Another Spinoff - Airport Security

Posted By Message

DancinBarefoot
06ers Rock!!

Member since 1/07

9537 total posts

Name:
The One My Mother Gave Me ;-)

Another Spinoff - Airport Security

Does this scare you??

. . . . . . . . . . . .
Late last week, the Transportation Security Administration, bowing to controversy and the threat of lawsuits, ruled that airline pilots will no longer be subject to the backscatter body scanners and invasive pat-downs at TSA airport checkpoints.

For pilots like myself this is good news, though at least for the time being we remain subject to the rest of the checkpoint inspection, including the X-raying of luggage and the metal detector walk-through. Eventually, we are told, the implementation of so-called CrewPASS will allow us to skirt the checkpoint more or less entirely.

Not everybody agrees that air crews deserve this special treatment. That's not an unreasonable point of view, and I don't disagree with it, necessarily. As security experts like Bruce Schneier point out, if you are going to screen at all, it is important to screen everybody, lest the system become overly complicated and prone to exploitable loopholes.

(Incidentally, the requirement that crews undergo checkpoint screening was imposed by the Federal Aviation Administration after the crash of a Pacific Southwest Airlines flight in 1987. A recently terminated flight attendant, David Burke, used his credentials, which the airline had failed to recover, to carry a concealed handgun onto Flight 1771 from Los Angeles to San Francisco. En route, he shot both pilots and nosed the airplane into the ground near Harmony, Calif., killing all 44 on board.)

But this is a useful approach only if the system is rational and effective to start with. As a pilot I would have no problem going through screening together with everybody else -- just not the screening we currently have in place, with its bullying and its mindless protocols and its wasteful obsession with minutiae.

And by "contradictory," here's some blockbuster news: Although the X-ray and metal detector rigmarole is mandatory for pilots and flight attendants, many other airport workers, including those with regular access to aircraft -- to cabins, cockpits, galleys and freight compartments -- are exempt. That's correct. Uniformed pilots cannot carry butter knives onto an airplane, yet apron workers and contract ground support staff -- cargo loaders, baggage handlers, fuelers, cabin cleaners, caterers -- can, as a matter of routine, bypass TSA inspection entirely.

All workers with airside privileges are subject to fingerprinting, a 10-year criminal background investigation and crosschecking against terror watch lists. Additionally they are subject to random physical checks by TSA. But here's what one apron worker at New York's Kennedy airport recently told me:

"All I need is my Port Authority ID, which I swipe through a turnstile. The 'sterile area' door is not watched over by any hired security or by TSA. I have worked at JFK for more than three years now and I have yet to be randomly searched. Really the only TSA presence we notice is when the blue-shirts come down to the cafeteria to get food."

Actually, this is something I wrote about, to no measurable reception, in a column over five years ago. Little has changed since then. With all of the recent talk about airport security, this ought to be a bombshell of a story. Every media outfit in the country should be covering it. It undermines almost everything TSA has told us from the beginning about the "need" to screen pilots and flight attendants, and if there is a more ringing "let me get this straight ..." scenario anywhere in the realm of airport security, I’d like to hear it.

This is one of the reasons I've been somewhat disappointed by all of the recent attention and controversy over body scanners and pat-downs. Sure, the deployment of the scanners is rightfully controversial; the devices raise important privacy issues, and possibly health issues as well. (And, yes, it is heartening that finally, after almost 10 years, we're seeing a groundswell of resistance against TSA.) The downside to this conversation, however, is that it distracts us from asking important questions about the agency's approach to security overall.

The purpose of highlighting this loophole is not to scare or sensationalize, and enacting yet another layer of zero-tolerance screening, this time for ground workers, is possibly the exact wrong response. The answer, if you ask me, rests in the middle. I would propose somewhat tougher screening for underwing employees, while ratcheting down somewhat the overzealous scrutiny of pilots and flight attendants. You may or may not agree, but in the meantime one thing is certain: This is, for now, a double standard so brazen and hypocritical as to be almost unbelievable.

