Beyonce & Jay Z Spin

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

Kellish
LIF Adult

Member since 10/07

2713 total posts

Name:
LOVE THE LIFE

Beyonce & Jay Z Spin

Everyone keeps throwing around the idea of a surrogate mother. Maybe it is just me but if she did have a surrogate WHO CARES!!! I don't think she needs to explain or be judged for it. Many women are unable to carry a baby and take this route. I think the bashing of her for this(faking prego part) is just crazy.

Posted 1/9/12 2:44 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

DramaQueen10
LIF Infant

Member since 1/11

256 total posts

Name:

Re: Beyonce & Jay Z Spin

Uh oh, you might be in for it now. I once posted a thread genuinely asking why people were making such a big deal about Kim Kardashian's divorce and I was crucified.

Personally, I agree with you, if Beyonce chose to have a surrogate or adopted or gave birth to an alien, who the h*ll cares!!

Message edited 2012-01-09 14:51:05.190000.

Posted 1/9/12 2:49 PM
 

Michi
My Love

Member since 5/05

31600 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Beyonce & Jay Z Spin

You think it is ok to fake a pregnancy? I am sorry for any woman who cant have her own child and there is no shame in having a surogate if that is the case. There is SHAME tho in wearing a fake baby bump so pple think ur pregnant if ur not. This is not Days of Our Lives.

Message edited 2012-01-09 14:51:23.620000.

Posted 1/9/12 2:50 PM
 

Cacarina
Two girls!

Member since 12/09

2971 total posts

Name:
Cari

Re: Beyonce & Jay Z Spin

I get what you mean - what's the big deal if she did have a surrogate? However, I think it is weird and asking for it when she went on an MTV awards show and announced her pregnancy in SUCH a public way by ending her performance by ripping off her jacket and rubbing her belly. Just a VERY public way of announcing a pregnancy, and IF she used a surrogate, a very odd thing to do.

But, who knows, how does anyone know she didn't have the baby herself???

Posted 1/9/12 2:51 PM
 

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: Beyonce & Jay Z Spin

I think that's the point though... for me at least. What's the big deal? Why so hush hush? Do you know how many women on this board alone are dealing with infertility issues? I just think that IF Beyonce is experiencing the same thing and hiding it, it makes it seem like it's something to be ashamed of which is sad and sick to me. She could've given a lot of ladies a confidence booster by proudly proclaiming that she's using a surrogate.

And if the reason is NOT because she's dealing with infertility and it's because she's worried about her post pregnancy body then I have little respect for her and it makes me wanna roll my eyes until they fall out of my head.

That's my piece.

Posted 1/9/12 2:54 PM
 

JennZ
MY LIFE!!

Member since 8/05

25463 total posts

Name:

Re: Beyonce & Jay Z Spin

Posted by Michi

You think it is ok to fake a pregnancy? I am sorry for any woman who cant have her own child and there is no shame in having a surogate if that is the case. There is SHAME tho in wearing a fake baby bump so pple think ur pregnant if ur not. This is not Days of Our Lives.



Unless you have solid 100% PROOF she faked it, your statement above is completely crazy.

I think the whole hoopla surrounding this is absurd. WHY do they have to prove anything? They are people just like we are who happen to have a very public profession. That which does NOT give us, or anyone the right to see behind their closed doors. They got married, not one pic was shared. Good for them, if they had been on the Kardashian wh0re train of pimping themselves out, we would have bitcched about that.


Get a grip people.

Posted 1/9/12 2:55 PM
 

DramaQueen10
LIF Infant

Member since 1/11

256 total posts

Name:

Re: Beyonce & Jay Z Spin

Posted by JennZ



Unless you have solid 100% PROOF she faked it, your statement above is completely crazy.

I think the whole hoopla surrounding this is absurd. WHY do they have to prove anything? They are people just like we are who happen to have a very public profession. That which does NOT give us, or anyone the right to see behind their closed doors. They got married, not one pic was shared. Good for them, if they had been on the Kardashian wh0re train of pimping themselves out, we would have bitcched about that.


