anyone's OB req payment before baby's birth?

Posted By Message

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

anyone's OB req payment before baby's birth?

Just received a letter in the mail, they want 714.00 by January, at my 7th month.

I don't feel comfortable with this at all.

A lot of money is going to be flying around for lab, sonograms, hospital, doc, spinal, baby's ped....

I would rather keep my money to myself when everything is sorted out, take my taxes and write checks out.

Did anyone's OB request this?

I called and left message. I am going to tell them its a no go...but wanted to get other's experiences. I also don't know if they are going to hold my checks or cash them(they want me on a 140.00 a month payment plan till Jan)

but I wanted all payments to be made in the 2010 calendar year for tax time the following year.

tia!

Posted 7/28/09 5:17 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: anyone's OB req payment before baby's birth?

where are they getting this amount from?

future copays?

I don't see how this is even legal.

i work in health care fraud.

this doesn't smell good to me. I have no idea without the details...but copays etc are pay as you go. receiving payment for services not rendered could be considered fraud.Chat Icon

Posted 7/28/09 5:21 PM
 

LSP2005
Bunny kisses are so cute!

Member since 5/05

19461 total posts

Name:
L

Re: anyone's OB req payment before baby's birth?

No - I only had the following payments.
Co-pay for initial visit $15
Co-pay for 12 week u/s (at another place) $15
Co-pay for 20 week u/s (at another place) $15
Co-pay to lab for blood work. Varies per test.

I will get an itemized bill after delivery and then pay what I owe. I would be extremly leary of paying in advance. Who is to say the day you go into labor that your obgyn will deliver you. I had a scheduled c/s, but never made it to that date and had an emergency c/s by an on-call doctor who was not mine.

Posted 7/28/09 5:21 PM
 

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: anyone's OB req payment before baby's birth?

Posted by Ophelia

where are they getting this amount from?

future copays?

I don't see how this is even legal.

i work in health care fraud.

this doesn't smell good to me. I have no idea without the details...but copays etc are pay as you go. receiving payment for services not rendered could be considered fraud.Chat Icon



i agree with this. i would not pay. sounds fishy. how do you pay for birth that hasn't yet occurred?

Posted 7/28/09 5:25 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: anyone's OB req payment before baby's birth?

yeah...and I am REALLY REALLY shocked by this.

everyone and their mother, literallyChat Icon , goes to this practice.

its huge. dr was a gem.

714 is assuming I have a vaginal birth, drs fees are 4400. that is my 20% co-pay.

I just feel like services better be rendered before I go coughing up cash.

Also, OB is assuming insurance co won't pay them.

it gets messy here...but...
I pay 750 deductible.
then 20% of all charges until I hit 2K.
So, at time of birth, it will be 2750.00.

I really want hospital to bill first and be told they are getting paid bill except for 20%...

then I want dr to bill and see that I already owe hospital 20%, so then dr is paid in full by insurance.

if this works...I am so much more likely to talk hospital down with my out of pocket...then I would be able to with a drs office. With Josh, I got a lot off of my hosp bill since I paid a lump sum, I was able to make a deal.

follow, or is it in my head? I am too hungry to figure it out.

Posted 7/28/09 5:27 PM
 

bpmom
Feeling Blessed

Member since 6/07

2963 total posts

Name:

Re: anyone's OB req payment before baby's birth?

Yep - I was with an OB like this for my first PG (I'm pretty sure I know who you're talking about, too Chat Icon ). They called it a pregnancy deductible, and actually sent me a coupon book with a payment schedule! Chat Icon
I refused to pay it, and called the office but they of course said it was protocol for the ins I was using. I then called my insurance co. and they directed me not to pay it because it was being set up in case insurance wouldn't pay for something. The ins. guy actually was very helpful and said that it if I paid it and then ins. paid it, the practice would not give me my money back. It's better to have them bill you when the birth occurs and then sort it out.
HTH.
PS - I switched to the Stony Brook midwives a few months later (at week 28 in my PG) and have had no problems with their billing system! Chat Icon

Posted 7/28/09 5:32 PM
 

twiceasnice
LIF Adult

Member since 2/08

1126 total posts

Name:

Re: anyone's OB req payment before baby's birth?

Yes my Dr. does this also.

At my first OB appt I got a notice in all the paperwork that the office contacted my insurance company to get an estimate of what my out of pocket bill would be. They request this to be paid in full by 24 wks PG and it should be paied in 4 installments.

I NEVER heard of this before. I spoke to a co-worker and she said everyone has to pre-pay. I go to a pretty common pratice so I think this is there way of making sure they get paid.

Posted 7/28/09 5:35 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: anyone's OB req payment before baby's birth?

thanks!!!!!!

actually I am in NC, but I am glad you have heard of this!

I remember with #1 being on phone with insurance, they told me not to pay anyone until everything was said and done.

Posted 7/28/09 5:35 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: anyone's OB req payment before baby's birth?