- - - - - - - - - - - -

Do you have questions for Salon's aviation expert? Contact Patrick Smith through his website and look for answers in a future column.



LINK

Message edited 2010-11-22 14:12:10.480000.

Posted 11/22/10 2:11 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

heathergirl
Cocktail Time!

Member since 10/08

4978 total posts

Name:
American mouth

Re: Another Spinoff - Airport Security

I think all airport/airplane personnel should be subject to the same security guidelines as anybody else.

Posted 11/22/10 2:18 PM
 

WhatNow
Say Cheese!

Member since 1/06

8033 total posts

Name:
A (formerly WhatNow?)

Re: Another Spinoff - Airport Security

I comlitely disagree with airport personal forgoing the security check!

Unless screening is done based on racial profiling, everyone getting on a plane should go through security. You just never know...

Posted 11/22/10 2:26 PM
 

heidla
Me and the guys

Member since 5/05

4024 total posts

Name:
Heidi

Re: Another Spinoff - Airport Security

This scares me!

security at its finest?

Message edited 2010-11-22 15:11:47.017000.

Posted 11/22/10 3:00 PM
 

MissRadiant
Happily Ever After

Member since 9/08

2534 total posts

Name:
N

Re: Another Spinoff - Airport Security

I think crew members should have to go through the same type of security that regular passengers go through. Even if it is in a different and quicker line. If we have to get to the airports 2 hours early- then they should report to work 45 minutes early to follow the proper protocol.

ETA: WOAH I just saw that video. No way would I allow my kid to be touched like that. Why did he have to take off his shirt??!!!! Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-11-22 15:39:57.150000.

Posted 11/22/10 3:07 PM
 

DancinBarefoot
06ers Rock!!

Member since 1/07

9537 total posts

Name:
The One My Mother Gave Me ;-)

Re: Another Spinoff - Airport Security

Posted by heidla

This scares me!

security at its finest?



Well, I guess all this talk about children under the age of 12 not being subject to a pat down is true - instead they get strip searched. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 11/22/10 3:19 PM
 

Aries14
Can't plan life...

Member since 8/08

2860 total posts

Name:

Re: Another Spinoff - Airport Security

Posted by DancinBarefoot

Posted by heidla

This scares me!

security at its finest?



Well, I guess all this talk about children under the age of 12 not being subject to a pat down is true - instead they get strip searched. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



I would not fly if it meant my daughter had to endure this

Posted 11/22/10 3:27 PM
 

heidla
Me and the guys

Member since 5/05

4024 total posts

Name:
Heidi

Re: Another Spinoff - Airport Security

Posted by Aries14

Posted by DancinBarefoot

Posted by heidla

This scares me!

security at its finest?



Well, I guess all this talk about children under the age of 12 not being subject to a pat down is true - instead they get strip searched. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



I would not fly if it meant my daughter had to endure this



ITA!!

Posted 11/22/10 3:35 PM
 

summerBaby10
let's be nice

Member since 9/07

10208 total posts

Name:
Wifey

Re: Another Spinoff - Airport Security

Posted by Aries14

Posted by DancinBarefoot

Posted by heidla

This scares me!

security at its finest?



Well, I guess all this talk about children under the age of 12 not being subject to a pat down is true - instead they get strip searched. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



I would not fly if it meant my daughter had to endure this



I wouldn't either. That video is creepy & it's done in front of so many people.
Unfortunately, I wouldn't put it past extremist terrorists to use children as bomb carriers.

Posted 11/22/10 3:36 PM
 

Christine
2nd verse same as the 1st

Member since 5/05

15287 total posts

Name:

Re: Another Spinoff - Airport Security

Posted by heidla

Posted by Aries14

Posted by DancinBarefoot

Posted by heidla

This scares me!

security at its finest?



