anyone have success not doing CIO?

Posted By Message

Aries14
Can't plan life...

Member since 8/08

2860 total posts

Name:

anyone have success not doing CIO?

I want to start by saying that I really don't believe in CIO but decided to give it a shot this week since my DD is 11 months old and still co-sleeping. We know it's time to get her in her crib. We did a few nights that we put her down in the crib, she cried for 15/20 minutes and then fell asleep. I thought GREAT! But it only lasted three nights like this and now for the past four nights as soon as we put her down in the crib she screams, stands up and just won't calm down. This is very different then the first three nights! Like I said, we don't really believe in CIO so we just can't bring ourselves to listen to her scream. Chat Icon Although we did make it through 40 minutes because I felt like I had to really feel like we gave it a shot before saying it didn't work. And now it's just getting worse! Now she starts clingy to me and crying as soon as we even go into her room! I almost feel like I "damaged" her by lettinger her cry in her crib for the last few nights. It's like she gets anxious and scared now as soon as she sees her crib. I'm at aloss and don't know what to do.

I gave the CIO a shot but I truely don't think my dd is cut out for it. My dr said he is behind whatever we decided to do for sleeping but warned us not to make going to bed an anxious, not pleasant experience. I'm affraid that we now made that with the crib. Has anyone had success in other ways besides CIO? I'm open to anything at this point. Thansk!

Posted 10/27/10 11:30 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

carissa1643
I LOVE my sons! :)

Member since 5/09

5283 total posts

Name:
Carissa

Re: anyone have success not doing CIO?

I tried everything before CIO. Then I wasnt being consistent with CIO so we stopped. Then a few weeks later we went back to it. This was over a course of 2 months.

The last time we did CIO was almost 2 months ago and DS was the same way, a little younger than your DD (8m at the time) but he was hysterical if we even went near his room, clinging on for dear life when I put him in the crib, but I had to walk out and leave him there. I really tried everything else first, we couldnt take it anymore. He was miserable and cranky and tired all the time.

I just had to commit and consistently do CIO. So, to answer your question I tried everything else first, I even thought CIO didnt work but it was that I wasnt being consistent.

Message edited 2010-10-27 11:37:25.390000.

Posted 10/27/10 11:36 AM
 

LoveyQ
Stalkers, get a life.

Member since 11/07

12820 total posts

Name:

Re: anyone have success not doing CIO?

Chat Icon My DS is younger than your DD so I don't have experience with that age yet. However, it sounds like she's having separation anxiety, very normal. I think whether or not you had tried CIO, she would probably be the same way now. But, I will say that I've read that if you let them cry and then go get them, they learn that they just need to cry longer before mommy or daddy comes to get them. Also, I've heard many a parent say that CIO took longer than 40 minutes (usually 1hour plus). I know it's SO hard to hear them cry and some parents can't do it, but I just wanted to throw that out there. It may not be that CIO didn't work, but that you needed to give it more time, if that makes sense (not saying you SHOULD have let her cry longer, but that if you wanted to do CIO, then that's probably what she would have needed). Lots of Chat Icon

Posted 10/27/10 11:37 AM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: anyone have success not doing CIO?

I'm no expert but we tried CIO once and it was absolutely horrible. She was so worked up and shaking in sobs. It actually WOKE her up more. It was two hours and that's with me in the room with her. She'd reach down to me (laying on the floor) like she was being tortured. I never wanted her room to be a 'bad' place so after that failed attempt we gave up.

we have two nap mats... one my aunt got her which is plastic and can be folded up. We put like three layers of blankets on that because it has grooves for the folds. then another we bought off woot for travel.. its a puffy thick blanket type thing with a pillow sewn into the top and a blanket also sewn in to go over her. She wanted it on top of her nap area so its on top of all the rest. All of this lays on our living room floor.

She sleeps and we pick her up and move her over to her toddler bed. (been in it since 20m) but we did the same with her in her crib. If she woke up it was only like once a night and it was easier to just stay in her room with her. I won't lie .. until the toddler bed was put in we would be lazy and bring her to bed but she STTN mostly so our justification was at least it wasn't every night. Once the toddler bed got in, we'd just lay on the floor next to her until she went back to sleep.

Last month or so she's been asking us both to go into her room to 'sleep' and we all lay on the floor in there. I've even laid in her bed with her (one huge feat I might add). It only worked after we padded her mattress with blankets to make it softer because the hard mattress would wake her up EVERY SINGLE TIME because compared to our bed or her mat it was a huge difference.

