All these drownings

Posted By Message

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

All these drownings

I guess it's that time of year.

I saw a nanny and a young child drowned in a pool last night.

Then there was the 12 year old on a school trip the day before.

As a parent, I would NEVER allow my child to go on a school trip to the beach. I also have spoken to many teachers who say you are out of your mind as a teacher if you take on this responsibility with your class.

DH and I have thrown around the idea of getting a pool, but now that DS is 18 months and so active..........it seems like not a good decision right now.


Thoughts?

Posted 6/24/10 6:35 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

chanmar
LIF Adolescent

Member since 7/07

499 total posts

Name:

Re: All these drownings

It is very sad, but what it boils down to, is lack of supervision, even for a second. As long as you fence your pool in, there is no reason to have an accident. My DS can't get enough of the pool, he is gonna be 4 next month. But he never is in pool without an adult present. Plus the gate gets locked every time we go on that side of our house. Even if it is just a minute to get something..

Posted 6/24/10 6:49 AM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: All these drownings

I will never have a pool, because I am too anxious about my daughter. I know the vast majority of people have them and never have an incident- but the idea just makes me too anxious.

As for the 12 year old who drowned- I am very upset about that, and disgusted that a) a principal would allow the trip and b) that the kids weren't more closely supervised AND allowed to go in the water. I am a teacher and whenever I take a trip I set very clear parameters for what is and what isn't allowed- every time. IMO those teachers were too inexperienced to attempt a trip like that, even though they had the required 1:10 ratio of adults to kids.

My NYC district does not allow swimming because of a drowning about 15 years ago. In fact, I wanted to take my kids on the Circle Line about 10 years ago and the principal said "No, no water trips, period". He didn't want any kind of liability and I couldn't blame him at all.

Posted 6/24/10 7:45 AM
 

kimbalina
Bring on the glitter and bows!

Member since 6/08

15158 total posts

Name:
Kim

Re: All these drownings

I was thinking about this last night when I heard about the Nanny and the child and it was followed up by the child at the beach Chat Icon

It is so sad that the Brother of the little girl who died in the pool is the one who saw them and called for help. I could not imagine that.

As for a trip to the beach or a pool for school, I think with the proper supervision I **might** let my child go. I would want to go with them, I think the idea of them going with just the teacher is not enough.

Posted 6/24/10 7:53 AM
 

IVFGIRL
LIF Infant

Member since 1/09

139 total posts

Name:
Eva

Re: All these drownings

Posted by chanmar

It is very sad, but what it boils down to, is lack of supervision, even for a second. As long as you fence your pool in, there is no reason to have an accident. My DS can't get enough of the pool, he is gonna be 4 next month. But he never is in pool without an adult present. Plus the gate gets locked every time we go on that side of our house. Even if it is just a minute to get something..



I agree, also most of the drownings have been ( exclusive of the young kids) have been of those who went into the water but couldn't swim. I read the one at Long Beach couldn't swim, also the one earlier in the season at JOnes Beach. I have always had a pool and always could swim, I just don't understand not knowing how to swim and still going in the water, I would be petrified.

Posted 6/24/10 7:45 PM
 

Erica
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

11767 total posts

Name:

Re: All these drownings

Posted by mzsocialworker1


As a parent, I would NEVER allow my child to go on a school trip to the beach. I also have spoken to many teachers who say you are out of your mind as a teacher if you take on this responsibility with your class.

Thoughts?



the parents didn't even know. the permission slip did not have the location OR that they would be swimming on it.


I think it was the teacher's first year, she probably didn't have the management skills to keep the kids from running into the water.

Posted 6/24/10 8:30 PM
 

maybesoon
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

5981 total posts

Name:

Re: All these drownings

we do not want a pool, accidents can happen no matter how careful you are. I would'nt buy a home if it had one . my DS is 20 months and as fast as lightening, can't watch him every second

Posted 6/24/10 10:04 PM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: All these drownings

Posted by chanmar

It is very sad, but what it boils down to, is lack of supervision, even for a second. As long as you fence your pool in, there is no reason to have an accident. My DS can't get enough of the pool, he is gonna be 4 next month. But he never is in pool without an adult present. Plus the gate gets locked every time we go on that side of our house. Even if it is just a minute to get something..

the Lawrence child was with her nanny and they both drowned. That is terrifying to me!!!

