Am I missing something ? Article on IVF ...

Posted By Message

Bops
My 3 wishes

Member since 12/07

13625 total posts

Name:

Am I missing something ? Article on IVF ...

My DD was from an IVF and my DS #2 was from a frozen embryo transfer from her "batch"...So "technically" my DC's are twins just like the kids in this article...Just 2+ years apart instead of 5.....


Just wondering why its news worthy I guess Chat Icon Did I miss a key componenet in the article ? I didn't think it was rare at all Chat Icon or is it the 5 year thing? My brain is mush these days so maybe I am missing it

Chat Icon

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/01/04/reuben-and-floren-blake-twins-born-five-years-apart_n_1184084.html?1325708920&ncid=webmail2

Message edited 2012-01-04 18:33:39.733000.

Posted 1/4/12 6:33 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MrsDamonSalv7319
Somewhere in Westeros

Member since 10/10

4495 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I missing something ? Article on IVF ...

I don't get why it's news either...I don't even fully get the twin thing...isn't it a separate sperm and egg even though it was fertilized from that batch? I don't think I'd think of my kids as twins if I was in that situation. To me twins are carried at the same time. (Not trying to be rude or snarky, that's just what I think).

Posted 1/4/12 6:52 PM
 

hope316
LIF Adult

Member since 8/07

1085 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I missing something ? Article on IVF ...

i agree it's not news worthy..... It just an example of the ignorance of fertility treatments

Posted 1/4/12 6:54 PM
 

FlowerWife
Positive Vibrations...

Member since 1/08

8423 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I missing something ? Article on IVF ...

omg i TOTALLY don't get it either!! DD is an IVF baby and we have 8 frosties that we'll most likely need to use one day.. i dont even think i would think of them as "twins." i def dont get it...Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 1/4/12 6:59 PM
 

FlowerWife
Positive Vibrations...

Member since 1/08

8423 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I missing something ? Article on IVF ...

Posted by MrsECullen7319

I don't get why it's news either...I don't even fully get the twin thing...isn't it a separate sperm and egg even though it was fertilized from that batch? I don't think I'd think of my kids as twins if I was in that situation. To me twins are carried at the same time. (Not trying to be rude or snarky, that's just what I think).



fraternal twins are different sperm and eggs too but the eggs ovulated at the same time. in IVF all the eggs are ovulated at the same time so technically i suppose they are twins but i dont really see it that way either. when i use my frosties i wont really consider them twins. but it is great that if im 40 and still want another baby ill still have my 29-year-old eggs!!

Posted 1/4/12 7:01 PM
 

Bops
My 3 wishes

Member since 12/07

13625 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I missing something ? Article on IVF ...

Posted by FlowerWife

Posted by MrsECullen7319

I don't get why it's news either...I don't even fully get the twin thing...isn't it a separate sperm and egg even though it was fertilized from that batch? I don't think I'd think of my kids as twins if I was in that situation. To me twins are carried at the same time. (Not trying to be rude or snarky, that's just what I think).



fraternal twins are different sperm and eggs too but the eggs ovulated at the same time. in IVF all the eggs are ovulated at the same time so technically i suppose they are twins but i dont really see it that way either. when i use my frosties i wont really consider them twins. but it is great that if im 40 and still want another baby ill still have my 29-year-old eggs!!




FlowerWife....do you happen to know if the rare part is the 5 year thing? Although I am pretty sure we are done, now it has me wondering (we are still storing my remaining frosties in case we change our minds Chat Icon )

Posted 1/4/12 7:05 PM
 

FlowerWife
Positive Vibrations...

Member since 1/08

8423 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I missing something ? Article on IVF ...

Posted by Bops

Posted by FlowerWife

Posted by MrsECullen7319

I don't get why it's news either...I don't even fully get the twin thing...isn't it a separate sperm and egg even though it was fertilized from that batch? I don't think I'd think of my kids as twins if I was in that situation. To me twins are carried at the same time. (Not trying to be rude or snarky, that's just what I think).



fraternal twins are different sperm and eggs too but the eggs ovulated at the same time. in IVF all the eggs are ovulated at the same time so technically i suppose they are twins but i dont really see it that way either. when i use my frosties i wont really consider them twins. but it is great that if im 40 and still want another baby ill still have my 29-year-old eggs!!




FlowerWife....do you happen to know if the rare part is the 5 year thing? Although I am pretty sure we are done, now it has me wondering (we are still storing my remaining frosties in case we change our minds Chat Icon )



i have no idea but i dont see 5 years as being that weird at all. ive heard of people using their embies way later than that Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 1/4/12 7:08 PM
 

InShock
life is good

Member since 10/06

9258 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I missing something ? Article on IVF ...

I think this is the stupidest thing ever. Unless the babies inhabited her uterus at the same time, they are not twins. Just plain stupid. Chat Icon

Posted 1/4/12 7:18 PM
 

Athee
I believe in miracles!

Member since 8/07

2462 total posts

Name:
A

Re: Am I missing something ? Article on IVF ...

not news worthy at all....

Posted 1/4/12 7:44 PM
 

Domino
Always My Miracle

Member since 9/05

9924 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I missing something ? Article on IVF ...

I feel like this article would have been a lot more "newsworthy" 20 years ago.

I love this quote:

Doctors at the Bristol Centre for Reproductive Medicine, based at Southmead Hospital, said the decision made by Mr and Mrs Blake to freeze their remaining embryos was a safer way to have twins.


Chat Icon sounds to me like they might have been the ones to stir the article up...

