Another carseat question - convertible

Posted By Message

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Another carseat question - convertible

So, I was given a brand new just out of the box Evenflo carseat back in September. It's in my dads car.

Should I just take that and use that as Tyler's carseat - or would you buy him a Britax (like I have for Jack)

I know that Britax is supposedly the best and feel guilty that Tyler won't be in one.

Oh, and there is a website that I can get the Marathon for only 229.

What would you do??????

ETA: I would put the Evenflo in my husbands car as the second seat.

Message edited 2010-04-18 10:18:15.537000.

Posted 4/18/10 10:17 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

charon54
My two boys!

Member since 5/05

7279 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: Another carseat question - convertible

I love my Evenflo car seats! We have 3, one for each of our cars and one for MIL's.

I can't see spending the amount of money they charge for a Britax. The Evenflos are just as safe. And they fit better in our cars too.

Posted 4/18/10 10:19 AM
 

InShock
life is good

Member since 10/06

9258 total posts

Name:

Re: Another carseat question - convertible

If you put the Evenflo in your DH's car, then what would be in your car?

If you have a Britax for your car (primary place he rides, right?), then I think the Evenflo in your DH's car is fine!

Posted 4/18/10 10:22 AM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Another carseat question - convertible

Posted by InShock

If you put the Evenflo in your DH's car, then what would be in your car?

If you have a Britax for your car (primary place he rides, right?), then I think the Evenflo in your DH's car is fine!



I would have to buy a Britax for my car and would put the Evenflo in DH's car - but in reality DH doesn't need two carseats in his car bc he will hardly ever have both boys - and if he did he would just take the minivan. KWIM?

Posted 4/18/10 10:26 AM
 

BabyBoy
is Skylar Elizabeth

Member since 5/05

4189 total posts

Name:
Tom

Re: Another carseat question - convertible

all car seats have to meet certain safety and gov't standards.

i always wanted a britax when planning and waiting for the baby but reality set in when i was ready to buy and i was not paying $800 for 2 car seats just to say i have britax.

i found my trufit seat to be better then most britiax models and it is the fraction of the cost...

a brand is a brand..features and how it's built are similar with some difference...is that difference worth $$$$? that is your call.

look at other seats..they are many products that will fit your needs.

For what its worth, evenflo was my 2nd choice...

Message edited 2010-04-18 10:36:43.203000.

Posted 4/18/10 10:36 AM
 

autumn
Mommy to 2 divas

Member since 9/07

3389 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: Another carseat question - convertible

I just got an evenflo symphony for my car because its a 3 in 1 and I don't want to spend money again on another seat. DH has the britax marathon in his car, which DD rarely goes in because she is with me more.

SO far I love my seat in my car.

Posted 4/18/10 10:47 AM
 

tara73
carseat nerd

Member since 11/09

3669 total posts

Name:
Buttercup

Re: Another carseat question - convertible

Posted by BabyBoy

all car seats have to meet certain safety and gov't standards.

a brand is a brand..features and how it's built are similar with some difference...is that difference worth $$$$? that is your call.

look at other seats..they are many products that will fit your needs.

For what its worth, evenflo was my 2nd choice...

<snipped some portions out>



All of this.

There are SO many seats that have surpassed the Britax Marathons and Boulevards in terms of features and weight limits. Britax's latest "innovations" amount to a useless "Click Safe" feature which only works on occasion and adding ginormous pillows to the side of a Boulevard. There are rumors they are coming out with something new this spring, I hope it addresses some of the areas their current seat lineup lacks (like lack of RF leg room and outdated RF limits)

I don't understand why people think Britax is so much safer than others. Good marketing I suppose, but it still bothers me. The Marathon actually performed quite poorly in Transport Canada's testing in forward facing mode with a 51lb dummy. (If you want details, google is your friend).

I own a Britax, it's not a bash against them, but against the perception that it's the "only" seat out there that is "bulletproof". At the time I purchased it for DD it fit our needs for a high RF limit and side impact protection. Since then I've purchased a Graco MyRide and a First Years Learning curve TrueFit. Both of those seats are superior to the Boulevard we have for ease of use, features, size and how much room my DD has. We are due with # 2 and Britax isn't even on the radar this go around.

Evenflo has come a LOOOOONG way with their seats, and their Sure Latch is really cool to help with installation. The Momentum 65 looks to be a promising addition to the Symphony 65 and the Maestro. The only seats I don't like of their current lineup are their infant buckets due to a requirement that the handle be down AND their be a 1 1/2" clearance between the handle and the front seat back.

Sunshine Kids' Radians are a great seat with SuperLatch which allows you to use LATCh for installation in any 2006 or newer vehicle up to the limit of the seat (currently 65 and 80lbs) Regular LATCH installation must be changed to a seatbelt install at 40lbs. They also currently have the highest rear facing limits at 45lbs in the XTSL have a narrow enough footprint that they can fit 3 across in most cars. They are also a steel alloy frame. Talk about a strong seat, here is a story and pics of one which survived a parking garage collapse http://www.car-seat.org/showthread.php?t=90385

Graco has also moved with the times and upped the limits on its SafeSeat from 30lbs to 32lbs and now to a current 35lbs (albeit by changing the name they have managed to confuse parents with 2 different SnugRides). They've come out with the Nautilus, a combination seat that is reasonably priced and harnesses to 65lbs (which also has 18" top slots on it's harness and will allow children to remain harnessed longer) and the MyRide with a 40lb RF limit and a nice deep shell and easy install.

Learning Curve/First Years TrueFit is a wonderful seat with a No rethread harness and great ease of use. Most recently they released the TrueFit Premier which has an anti rebound bar for rear facing (similar to Sunshine Kids and Britax allowing for RF tethering)

Even Safety 1st/Dorel has come out with a Complete Air with a 40lb RF limit and side impact protection system which they also added to the new Onboard 35 infant seat (35lb seat)

There are so many more options which have been released in the past 2 years with a seat in just about everyone's price range. And for every seat on the market there is a negative side as well. There is no "perfect" seat out there.

There is no "safest" seat available on the market, really. While all the seats must pass the same Federal standards, there are millions of variables involved in crash dynamics, including how the seat was installed and used, which determine the outcome.

The "right" seat is the seat that properly fits your vehicle, properly fits your child, properly installed, properly used EVERY TIME and is within your budget.

Posted 4/18/10 9:57 PM
 

Diana1215
Living on a prayer!!!

Member since 10/05

29450 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Another carseat question - convertible

Wow thank you so much for all of the information! I think i will be using the Evenflo

Posted 4/18/10 10:02 PM
 

MrsNicolaxoxo
<3

Member since 6/09

3403 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Another carseat question - convertible

I would use the evenfloChat Icon

Posted 4/18/10 10:03 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
another carseat/jacket question (re: convertible car seats) Myababy 1/3/10 11 Parenting
Convertible Carseat Question lkrpaul 10/27/09 0 Parenting
Convertible Carseat Question... CarlieJLD7 10/3/09 10 Parenting
Convertible Carseat Question cjik 3/15/09 18 Parenting
Convertible Carseat Question zeta1996 4/7/07 11 Parenting
Convertible carseat question... CaidensMommy 1/14/07 5 Parenting