I will say though AJ can sleep through anything! So it makes it a bit easier for us in a way. We do NOT move her until she's totally out for the night. Snoring is better.

Sure its not textbook

Sure some may frown at it

But do I care? heck no

She sleeps in her bed.
We sleep in ours.

She was coslept until 6mo, then again from 8-12m, then yet AGAIN from 19-22m because we moved a few times and she stayed with my aunt who slept with her on a inflatable bed. So breaking her of cosleep would NEVER be easy. But what we do works for us and that's all that matters, right?

Posted 10/27/10 11:44 AM
 

Aries14
Can't plan life...

Member since 8/08

2860 total posts

Name:

Re: anyone have success not doing CIO?

Thank you ladies for responding. Chat Icon

I know that CIO can take longer then 40 minutes, but that is really the most we are comfortable doing. Manily bc it seems to make things worse the longer we leave her.

I want to be consistant, I really do. But it just feels like it's doing more harm then good at this point. She cries even before we get to her room Chat Icon Should I wait and try again in a few weeks?

Posted 10/27/10 11:44 AM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: anyone have success not doing CIO?

Our ped isn't a fan of CIO and neither are we.

We try to keep to a nighly routine of bath, book and bed when he looks drowzy and so far we are getting 5-7 hours of sleep a night.

If he wakes up I bring him to bed to feed him, he stays in bed because I'm too tired to bring him back after he's done BF.

Posted 10/27/10 11:49 AM
 

Aries14
Can't plan life...

Member since 8/08

2860 total posts

Name:

Re: anyone have success not doing CIO?

Posted by Xelindrya

I'm no expert but we tried CIO once and it was absolutely horrible. She was so worked up and shaking in sobs. It actually WOKE her up more. It was two hours and that's with me in the room with her. She'd reach down to me (laying on the floor) like she was being tortured. I never wanted her room to be a 'bad' place so after that failed attempt we gave up.

we have two nap mats... one my aunt got her which is plastic and can be folded up. We put like three layers of blankets on that because it has grooves for the folds. then another we bought off woot for travel.. its a puffy thick blanket type thing with a pillow sewn into the top and a blanket also sewn in to go over her. She wanted it on top of her nap area so its on top of all the rest. All of this lays on our living room floor.

She sleeps and we pick her up and move her over to her toddler bed. (been in it since 20m) but we did the same with her in her crib. If she woke up it was only like once a night and it was easier to just stay in her room with her. I won't lie .. until the toddler bed was put in we would be lazy and bring her to bed but she STTN mostly so our justification was at least it wasn't every night. Once the toddler bed got in, we'd just lay on the floor next to her until she went back to sleep.

Last month or so she's been asking us both to go into her room to 'sleep' and we all lay on the floor in there. I've even laid in her bed with her (one huge feat I might add). It only worked after we padded her mattress with blankets to make it softer because the hard mattress would wake her up EVERY SINGLE TIME because compared to our bed or her mat it was a huge difference.

I will say though AJ can sleep through anything! So it makes it a bit easier for us in a way. We do NOT move her until she's totally out for the night. Snoring is better.

Sure its not textbook

Sure some may frown at it

But do I care? heck no

She sleeps in her bed.
We sleep in ours.

She was coslept until 6mo, then again from 8-12m, then yet AGAIN from 19-22m because we moved a few times and she stayed with my aunt who slept with her on a inflatable bed. So breaking her of cosleep would NEVER be easy. But what we do works for us and that's all that matters, right?




Thanks for sharing Chat Icon I think softing up the matteress is a great idea! I mean she's so used to ours and hers is like a rock!

When I asked our ped about this I really thought we would get a whole speech about getting her in her crib and not feeding in the middle of the night.... to my pleasant surprise he was very much "whatever works. If she is sleeping and you are sleeping.. that's all that matters."

Posted 10/27/10 11:50 AM
 

Aries14
Can't plan life...

Member since 8/08

2860 total posts

Name:

Re: anyone have success not doing CIO?

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Our ped isn't a fan of CIO and neither are we.

We try to keep to a nighly routine of bath, book and bed when he looks drowzy and so far we are getting 5-7 hours of sleep a night.

If he wakes up I bring him to bed to feed him, he stays in bed because I'm too tired to bring him back after he's done BF.




Our ped is the same way. He said he would never tell a parent not to do it but he wouldn't do it with his kids.

I even asked about her waking still for a bottle and expected to hear that she doesn't need it and to stop it even if she cries for it. But instead he said "if it were me I would rather get up for 10 minutes to feed her and go right back to sleep then have her cry for an hour". He believes kids drop bottles and STTN when they are ready.