Get a grip people.




Amen!!

Posted 1/9/12 2:56 PM
 

MamaLeen
:)

Member since 10/09

4594 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Beyonce & Jay Z Spin

ITA Jenn, people need to get a grip!!!!

This is all SPECULATION made up from the public. This whole Beyonce thing has just shown me how nuts people really are. Chat Icon It is driving people crazy that they are so private and they will never know.

Posted 1/9/12 2:58 PM
 

ModDot
PUMPKIN ALL THE THINGS

Member since 8/11

2196 total posts

Name:
Trissy

Re: Beyonce & Jay Z Spin

I tend to agree, they base it off the sound a mic made when she was on an interview. I thought it was rubbing on her dress. I think they are just private people and have to pay for it now that they are in the public eye. Also, I just read they suffered a miscarriage prior to this pregnancy so I would be guarding myself too if I were in their situation. Plus, they owe no one an explanation

Posted 1/9/12 2:58 PM
 

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: Beyonce & Jay Z Spin

Posted by JennZ

WHY do they have to prove anything?



They don't. Nobody asked them to. At least, I don't care. But they'll just have to deal with speculation. The price of fame.

ETA: Can I ask why everyone else is so angry on their behalf? I mean, you call people who believe the theory crazy... but you guys are jumping up and down in their defense. Why? To me, that comes off just as crazy. Just my two cents!

Message edited 2012-01-09 15:02:16.580000.

Posted 1/9/12 3:00 PM
 

DramaQueen10
LIF Infant

Member since 1/11

256 total posts

Name:

Re: Beyonce & Jay Z Spin

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by JennZ

WHY do they have to prove anything?



They don't. Nobody asked them to. At least, I don't care. But they'll just have to deal with speculation. The price of fame.



What??? Everybody has asked them to prove it... and its because she hasn't that she's being bashed

Posted 1/9/12 3:02 PM
 

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: Beyonce & Jay Z Spin

Posted by DramaQueen10

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by JennZ

WHY do they have to prove anything?



They don't. Nobody asked them to. At least, I don't care. But they'll just have to deal with speculation. The price of fame.



What??? Everybody has asked them to prove it... and its because she hasn't that she's being bashed



Yeah because saying "I'll believe it when I see the c-section scar" is demanding proof. It's a joke!

Posted 1/9/12 3:05 PM
 

DramaQueen10
LIF Infant

Member since 1/11

256 total posts

Name:

Re: Beyonce & Jay Z Spin

Posted by jilliibabii

Posted by DramaQueen10

What??? Everybody has asked them to prove it... and its because she hasn't that she's being bashed



Yeah because saying "I'll believe it when I see the c-section scar" is demanding proof. It's a joke!



No, but people expecting her to post pictures of her pregnant belly in response to the speculation was demanding proof....

In any case, Beyonce's fake pregnancy, Kim Kardashian's divorce, Justin Beiber's alleged illigitimate child, it's all fun to talk about, but when people get so up in arms about it as if they were personally affected by it in some way, it's weird... that's all Chat Icon

Message edited 2012-01-09 15:17:18.743000.

Posted 1/9/12 3:10 PM
 

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: Beyonce & Jay Z Spin

Posted by DramaQueen10

In any case, Beyonce's fake pregnancy, Kim Kardashian's divorce, Justin Beiber's alleged illigitimate child, it's all fun to talk about, but when people get so up in arms about it as if they were personally affected by it in some way, it's weird... that's all Chat Icon



This is why I added the comment in my other post! People getting so angry on their behalf is just as bananas to me! lol!

Posted 1/9/12 3:18 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Beyonce & Jay Z Spin

I don't care how she had the baby but I do think it is utter crap (and completely nuts - especially if this is for financial gain) to pretend she's pregnant.

Posted 1/9/12 3:42 PM
 

LoveyQ
Stalkers, get a life.