Posted 1/4/12 8:43 PM
 

ItsaJoya19
my cup runneth over

Member since 1/10

2949 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Am I missing something ? Article on IVF ...

Um what? This is the most ridiculous claim I've ever read.

Slow news day huh?

Posted 1/4/12 8:44 PM
 

Jax430
Hi!

Member since 5/05

18919 total posts

Name:
Jackie

Re: Am I missing something ? Article on IVF ...

Crashing here...but W*T*F*??? This is NOT news!

I guess I'll be having "twins" eventually. Chat Icon

Message edited 2012-01-04 21:09:19.003000.

Posted 1/4/12 9:08 PM
 

lucyloo
nope

Member since 1/06

9758 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I missing something ? Article on IVF ...

I never knew that. Chat Icon

Posted 1/4/12 9:17 PM
 

mcl916
my two loves

Member since 10/06

5133 total posts

Name:
Megan

Re: Am I missing something ? Article on IVF ...

Um yeah, then DD and DS are twins too Chat Icon They were born THREE whole years apart. I don't really see this as newsworthy, I think I remember seeing something about a couple getting pregnant with an embryo over 10 years old recently so 5 years is nothing.

Bops, I've heard after 5 years the embryo quality can be affected, but I still think you can have a good chance. We still have 5 on ice and they will be 4 years old on the 9th. If I use them all and get pregnant with them all eventually, will they be considered septuplets? Chat Icon

Message edited 2012-01-04 21:19:39.577000.

Posted 1/4/12 9:18 PM
 

Bops
My 3 wishes

Member since 12/07

13625 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I missing something ? Article on IVF ...

Posted by mcl916

Um yeah, then DD and DS are twins too Chat Icon They were born THREE whole years apart. I don't really see this as newsworthy, I think I remember seeing something about a couple getting pregnant with an embryo over 10 years old recently so 5 years is nothing.

Bops, I've heard after 5 years the embryo quality can be affected, but I still think you can have a good chance. We still have 5 on ice and they will be 4 years old on the 9th. If I use them all and get pregnant with them all eventually, will they be considered septuplets? Chat Icon





Chat Icon Chat Icon


Ok.....thanks all...I was starting to think my reading comprehension skills went down the flusher !

This was on my AOL todays news and I was sitting there reading it waiting for the punchline that never came

Chat Icon

Posted 1/4/12 9:47 PM
 

ny55angel
car seat tech & geek :-)

Member since 2/06

4346 total posts

Name:
P

Re: Am I missing something ? Article on IVF ...

I didn't go through IVF, but regardless, these children are NOT twins. Twins are with each other in utero, and are born within minutes of each other, NOT years !! IMO there is no difference between these two children then between any set of siblings. I get that the eggs were from the same retrevial, and they were fertilized from the same batch of sperm, but that (to me) is where it ends as the "twin" aspect.

And really, this happens all the time when it comes to IVF and FET's doesn't it? Could you imagine saying, this is my sister, she's 5 years younger then me, but we're twins !! I'm sure they will get a lot of Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon and Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 1/4/12 10:19 PM
 

Jax430
Hi!

Member since 5/05

18919 total posts

Name:
Jackie

Re: Am I missing something ? Article on IVF ...

OMG...I'm watching the trainwreck that is Toddlers & Tiaras, and one of the girls' moms said that her daughters were born 8 years apart as the result of IVF and later, FET...and she considers them fraternal twins....her "chosen frozens"! Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

DH and I cracked up b/c I had read him this article earlier.

Posted 1/4/12 11:09 PM
 

menmyboys
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/11

811 total posts

Name:
Nikole

Re: Am I missing something ? Article on IVF ...

Posted by MrsECullen7319

I don't get why it's news either...I don't even fully get the twin thing...isn't it a separate sperm and egg even though it was fertilized from that batch? I don't think I'd think of my kids as twins if I was in that situation. To me twins are carried at the same time. (Not trying to be rude or snarky, that's just what I think).



I agree with this... If we go with the idea of this article, then technically all my kids are "twins/triplets".

Just to make it clear, and, no this isn't meant to be flammatory, I'm carrying twins, and the only reason they're "twins" (to me) is because they're in there at the same time...

Posted 1/5/12 5:54 AM
 

JenMarie
One day at a time

Member since 11/07

7397 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Am I missing something ? Article on IVF ...

I think many people are just uneducated about fertility treatments and someone needed a new story, so they twisted this into something many people will think is unheard of and crazy.

I can't tell you how many times when we were going through IUI treatments that people asked us if we were having a "test tube baby". People just don't know much about fertility treatments unless they go through it or someone close to them does.

Posted 1/5/12 8:23 AM
 

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I missing something ? Article on IVF ...

Posted by JenMarie

I think many people are just uneducated about fertility treatments and someone needed a new story, so they twisted this into something many people will think is unheard of and crazy.

I can't tell you how many times when we were going through IUI treatments that people asked us if we were having a "test tube baby". People just don't know much about fertility treatments unless they go through it or someone close to them does.



yup..agreed

Posted 1/5/12 12:59 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
NYTimes IVF Article snowbunny 2/20/09 3 Infertility
Accupuncture/IVF article julz33 2/17/08 1 Infertility
IVF and acupuncture article ihilani 2/7/08 4 Infertility
Article in Newsday on IVF funding Goldi0218 10/17/07 4 Infertility
Article I found about IVF cycle DRMom 12/11/06 0 Infertility
Interesting article regarding IVF casey31 3/16/06 5 Infertility