Posted by Janice

yeah...and I am REALLY REALLY shocked by this.

everyone and their mother, literallyChat Icon , goes to this practice.

its huge. dr was a gem.

714 is assuming I have a vaginal birth, drs fees are 4400. that is my 20% co-pay.

I just feel like services better be rendered before I go coughing up cash.

Also, OB is assuming insurance co won't pay them.

it gets messy here...but...
I pay 750 deductible.
then 20% of all charges until I hit 2K.
So, at time of birth, it will be 2750.00.

I really want hospital to bill first and be told they are getting paid bill except for 20%...

then I want dr to bill and see that I already owe hospital 20%, so then dr is paid in full by insurance.

if this works...I am so much more likely to talk hospital down with my out of pocket...then I would be able to with a drs office. With Josh, I got a lot off of my hosp bill since I paid a lump sum, I was able to make a deal.

follow, or is it in my head? I am too hungry to figure it out.



they cannot bill you a copay for a service not yet rendered.

end of story.

call you insurance company and report this. and maybe call your states AG and ask them about the practice.

since you are in another state, I am not sure of the protocol...but from where I sit, that does not fly.

Posted 7/28/09 5:36 PM
 

twiceasnice
LIF Adult

Member since 2/08

1126 total posts

Name:

Re: anyone's OB req payment before baby's birth?

Posted by bdmom

Yep - I was with an OB like this for my first PG (I'm pretty sure I know who you're talking about, too Chat Icon ). They called it a pregnancy deductible, and actually sent me a coupon book with a payment schedule! Chat Icon
I refused to pay it, and called the office but they of course said it was protocol for the ins I was using. I then called my insurance co. and they directed me not to pay it because it was being set up in case insurance wouldn't pay for something. The ins. guy actually was very helpful and said that it if I paid it and then ins. paid it, the practice would not give me my money back. It's better to have them bill you when the birth occurs and then sort it out.
HTH.
PS - I switched to the Stony Brook midwives a few months later (at week 28 in my PG) and have had no problems with their billing system! Chat Icon



Thanks for the advice. My insurance co hasn't cooperated with the office so I haven't been billed yet.

Did you use Three Village??

Posted 7/28/09 5:37 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: anyone's OB req payment before baby's birth?

thanks.

I also have another question please!Chat Icon

ultrasounds, since I am working in 2 calendar years, I will have 2 ultrasounds in 2009.

at 350 a pop. which I will pay out of pocket since its my deductible.

or...does dr bill for them at the end with office visits and delivery?

Posted 7/28/09 5:40 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: anyone's OB req payment before baby's birth?

Posted by Janice

thanks.

I also have another question please!Chat Icon

ultrasounds, since I am working in 2 calendar years, I will have 2 ultrasounds in 2009.

at 350 a pop. which I will pay out of pocket since its my deductible.

or...does dr bill for them at the end with office visits and delivery?



ultrasounds are different than prenatal care and are not billed as a package deal.

it's up to you really. you can have them bill your ins, and pay the bill when your company denies the claim.

or you can save the paperwork and pay up front.

I am not sure how your exact plan works in terms of prenatal care and your dd (since you start in one calendar year and finish in another) so it's hard to say concretely...but without specifics, that is what I would say.Chat Icon

Posted 7/28/09 5:48 PM
 

Shorty
.

Member since 5/05

30390 total posts

Name:
really

Re: anyone's OB req payment before baby's birth?

yes - my Dr's fees are approx $3k for a v-birth, so they required a deposit of my 10% coinsurance ($300) before I reached 20wks.

Posted 7/28/09 5:56 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: anyone's OB req payment before baby's birth?

gracias.

seems like too much money going out to everyone.

I want final bills coming to me. not prepays.

I hope they call back tomorrow...so its not another day of wondering...............

Posted 7/28/09 5:56 PM
 

Susie715
LIF Infant

Member since 4/09

228 total posts

Name:
Suzanne

Re: anyone's OB req payment before baby's birth?

Another point to consider... does your deductible reset in January? Mine does...
And for tax purposes it might be beneficial to have all the expenses paid in 2009 so you can claim it immediately and not wait a yr...

Definitely call the dr office and your insurance to find out your options.

Posted 7/28/09 6:10 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: anyone's OB req payment before baby's birth?

Janice, I wanted to also point out that the rules that I go by at work are different that what I could apply to a private insurer.

so call your insurance and again, call the Attorney General of your state (no Mr. Eric Holder Chat Icon ) and find out if that practice is acceptable.

the same for you girls living here in NY. call the state and call your insurance plans to see what they say in regard to pre paying a copay.

Chat Icon it really sounds off to me...but like I said...I have different rules dancing around in my head.

Posted 7/28/09 6:14 PM
 

gck0708
She is love!

Member since 11/08

1863 total posts

Name:
Grace

Re: anyone's OB req payment before baby's birth?