Member since 11/07

12820 total posts

Name:

Re: Beyonce & Jay Z Spin

Honestly I couldn't care less if she was really pregnant or had a surrogate, but I think there's no need to be deceitful and fake a pregnancy if you're using a surrogate. Many people use surrogates because that's their only option. If that was the case for her, then she could use her fame to really bring a lot of light to that. But to fake a pregnancy instead seems ludicrous.

Now, I never actually thought she wasn't pregnant. To me she looked pregnant etc. But I'm just saying that if she did fake it, just seems so stupid. Hopefully she didn't fake it, but honestly, NO ONE will ever know the truth. Bottom line is they have a baby now.

Posted 1/9/12 4:19 PM
 

hotsauce345
my love, my life, my son

Member since 1/09

4169 total posts

Name:
Melody

Re: Beyonce & Jay Z Spin

I think you're missing the point, like alot of others. NOBODY ever said they thought that having a surrogate was bad!

When I found out she was pregnant...my first words were "awww I'm so happy for her! I know she's been really wanting this!"

Then when that video came out of the crumpling belly...I was like "Woah, what the heck was that? thats not normal" and I started to think "wow, is she really using this to boost publicity?" I never questioned wether or not she was actually pregnant...but I thought it was weird she might wear a prosthetic belly...I just didn't understand the purpose for wearing a fake belly if you're really pregnant...and when someone mentioned she was trying to "look further along" because "pregnant sells" I thought "gosh if thats true ...thats disgusting!"

I've experienced a loss of pregnancy so to me...pregnancy is NOT something you mess around with, falsify, or use for attention (call me superstitious)

Again, nobody knows whats what...it's all just speculation. And having a surrogate is not a bad thing (although if it were for the reason of "keeping your body and looks" I think thats awfully superficial...but I'm entitled to my opinion.)

Nobody said she had to defend her pregnancy either...but when you choose to be in the spotlight...your whole life is on display for all to see...and people will talk because you have become a household name. People are entitled to their opinions and I think it's silly that others get offended. We are on a CELEBRITIES AND ENTERTAINMENT BOARD...we specifically come here to talk about celebrities and entertainment...so for people to come to this board and say "Who cares?" is kind of silly because obviously they care about whats going on in celebrity news if they are here. KWIM?

Message edited 2012-01-09 16:26:47.090000.

Posted 1/9/12 4:24 PM
 

jgl
Love my little boys!!!

Member since 8/07

7060 total posts

Name:
g

Re: Beyonce & Jay Z Spin

I care more that they named their dd Blue. So dumb! Jmo Chat Icon

Posted 1/9/12 7:45 PM
 

MamaLeen
:)

Member since 10/09

4594 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Beyonce & Jay Z Spin

Posted by MrsMeloyellow
Nobody said she had to defend her pregnancy either...but when you choose to be in the spotlight...your whole life is on display for all to see...and people will talk because you have become a household name. People are entitled to their opinions and I think it's silly that others get offended. We are on a CELEBRITIES AND ENTERTAINMENT BOARD...we specifically come here to talk about celebrities and entertainment...so for people to come to this board and say "Who cares?" is kind of silly because obviously they care about whats going on in celebrity news if they are here. KWIM?



I get what you are saying but there is a big difference between coming on here to check out people's outfits and gossip and speculating/obsessing about every detail of a woman's pregnancy and birth. (not saying you did/do this, just have noticed it)

I guess I am just surprised by how affected people seem to be by it since it doesn't involve them at all. I feel like part of it is because B&J are private and it rubs people the wrong way. We are so used to celebrities showing us their hoohas and twittering when they take a poop.

Posted 1/9/12 7:57 PM
 

LotsaLuv
Us

Member since 6/10

4094 total posts

Name:
F

Re: Beyonce & Jay Z Spin

Posted by jgl

I care more that they named their dd Blue. So dumb! Jmo Chat Icon




LOL I agree, that's what I was questioning, actually that's the only think I have questioned.

You can't even use a nickname for that.

