/4/14 6:54 AM
 

BBD322x0
LIF Adolescent

Member since 3/14

703 total posts

Name:
Brittany

Birthday Cake ?

I don't think it's silly. I've found that every time I've thrown a party, by the time dessert comes out most people are stuffed anyway so I wouldn't go crazy. I think as long as you have the small platters on the table so everyone can have something that a small cake for DH is fine Chat Icon

Posted 8/4/14 11:23 AM
 

Rosie0613
LIF Adolescent

Member since 8/10

875 total posts

Name:
Rosie

Re: Birthday Cake ?

I agree - do the dessert platter with the cake your DH wants. Not everyone will want lemon meringue but at least there will be choices available.

Posted 8/4/14 11:47 AM
 

LIRascal
drama. daily.

Member since 3/11

7287 total posts

Name:
Michelle

Birthday Cake ?

Yep I did this for my DD's Christenings. I got the dessert cakes platters for the table, then did my choice of cake for the main cake. I think you should have a little cake for him to blow out his candles and for pictures and have the restaurant cut it up if anyone wants some.

Posted 8/4/14 12:20 PM
 

kris01
LIF Adult

Member since 10/06

1731 total posts

Name:
Kris

Re: Birthday Cake ?

Thanks for the advice!
I think that is what I'm going to do.
Dessert platters for the table and then a small cake for DH in his choice for flavor.
Thanks again.....

Posted 8/4/14 12:35 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Question about birthday invites for a combined birthday party jprimrose 9/13/11 5 Parenting
Need to order a birthday cake for DD's birthday on Memorial Day....help where? piggy007 5/9/11 2 Parenting
Being at a birthday party for 4 1/2 hours and no birthday cake yet... adeline27 5/4/09 17 Parenting
What's your favorite kind of birthday cake? Diva 9/28/06 43 Families Helping Families ™
Bakery Recommendation for 1st Birthday Cake MM2004 5/27/06 5 Parenting
Birthday Cake ??? mommy2Alex 3/7/06 3 Parenting