ETA: But my real post/questuin isnt about the bottles - I want her to be ok sleeping in her crib at this point. We can work on dropping feedings after, lol

Message edited 2010-10-27 11:55:37.867000.

Posted 10/27/10 11:54 AM
 

Dulcinea
Weekend Warrior

Member since 3/08

2530 total posts

Name:
Dulcinea

Re: anyone have success not doing CIO?

Definitely wait if you don't think DC is ready.

A month ago, we got our cosleeping 21 mo. DS to sleep in his converted crib. We made sure he was very sleepy, then did the bath, book, then bed routine. He also gets a lovey of his choice (his ball). Then it is lights out!

No CIO here, the key is just to make sure he has the routine, he's sleepy and has a lovey. Also have dad put DC to sleep if he/she responds better to that.

Good luck!




Posted 10/27/10 12:29 PM
 

Dulcinea
Weekend Warrior

Member since 3/08

2530 total posts

Name:
Dulcinea

Re: anyone have success not doing CIO?

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Our ped isn't a fan of CIO and neither are we.

We try to keep to a nighly routine of bath, book and bed when he looks drowzy and so far we are getting 5-7 hours of sleep a night.

If he wakes up I bring him to bed to feed him, he stays in bed because I'm too tired to bring him back after he's done BF.




This is exactly what I do. Love being able to sleep abit with him before having to get up for work.

Posted 10/27/10 12:32 PM
 

NoStressMom
My Heart and Soul

Member since 5/05

11122 total posts

Name:
D

Re: anyone have success not doing CIO?

add me to the list we just can't do it DD is 16 months old she has been cosleeping with us since she was 11 months old before that slept great no issue with her crib and then we moved into our house she was teething got sick and ended up in our bed and now she falls alseep on our bed we move her to the crib in her room and she wakes up around 2am and we put her in with us until we have to get up at 6am it works for us we all get our sleep. I'm happy with that for now. hope you find your balanceChat Icon

Posted 10/27/10 12:34 PM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: anyone have success not doing CIO?

I never really did CIO. I tried but failed. I always went in and comforted my kids a couple of times. If, then, I knew they were fine once I picked them up then I might let them go for 15 or 20 mins. If they didn;t fall asleep after that I would go back in and rock them. They are both very good sleepers now. When I ask them in they want to go night noght, they run to the stairsChat Icon

Posted 10/27/10 12:36 PM
 

KartveliT
...

Member since 1/08

8363 total posts

Name:

Re: anyone have success not doing CIO?

DD was a terrible sleeper first 2 + years , especially when she was a NB to around 18 mos....
Most of the time the problem wasn't her falling asleep, it was her staying asleep, she woke up at least 2-3 times a night , but since I do not believe in CIO (when it comes to my own DC, I don't really care what others do) it I never even tried it , we just dealt with sleepless nights, tried different things to get her to go back to sleep - I would hold her and walk around the house, sing to her, read to her, rock her, when she got older let her watch TV 15 min or so and finally get her down again.....
One thing though she would never , ever sleep in our bed, no matter how much I tried. She had to be in her crib.
Around 2 she started sleeping better and at 2.5 she was sleeping through the night , I mean we've had few bad nights, but nothing compared to earlier days Chat Icon (she is 3)

Message edited 2010-10-27 12:37:52.500000.

Posted 10/27/10 12:37 PM
 

Lara&Aidansmommy
For mom i miss u ETC ILOVEU

Member since 3/07

13921 total posts

Name:
ETC I LOVE YOU

Re: anyone have success not doing CIO?

I am no help at allChat Icon My dd still cosleeps with us and shes 10 months old. I just want to say I feel a little better knowing I am not alone Chat Icon

Posted 10/27/10 12:49 PM
 

Aries14
Can't plan life...

Member since 8/08

2860 total posts

Name:

Re: anyone have success not doing CIO?

Posted by Larasmommy

I am no help at allChat Icon My dd still cosleeps with us and shes 10 months old. I just want to say I feel a little better knowing I am not alone Chat Icon



Chat Icon me too! It also helps to hear that people were able to have good sleepers down the road.

Posted 10/27/10 1:02 PM
 

sleepie76
enjoying every minute

Member since 12/07

3881 total posts

Name:

Re: anyone have success not doing CIO?

I'm not a CIO mom.
NO WAY could I do over 40 minutes.
I could probably do 10 or so.

