Am I being too harsh??? Updated

Posted By Message

JChia
Mom of 2 Princesses

Member since 9/07

2540 total posts

Name:
Jen

Am I being too harsh??? Updated

DD has a habit of hitting me when she doesn't get her way. Lately I've been instituting time outs for this, because, well, I don't like getting hit all the time.

tonight she tried it again and I tried giving her a timeout. She decided she "likes" time outs, so I told her that if she hits me she would not get her bedtime milk. I guess she didn't believe me because she hit me and then I told her no bedtime milk. She cried and kicked and hit me again. So I gave her a chance to apologize and she did and no sooner had I told DH to get her milk than she hit me again.. HARD. So I took it away again, put her in her crib, said goodnight and walked away. She is in a crib tent and all ready for bed and crying her eyes out for the past 1/2 hour. I have no intention of giving her milk, but should I go in and comfort her???

ETA she is almost 2.5

Updated below - thanks everyone!

Message edited 2010-07-26 20:38:03.850000.

Posted 7/26/10 8:18 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

kahlua716
3 Girls for Me!

Member since 8/07

12475 total posts

Name:
Keri

Re: Am I being too harsh??? ASAP PLEASE!

I have no idea...

I would say probably not. I wouldn't comfort her, but maybe go in and try talking to her again- calmly but sternly. I wouldn;t be overly sweet...

I could be giving bad advice though- that's just what I would do.

Good luck Chat Icon

Posted 7/26/10 8:22 PM
 

KennysMommy
Never knew LOVE like it before

Member since 3/10

2640 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: Am I being too harsh??? ASAP PLEASE!

I can only speak from experience as a special ed teacher (spec ed kids and toddlers are a LOT alike) I would def go in and comfort her because it's likely she doesn't remember the hitting.

I would also be very consistent with your discipline, punishments, and methods from now on. Don't change things to make her upset. If a time out is the punishment, keep it. Maybe change location of where she sits. Depriving her of something different each time can be confusing to her. HTH!

Posted 7/26/10 8:22 PM
 

JennyPenny
?

Member since 1/08

12702 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Am I being too harsh??? ASAP PLEASE!

I personally wouldn't go in. She was given fair warning- several times- and kept pushing you. Tomorrow morning you can talk to her about it. Comforting her is giving her more attention- her original want.

Posted 7/26/10 8:25 PM
 

Ang-Rich
Beyond Compare

Member since 5/05

17988 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I being too harsh??? ASAP PLEASE!

I don't know..I can only speak from personal experience and opinion.

If she doesn't stop in 15-20 minutes maybe go in and explain that hands are not for hitting and that she has to go to bed. If she asks for milk explain that you told her to stop hitting and because she did not listen and hit mommy she will not get milk tonight.

If she starts to quite down then I say leave her and let her fall asleep on her own. Tomorrow is a new day.

At 2.5 my son could follow direction and understood that hitting was not acceptable. When he did hit (and believe me he did) there were consequences for his actions. At that age he could tell me he was sorry...even the next day on his own.

Posted 7/26/10 8:28 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Am I being too harsh??? ASAP PLEASE!

Nope, not harsh.

Two nights ago Eddie went to bed without a book or tickles for not listening.

Posted 7/26/10 8:32 PM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: Am I being too harsh??? ASAP PLEASE!

At that age, I don't think that's too harsh

ETA: This post reminds me of how I wish an acquaintance of mine would read parenting forums because she does not discipline her 2.5yr old AT ALL! Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-07-26 20:37:13.617000.

Posted 7/26/10 8:35 PM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Am I being too harsh??? ASAP PLEASE!

I'd probably go in after 15-20 minutes to comfort if she didn't settle down. I wouldn't give her the milk, but a cuddle to calm her and then put her back down.

From experience, I know that my DS will generally calm down in about 15 minutes. If he doesn't stop after 15-20, he is too wound up and too upset to self soothe. I can go in and sit with him for 5 minutes and he will calm down and pass out. For him, I think it's better than letting him cry longer.

Posted 7/26/10 8:36 PM
 

JChia
Mom of 2 Princesses

Member since 9/07

2540 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: Am I being too harsh??? ASAP PLEASE!

Update DH convinced me that we should both go in. We did comfort her and explained sternly not to hit and that its ok to be angry but not ok to hit. Then she did say she was sorry so we read a story and played a quick tickle game and she is sleeping now. But No milk. she didn't even ask for it.

Thanks everyone for the input!!!

Posted 7/26/10 8:37 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Want honesty here - was I too harsh or helpful? Charly 12/24/08 23 Parenting
Ok do you think this is to harsh of a list? vegalady 7/16/08 8 Parenting
Who else will watching Martha Stewart give a harsh yet tasteful smackdown to the next loser? MrsProfessor 9/28/05 2 Families Helping Families ™
leaking foundation...HELP - ASAP chris605 10/12/05 4 Home
NEED AN ANSWER ASAP 04bride 9/13/05 2 Families Helping Families ™