American Idol Top 13

Posted By Message

BaysideForever
LIF Adult

Member since 1/11

9976 total posts

Name:

American Idol Top 13

What did you think?

So many contestants made big mistakes in my opinion. Other seasons are usually so smooth, I have been surprised with how choppy these performances have been.

Posted 3/8/12 11:44 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

FrankiesGirl107
My Girls

Member since 12/06

3642 total posts

Name:
Amee

Re: American Idol Top 13

LOVE LOVE LOVE Jessica Sanchez...been saying it for a while, and last night wasn't perfect, but the best of the bunch by far!!

I liked Ericka, Joshua and Hollie as well.

I think Shannon is gone...that was just awful. And although I like Elise, I didn't think she did that well...

Same for Phillip...I felt like the 'show' part of his performance overpowered his singing...

Posted 3/8/12 11:50 AM
 

BaysideForever
LIF Adult

Member since 1/11

9976 total posts

Name:

Re: American Idol Top 13

Posted by FrankiesGirl107

LOVE LOVE LOVE Jessica Sanchez...been saying it for a while, and last night wasn't perfect, but the best of the bunch by far!!




She does have an amazing voice but I can't stand watching her. She does this irritating thing with her fingers on the mic. It kept bothering me the entire performance. But yeah, great job on that song!

Posted 3/8/12 12:05 PM
 

lbelle821
Arghhhhh

Member since 2/06

5285 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: American Idol Top 13

I think Jessica Sanchez is great too but I'm afraid that her stength in ballad-ey type songs might hurt her like it did for Pia Toscano who got kicked off early.

She really did great last night.

My heart belongs to Phil thoughChat Icon

Posted 3/8/12 12:22 PM
 

PrettyPeonies
GAW my baby boy <3

Member since 8/10

3874 total posts

Name:
Pino

Re: American Idol Top 13

Posted by lbelle821

I think Jessica Sanchez is great too but I'm afraid that her stength in ballad-ey type songs might hurt her like it did for Pia Toscano who got kicked off early.

She really did great last night.

My heart belongs to Phil thoughChat Icon



I'm w/you word for word on this. I love Phil simply b/c he reminds me of Dave Matthews. I would like to see him mix it up a bit.

Posted 3/8/12 12:25 PM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: American Idol Top 13

I think Jessica Sanchez is AMAZING. And I always think that the fingers thing is actually an indication of genuine musicality.. she feels it, she doesn't just sing it. I absolutely love her.

I've thought about her compared to Pia Toscano last year and I think Jessica has something Pia doesn't. Pia had the voice but she was flat and stiff. She didn't connect AT ALL and that was her problem. Jessica isn't like that.

I really liked Phil too. I can see him in the top 3 for sure.

I agree with what an OP said about so many people having mistakes... almost everyone started out rocky. Simon would have crushed a lot of these kids for sure.

Posted 3/8/12 12:30 PM
 

Mere09
So Dam* Lucky

Member since 10/08

6368 total posts

Name:

Re: American Idol Top 13

Can I just say something about Phil Phillips.....

He needs to STOP mimicking Dave Matthews. Every little thing that he does: the way he speaks, the way he dances, the way he holds his guitar, the way he sings is an EXACT replica of Dave Matthews. It's crazy!!!
He's obviously very talented but he needs to start doing his own thing. I'm a HUGE DMB fan and really liked him in the beginning because he reminded me of Dave, but it's getting to the point where it's too much and coming off VERY unoriginal.

Jessica Sanchez.... HOLY MOLY!! That chick can sing!!!

Posted 3/8/12 1:28 PM
 

FrankiesGirl107
My Girls

Member since 12/06

3642 total posts

Name:
Amee

Re: American Idol Top 13

Posted by BaysideForever

Posted by FrankiesGirl107

LOVE LOVE LOVE Jessica Sanchez...been saying it for a while, and last night wasn't perfect, but the best of the bunch by far!!




She does have an amazing voice but I can't stand watching her. She does this irritating thing with her fingers on the mic. It kept bothering me the entire performance. But yeah, great job on that song!



I noticed that....but then again, Scotty McCreery had a funny way of holding the mic too Chat Icon

Posted 3/8/12 1:41 PM
 

MrsFlatbread
Skinny jeans are in my future

Member since 6/06

10258 total posts

Name:
Baby Momma

Re: American Idol Top 13

Hee San (or whatever it is) has to go. It's almost comical that he is there. That church kid too. Bleh. Terrible.

Jessica and Hollie are my favorites.

Posted 3/8/12 2:12 PM
 

KaKa2323
Got my miracle

Member since 9/11

1465 total posts

Name:
K

Re: American Idol Top 13

Posted by eroxgirl

I think Jessica Sanchez is AMAZING. And I always think that the fingers thing is actually an indication of genuine musicality.. she feels it, she doesn't just sing it. I absolutely love her.

I've thought about her compared to Pia Toscano last year and I think Jessica has something Pia doesn't. Pia had the voice but she was flat and stiff. She didn't connect AT ALL and that was her problem. Jessica isn't like that.

I really liked Phil too. I can see him in the top 3 for sure.

I agree with what an OP said about so many people having mistakes... almost everyone started out rocky. Simon would have crushed a lot of these kids for sure.

ITA on everything you saidChat Icon

Message edited 2012-03-08 14:48:19.830000.

Posted 3/8/12 2:47 PM
 

bella
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

1871 total posts

Name:

Re: American Idol Top 13

I really like Erika, I think she is going to go far in this competition. I think she is going to be one of those that just keeps gradually getting better and getting through and then is there at the end peaking at the right time (now I sound like Randy, LOL!)

Jessica was good as well and while I liked Hollie (and I believe she is the same age as Jessica) she looked like such a young girl , almost too young, that might impact her chances with song choices etc going forward. I often find the younger kids have a harder time with song choices because the judges don't expect them to pick something too "mature"....I think it's almost harder for younger kids....but maybe that's just becasue I'm getting too OLD!

Posted 3/8/12 4:09 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
A girl at work is trying out for American Idol! Shroggie 8/11/06 6 Families Helping Families ™
I won something in the American Idol Ford Sweepstakes! randella 5/24/06 22 Families Helping Families ™
American Idol Fans - aka - Katharine Fans, COME ON IN!!!!! MrsERod 5/23/06 96 Families Helping Families ™
Does anyone know the boy from Levittown that is on American Idol? MRSJLK 2/22/06 37 Families Helping Families ™
Kelly Clarkson won't let American Idol use her songs! calendargrl 1/18/06 29 Families Helping Families ™
American Idol fans -guess who visited the troops? PIC ADDED 05mommy09 1/10/06 14 Families Helping Families ™