Well, I guess all this talk about children under the age of 12 not being subject to a pat down is true - instead they get strip searched. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



I would not fly if it meant my daughter had to endure this



ITA!!



I can't believe the father stood there and allowed that to happen.

I wonder if this video was taken prior to raising the age. I think it was originally set at 6 years old. Not that I'd want to see a 13 year patted down like that either. Chat Icon

Posted 11/22/10 3:37 PM
 

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: Another Spinoff - Airport Security

This isn't right. I think every single person who steps foot past airport security should have to go through it. And not just half the checks- all of them.

ETA: A few comments say the video was cut off in the beginning at that the fatehr, who was irate, took the boy's shirt off. Don't know how true it is, but it's something to consider.

Message edited 2010-11-22 15:43:58.130000.

Posted 11/22/10 3:41 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Another Spinoff - Airport Security

I wouldn't allow my children to be patted down like that at all.

But on the topic, I do believe that all airport personnel should be checked as everyone else is - unsure if bodyscanning is the way to go.

For pilots, I do find it a little strange because I see no reason why they would need to carry a bomb or weapon when they're the ones driving the plane. They could just aim down, no?

Posted 11/22/10 3:49 PM
 

heidla
Me and the guys

Member since 5/05

4024 total posts

Name:
Heidi

Re: Another Spinoff - Airport Security

Posted by jilliibabii

This isn't right. I think every single person who steps foot past airport security should have to go through it. And not just half the checks- all of them.

ETA: A few comments say the video was cut off in the beginning at that the fatehr, who was irate, took the boy's shirt off. Don't know how true it is, but it's something to consider.



I just saw those too. They still patted him down. I've been patted down twice in the past year and I didn't even set the metel detector off! They claimed once my dress was too baggy and the other time my dress was too long.

Posted 11/22/10 3:51 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Another Spinoff - Airport Security

I would have a complete meltdown is someone touched my child like that. Obviously someone took a whole video on top of that. A complete stranger.

Talk about teaching our children that stranger should not touch them, especially in their private area. And now you have that. Kids being "humiliated" because if someone had touched me like that when I was a little girl in front of everyone to watch, I would have been traumatized.

I guess I just won't be flying anymore.

And if I have to go through the humiliation of scaners.. well so can a pilot or ANYONE working at an airport or in a plane.

Message edited 2010-11-22 16:03:53.600000.

Posted 11/22/10 4:02 PM
 

jilliibabii
Mrs. O'Connor

Member since 6/10

12821 total posts

Name:
Jillian

Re: Another Spinoff - Airport Security

Posted by nrthshgrl

For pilots, I do find it a little strange because I see no reason why they would need to carry a bomb or weapon when they're the ones driving the plane. They could just aim down, no?



I'm sorry, I just LOLed at that. Chat Icon

I guess they could but there's other people in the cockpit. I hope they'd try and stop him!

Posted 11/22/10 4:08 PM
 

codybear
Our Family is Complete!

Member since 11/06

2064 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: Another Spinoff - Airport Security

Posted by DancinBarefoot

"But this is a useful approach only if the system is rational and effective to start with. As a pilot I would have no problem going through screening together with everybody else -- just not the screening we currently have in place, with its bullying and its mindless protocols and its wasteful obsession with minutiae."


This is exactly how I feel, as a regular traveler, I have no problem going through the screening, if it was even effective.


Posted 11/22/10 4:24 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Getting a breastpump through airport security? A-Nonny-Mouse 9/9/09 6 Parenting
Security Screening at Airport Ian&EmmesMommy23 7/10/09 3 Pregnancy
Madge Won't Disrobe for Airport Security GossipQueen 8/29/08 17 Celebrities & Entertainment
Security breach at McArthur Airport Gumpslilqtpie 7/25/08 7 Families Helping Families ™
Clear- fly through airport security MrsPorkChop 6/25/08 4 Travel & Vacations
Airport Security - what was a checked for? Waste06 3/21/08 4 Travel & Vacations