Yes, mine requires payment in full before the birth. But I'm going straight through the hospital. Reason #88273829382 why I hate the medical system where I live.

Posted 7/28/09 8:07 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: anyone's OB req payment before baby's birth?

Yes both babies I paid in advance. Two different offices. I had no issues. It was my 10% and I had already met my deductible.

Posted 7/28/09 11:42 PM
 

steph4777
**************

Member since 5/05

11726 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: anyone's OB req payment before baby's birth?

I had never heard of it until my BF found out she was pregnant a few weeks ago. When she told me that the OB required payment before the baby was born I was floored. Apparently it has to do with the terms of her insurance plan and the OB's policies (I thought it was a Southern thing cuz she lives in Memphis). She is also high-risk and has to have a sono at every visit. She was saying that the prenatal care alone is going to cost thousands of dollars.

There are so many things that happen throughout a pregnancy and I would not feel comfortable paying for a delivery that I have not had yet.

Posted 7/28/09 11:52 PM
 

alisha
LIF Adult

Member since 3/07

1199 total posts

Name:

Re: anyone's OB req payment before baby's birth?

Posted by Janice

thanks.

I also have another question please!Chat Icon

ultrasounds, since I am working in 2 calendar years, I will have 2 ultrasounds in 2009.

at 350 a pop. which I will pay out of pocket since its my deductible.

or...does dr bill for them at the end with office visits and delivery?



Whatever you do, make sure all your services are submitted to your insurance. The insurance company will process the claim and apply their network discount, so even though you are in your deductible, you will owe the discounted amount, not retail.

i.e. I have an Aetna POS II plan. Each time I have labwork done, I am charged. Quest charges an arm and leg (well over $1000 by now) but I have only had to pay a couple hundred dollars b/c of the insurance discount. AND this is all going towards my out of pocket maximum of $1000, after which the insurance picks up the bill at 100%.

Long story short, all claims should funnel through insurance FIRST before you pay.

Posted 7/29/09 7:56 AM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: anyone's OB req payment before baby's birth?

Posted by Janice

yeah...and I am REALLY REALLY shocked by this.

everyone and their mother, literallyChat Icon , goes to this practice.

its huge. dr was a gem.

714 is assuming I have a vaginal birth, drs fees are 4400. that is my 20% co-pay.

I just feel like services better be rendered before I go coughing up cash.

Also, OB is assuming insurance co won't pay them.

it gets messy here...but...
I pay 750 deductible.
then 20% of all charges until I hit 2K.
So, at time of birth, it will be 2750.00.

I really want hospital to bill first and be told they are getting paid bill except for 20%...

then I want dr to bill and see that I already owe hospital 20%, so then dr is paid in full by insurance.

if this works...I am so much more likely to talk hospital down with my out of pocket...then I would be able to with a drs office. With Josh, I got a lot off of my hosp bill since I paid a lump sum, I was able to make a deal.

follow, or is it in my head? I am too hungry to figure it out.



THIs makes perfect sense and what you should insist upon. The hospital will almost always negotiate!!

Posted 7/29/09 8:31 AM
 

dm24angel
Happiness

Member since 5/05

34581 total posts

Name:
Donna

Re: anyone's OB req payment before baby's birth?

Posted by Ophelia

Janice, I wanted to also point out that the rules that I go by at work are different that what I could apply to a private insurer.

so call your insurance and again, call the Attorney General of your state (no Mr. Eric Holder Chat Icon ) and find out if that practice is acceptable.

the same for you girls living here in NY. call the state and call your insurance plans to see what they say in regard to pre paying a copay.

Chat Icon it really sounds off to me...but like I said...I have different rules dancing around in my head.



It is allowed. I worked in health insurance for years and Dr's are basically allowed to pre bill for deliveries , theres no state regulations or anything.

Its not a "copay"... the 20% is "co-insurance" and follows a bit of a different rule.

The deductible shouldnt be allowed to be billed upfront. They CAN....and it's not illegal but you can fight that with the insurance company, you can have them call .

For the deductible you can tell the OB you are seeing other dr's ( anything for that matter, dermatologist, PCP, etc etc ) and that you cannot determine how much will be applicable to them in the end.

I would fight ALL of it, and say b/c there are other services involved and their is a "Stop loss" ( an amount you hit where the insurance starts paying at 100%) you dont feel comfortable paying now and waiting for a possible refund if you overpay.

Posted 7/29/09 8:36 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
I was feeling the baby move a lot and now not so much. Anyone else go through this jxnoscar 7/28/09 7 Pregnancy
Baby Size at birth KangaMom 3/22/06 23 Pregnancy
When does baby get into position for birth? KAS 3/6/06 4 Pregnancy
Question about Baby Movements right before you gave birth AnnBrunoXO 2/10/06 7 Parenting
Baby shower AND birth announcements? Anniegrl 1/25/06 8 Pregnancy
Shana from Meet the Barkers gives birth to baby girl metsgirlie 12/27/05 12 Families Helping Families ™