BF 12 mo old and whole milk?

Posted By Message

Sparrow
LIF Adult

Member since 11/10

6826 total posts

Name:

BF 12 mo old and whole milk?

I'm confused as to what I'm supposed to be giving DD as far as "milk" goes. DD is basically EBF and eats 3 meals a day plus snacks. I had been giving her water with meals and BF in between, at night and in the AM (basically whenever she wants). Now I'm confused and wondering if I'm supposed to be also giving her cow's milk in addition to BF? I just assumed the cow's milk was only given to FF babies but I just read a confusing article on babycenter that seemed to imply that BF babies are still supposed to drink 2-3 additional cups of cow's milk daily. The nurse at our ped's office told me you need to watch dairy intake becuase you don't want to exceed 24 oz daily. I really have no idea how much BM DD gets.

In addition, she will barely drink cow's milk. DH and MIL have tried on several occasions now to give it to her when I'm at work and she'll only take a few oz after lots of coaxing and trying over and over. Any tips to get her to take more?

Posted 4/15/12 9:46 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

wingsofsong
My 3 little loves <3<3<3

Member since 1/09

7395 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: BF 12 mo old and whole milk?

As per our ped, I started my son on whole milk at 1 year,even though he was EBF. Breast milk is not dairy, so it doesn't mattered how many ounces she gets when she nurses. It took my son a while to get used to cow's milk. We finally figured out that the thickness bothered him because he was used to only breast milk and water, which are both very thin. So we tried giving him skim milk, which he gulped down! So we did a slow transition- a few days of skim, then skim mixed with 1%, then just 1%, then mixed with 2%, etc. He was on whole milk after about 2 weeks.
Check with your ped, but if she won't drink milk, it should be ok for her to get her dairy intake in other ways, like yogurt, cheese, etc. HTH!

Posted 4/15/12 10:19 PM
 

Sparrow
LIF Adult

Member since 11/10

6826 total posts

Name:

Re: BF 12 mo old and whole milk?

I didn't know BM wasn't considered to be dairy, that's interesting. Luckily DD loves yogurt and cheese, I guess we'll be giving her more of that! I'm going to keep trying with the cow's milk. DH was adding a small amount of water to it yesterday to thin it up a bit and that seemed to help. Thanks!

Posted 4/16/12 9:35 AM
 

VikingChick
LIF Adult

Member since 5/11

1024 total posts

Name:
Anna

Re: BF 12 mo old and whole milk?

It was always my understanding that you only needed to provide cow milk if you were planning on weaning. So, if DC is still BF and you are happy with that, why even bother offering cow milk? On the other hand, if you are trying to wean, go ahead and offer the milk. Also, if he doesn't like cow milk, have you tried goat milk? It is more similar to mom's.

Posted 4/16/12 12:52 PM
 

PoppySeed
LIF Infant

Member since 10/09

358 total posts

Name:

Re: BF 12 mo old and whole milk?

Posted by anskiv

It was always my understanding that you only needed to provide cow milk if you were planning on weaning. So, if DC is still BF and you are happy with that, why even bother offering cow milk? On the other hand, if you are trying to wean, go ahead and offer the milk.



This. Of course, cow's milk isn't really necessary for anyone at any age, but cow's milk is usually used as a replacement for formula when they turn one or BM when they're weaned.

Posted 4/16/12 1:08 PM
 

Sparrow
LIF Adult

Member since 11/10

6826 total posts

Name:

Re: BF 12 mo old and whole milk?

Posted by PoppySeed

Posted by anskiv

It was always my understanding that you only needed to provide cow milk if you were planning on weaning. So, if DC is still BF and you are happy with that, why even bother offering cow milk? On the other hand, if you are trying to wean, go ahead and offer the milk.



This. Of course, cow's milk isn't really necessary for anyone at any age, but cow's milk is usually used as a replacement for formula when they turn one or BM when they're weaned.



This was what I thought but then I read something that seemed to indicate otherwise (although it wasn't very clear). The hand-out my ped's office gave me doesn't even mention BF at this age. When I told the nurse at the office that we still BF she seemed a tiny bit surprised and said "Oh, um, ok, if that's still working then why change it". The doctor had the same type of reaction, I'm guessing they don't get many extended BF'ers in their practice.

I'm really surprised DD doesn't want the cow's milk. She was 95% BF but would get occasional bottles of formula when I work very PT and never complained about the formula. So odd.

Posted 4/16/12 1:26 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
How much milk/liquids does your almost 2 yr old (or newly 2 yr old) drink per day? itsbabytime 1/4/12 14 Parenting
Menu for 8 month old w/Milk Allergy AnnBrunoXO 10/13/06 1 Parenting
3 week old won't take the bottle of breast milk KittyCat 10/5/06 8 Parenting
My 3 month old had whole milk Shelly 7/25/06 5 Parenting
How much milk for an 18 month old? dee7772 4/23/06 5 Parenting
Non-Baby foods for a 10-month old who is milk intolerant MM2004 4/22/06 8 Parenting