They will have tons of followers naming their kids Blue, Yellow, and Gold though.

Posted 1/9/12 8:49 PM
 

ElizaRags35
My 2 Girls

Member since 2/09

20494 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Beyonce & Jay Z Spin

I think it's very possible that they used a surrogate. I definitely would never judge anyone who chooses surrogacy. However, if someone were to fake a pregnancy and hide a surrogate and go to such great lengths to cover up the truth, then I would find it disgusting -- not the surrogacy part of course, the hiding and faking.

For all I know, she really did give birth to Blue Ivy (Chat Icon to the name). But if she didn't, I would definitely think less of her and Jay-Z (for faking/hiding the truth). It would be like she felt ashamed in using surrogate which is NOT something to be ashamed about.

Posted 1/9/12 11:01 PM
 

BlessedMomma
LIF Adult

Member since 12/11

6163 total posts

Name:
Momma Bear

Re: Beyonce & Jay Z Spin

Posted by MrsMeloyellow

I think you're missing the point, like alot of others. NOBODY ever said they thought that having a surrogate was bad!

When I found out she was pregnant...my first words were "awww I'm so happy for her! I know she's been really wanting this!"

Then when that video came out of the crumpling belly...I was like "Woah, what the heck was that? thats not normal" and I started to think "wow, is she really using this to boost publicity?" I never questioned wether or not she was actually pregnant...but I thought it was weird she might wear a prosthetic belly...I just didn't understand the purpose for wearing a fake belly if you're really pregnant...and when someone mentioned she was trying to "look further along" because "pregnant sells" I thought "gosh if thats true ...thats disgusting!"

I've experienced a loss of pregnancy so to me...pregnancy is NOT something you mess around with, falsify, or use for attention (call me superstitious)

Again, nobody knows whats what...it's all just speculation. And having a surrogate is not a bad thing (although if it were for the reason of "keeping your body and looks" I think thats awfully superficial...but I'm entitled to my opinion.)

Nobody said she had to defend her pregnancy either...but when you choose to be in the spotlight...your whole life is on display for all to see...and people will talk because you have become a household name. People are entitled to their opinions and I think it's silly that others get offended. We are on a CELEBRITIES AND ENTERTAINMENT BOARD...we specifically come here to talk about celebrities and entertainment...so for people to come to this board and say "Who cares?" is kind of silly because obviously they care about whats going on in celebrity news if they are here. KWIM?



I COULDNT AGREE MORE WITH EVERY WORD YOU JUST SAID!!!!!!! Especially the end part for the people who post on these boards "who cares!"

Posted 1/10/12 10:29 AM
 

LovingLife
Blessed

Member since 8/06

2818 total posts

Name:
Blessed

Re: Beyonce & Jay Z Spin

Posted by BlessedMomma

Posted by MrsMeloyellow

I think you're missing the point, like alot of others. NOBODY ever said they thought that having a surrogate was bad!

When I found out she was pregnant...my first words were "awww I'm so happy for her! I know she's been really wanting this!"

Then when that video came out of the crumpling belly...I was like "Woah, what the heck was that? thats not normal" and I started to think "wow, is she really using this to boost publicity?" I never questioned wether or not she was actually pregnant...but I thought it was weird she might wear a prosthetic belly...I just didn't understand the purpose for wearing a fake belly if you're really pregnant...and when someone mentioned she was trying to "look further along" because "pregnant sells" I thought "gosh if thats true ...thats disgusting!"

I've experienced a loss of pregnancy so to me...pregnancy is NOT something you mess around with, falsify, or use for attention (call me superstitious)

Again, nobody knows whats what...it's all just speculation. And having a surrogate is not a bad thing (although if it were for the reason of "keeping your body and looks" I think thats awfully superficial...but I'm entitled to my opinion.)