She has her bottle then cuddles up on us on the couch and falls asleep. We transer her to the crib when she is asleep. She may open her eyes and see where she is, either close and go right back to sleep or let out a little cry.

I wish I had a routine where I could put her down drowsy and she would go to sleep but it never happened. She was a horror with the bassinet and crib. I'm thankful we ever got her to the crib.


She usually wakes at 4-5am crying, I get her and bring her to our bed.


I flipped the mattress early, the infant side was like a rock! Once I flipped to the softer side we had more success.
I wouldnt want to sleep on that mattress either.

It probably took us 2 months to get her into that crib, my Ped wasnt a fan of CIO either. I started by familiarizing her with the crib. Put her in it & play peek a boo. Or let her stand in there while I put her laundry away. So she got used to it and stopped being afraid of it as a nighttime torture device. Lay her down for naps, if she wakes up crying, I would rock her and then put her back in the crib. She slowly accepted the fact that this was her room and crib wasnt so scary.

Message edited 2010-10-27 13:30:25.767000.

Posted 10/27/10 1:25 PM
 

OrganicMama
So in love with my little man!

Member since 6/08

5172 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: anyone have success not doing CIO?

I'm no help because DS is only 5 months. I'm not a CIO mom, nor will I ever be. DS goes from completely happy to full blown screaming tears in less than 60 seconds, so to let him cry for even a minute is torture for both me and him. I've read some CIO articles and I don't like what I've read, so I could never do it (it's just not for me, I don't care what others do).

Anyways, my suggestion would be to pick up a book from Dr. Sears, he has suggestions for non-CIO moms.
Chat Icon

Posted 10/27/10 1:43 PM
 

Aries14
Can't plan life...

Member since 8/08

2860 total posts

Name:

Re: anyone have success not doing CIO?

It really helps hearing everyones stories and things they tried. Thank you ladies. I still don't know what the right answer for us is yet but at least I have a few ideas of things to try!

Posted 10/27/10 2:08 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: anyone have success not doing CIO?

We did with my DD. I never really needed to let her cry.
DS, not so much. He started sleeping all night at 17 months and recently has started waking up again.
It just doesn't feel right to me to let my children cry. I know they can sleep on their own so I feel like when they are off this sleep pattern something is going on and they need whatever extra comfort they are looking for. My DD is 5 and sleeps with me because right now she can't handle sleeping alone. While it's not ideal it feels right to me as a parent to meet her needs at the moment.

Posted 10/27/10 2:49 PM
 

Wendy
Wheeee!

Member since 5/05

13736 total posts

Name:

Re: anyone have success not doing CIO?

We were going to give it a whirl but I know I won't be able to do it.

Ann is 16 months, falls asleep snuggling, watching TV with me in my bed, then I put her in her crib. She sleeps through the night. I'm sure it's not the "right way" to get her to sleep but it works (for now! Chat Icon ).



ETA: I did try putting her in the crib awake and just staying in the room with her until she fell asleep - based on an article I read in Parents - but it didn't work any better than I think CIO would and I ended up picking her up anyway! Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-10-27 14:53:30.510000.

Posted 10/27/10 2:51 PM
 

Dulcinea
Weekend Warrior

Member since 3/08

2530 total posts

Name:
Dulcinea

Re: anyone have success not doing CIO?

Posted by Wendy

We were going to give it a whirl but I know I won't be able to do it.

Ann is 16 months, falls asleep snuggling, watching TV with me in my bed, then I put her in her crib. She sleeps through the night. I'm sure it's not the "right way" to get her to sleep but it works (for now! Chat Icon ).



ETA: I did try putting her in the crib awake and just staying in the room with her until she fell asleep - based on an article I read in Parents - but it didn't work any better than I think CIO would and I ended up picking her up anyway! Chat Icon



My brother does the same thing with his 2 yo. I don't think there's a a right or wrong way as long as your child is getting enough sleep.

You don't need CIO to teach your child to sleep through the night. They will eventually learn to do so. We all did, didn't we? ;)

Posted 10/28/10 4:51 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
woo hoo! CIO Success! Laura1976 6/3/09 1 Parenting
BTDT moms who had success with CIO, PLEASE come in! bayla 10/23/08 3 Parenting
Sleep Resources for Parents who aren't doing CIO Grill 5/19/10 0 Parenting
CIO advice- doing thei TONIGHT sal79 12/29/09 3 Parenting
doing CIO for the 2nd time... headoverheels 11/2/09 4 Parenting
Anyone have success with acupuncture (and not doing IVF or IUI) ? nywebchic 8/21/06 1 Infertility