Nobody said she had to defend her pregnancy either...but when you choose to be in the spotlight...your whole life is on display for all to see...and people will talk because you have become a household name. People are entitled to their opinions and I think it's silly that others get offended. We are on a CELEBRITIES AND ENTERTAINMENT BOARD...we specifically come here to talk about celebrities and entertainment...so for people to come to this board and say "Who cares?" is kind of silly because obviously they care about whats going on in celebrity news if they are here. KWIM?



I COULDNT AGREE MORE WITH EVERY WORD YOU JUST SAID!!!!!!! Especially the end part for the people who post on these boards "who cares!"



Just a thought - what if she wore the prosthetic belly in the beginning to look farther along so MAYBE she can have some privacy when she actually gives birth since she was expected to give birth in February instead of January. Of course IF that was the plan it backfired BUT it could have been an attempt.

Posted 1/10/12 1:40 PM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: Beyonce & Jay Z Spin

Posted by Michi

You think it is ok to fake a pregnancy? I am sorry for any woman who cant have her own child and there is no shame in having a surogate if that is the case. There is SHAME tho in wearing a fake baby bump so pple think ur pregnant if ur not. This is not Days of Our Lives.



You know what, I think it's flipping OUTSTANDING that you are SO SECURE with yourself that you can't imagine any scenario where you might not want to tell the entire world the truth about where your baby came from.

SHAME in wearing a fake baby bump? Are you effing kidding me?

You're so unbelievably judgmental. I hope you NEVER have to deal with the stress of something as serious as miscarriage or infertility.

Posted 1/10/12 2:29 PM
 

BlessedMomma
LIF Adult

Member since 12/11

6163 total posts

Name:
Momma Bear

Re: Beyonce & Jay Z Spin

And wheres the SHAME in admitting you had a miscarriage? Or infertility? Or just having issues?

I understand that is private, BUT MAYBE JUST MAYBE she could take her fame and do something really good with it like shedding a light on Miscarriage and Infertility... Donate to a charity and put a spotlight on it to gain more donations and more research into it since its such an under-researched piece of medicine... Maybe she could have been a spokeswoman for it...

AND if you dont want to talk about it and keep it private thats each persons right, then dont make a spectacle of yourself with a prosthetic bump... IF that is in fact what she did... All this BS with the hospital and the privacy and now the hospital is trying to defend them and do damage control... Like I always say, where theres smoke theres fire... You never hear ANY STORIES about Jennifer Garner, Kate Hudson, Hilary Duff, Jessica Alba... All those women are famous and rich and I have never heard a bad word about their hospital stays, speculation about their pregnancies or anything else...

Im sorry I dont think you have the right to put anyone down for having an opposing opinon from you...

AND how convenient NOW 2 days later with bad press NOW Jayz just HAPPENS to slip in a song where he mentions they had a miscarriage... SOOOO you were so private you didnt want to talk about it before but NOW you want to talk about it since you have SO MUCH bad press floating around you? What convenient timing you have...

OO and lets see how much $ shes going to make for selling pics of her baby, selling her diet and exercise secrets for getting her body back in a ridiclous unrealistic time frame and all the money they will make for the story of her miscarriage and pregnancy and birth... Dont EVER Doubt for one second that EVERY SINGLE THING these people do is calculated... Not just Jay and Beyonce, but just about EVERY SINGLE famous person...

Message edited 2012-01-10 15:18:08.520000.

Posted 1/10/12 3:13 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Wanna see the yacht Beyonce and Jay-Z are on? MrsQ 6/19/07 23 Celebrities & Entertainment
IT'S OVER!! BEYONCE BREAKS UP WITH JAY Z!! JennZ 2/27/07 15 Celebrities & Entertainment
Beyonce and Jay-Z to Tie the Knot Next Weekend? MrsQ 12/5/06 5 Celebrities & Entertainment
Is Jay-Z sexy, or does Beyonce being with him make him sexy? Janice 10/15/05 24 Families Helping Families ™
beyonce on jay-z Dani 11/6/06 1 Celebrities & Entertainment
Beyonce & Jay-Z: It's Over???? MrsQ 10/30/06 5 Celebrities & Entertainment