Posted 6/24/10 10:19 PM
 

Gertyrae
Peace out Homies!

Member since 5/05

20046 total posts

Name:
Gerty ®

Re: All these drownings

Posted by chanmar

It is very sad, but what it boils down to, is lack of supervision, even for a second. As long as you fence your pool in, there is no reason to have an accident. My DS can't get enough of the pool, he is gonna be 4 next month. But he never is in pool without an adult present. Plus the gate gets locked every time we go on that side of our house. Even if it is just a minute to get something..




This is true - but education comes into play also. There are many children who figure out how to open a gate or climb a fence. Children that are around pools MUST be taught how to swim at the earliest possible age and parents and/or nannies should be required to take CPR classes.

Posted 6/25/10 12:54 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: All these drownings

I don't think not getting a pool is the answer. I think teaching your child to swim is the way to go. I also think children WITH pools are much better swimmers than kids that just take lessons because they are in the pool all of the time.

Obviously you go for the double fence - or in my cousin's case they had a ladder that was locked so the kids couldn't get in without an adult.

Posted 6/25/10 6:51 AM
 

chanmar
LIF Adolescent

Member since 7/07

499 total posts

Name:

Re: All these drownings

Posted by Gertyrae

Posted by chanmar

It is very sad, but what it boils down to, is lack of supervision, even for a second. As long as you fence your pool in, there is no reason to have an accident. My DS can't get enough of the pool, he is gonna be 4 next month. But he never is in pool without an adult present. Plus the gate gets locked every time we go on that side of our house. Even if it is just a minute to get something..




This is true - but education comes into play also. There are many children who figure out how to open a gate or climb a fence. Children that are around pools MUST be taught how to swim at the earliest possible age and parents and/or nannies should be required to take CPR classes.



Agreed, It is very important to teach your kids how to swim as soon as you can. I Agree also everyone should know Child CPR, and adult CPR. It is a personal opinion to have a pool or not. I don't believe i would not get or keep a pool in fear of someone drowning, but if somoene does not feel comfortable then by all means, it would not be fun to live in fear of a possibility of someone drowning in your pool..

Posted 6/25/10 6:55 AM
 

Nifheim
allo

Member since 1/09

5476 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: All these drownings

i was a child who's parents had a pool with no fence and one day while my mom was on the phone inside i decided to pull my bike up to the pool and LUCKILY got into a float and was floating around the pool (i think i was 3) but i could swim but for short periods of time. After that the pool fence went up.

If you live on a island
A. have swimming lessons
B. Gate your pools
C. educate yourself on pool safety and beach safety

As far as accidents, they happen. The nanny most likely slip and fell into the pool with the child and from what I heard at the beach there were no lifeguards on duty. I would have no objections to sending a tween/teen to the beach if he/she knew how to swim and there were lifeguards on duty and enough supervision.

Posted 6/25/10 9:03 AM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: All these drownings

Posted by Erica


the parents didn't even know. the permission slip did not have the location OR that they would be swimming on it.


I think it was the teacher's first year, she probably didn't have the management skills to keep the kids from running into the water.



I read that a verbal permission was given over the phone- which doesn't usually give a lot of info. I HATE doing verbal permission, and actually stopped doing it. I also read today that the teachers ok'd the kids going in the water. Chat Icon Chat Icon

In a million years I would never take my students on a water trip. Those teachers were not thinking AT ALL.

Posted 6/25/10 9:03 AM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: All these drownings

I also had a pool growing up but we always had a gate around it.


My parents are actually planning to get locks now and an alarm because there have been issues with tweens going into random people's backyards by them in the middle of the night to go swimming.

Not that either of these things could really stop them. They could still jump the fence and if you can't swim----well-----that's that.

Posted 6/25/10 9:12 AM
 

Pumpkin
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

3353 total posts

Name:

Re: All these drownings

We have an inground pool. At first I was against it. But my BDH really wanted it. I have a fence around the pool, my property and the house and fence are alarmed and locked.

When we have children I plan on having the start swinng lessons as soon as the dr says okay.

Posted 6/25/10 12:50 PM
 

Boobobunny
Live in the Present

Member since 5/05

3572 total posts

Name:
Dannielle

Re: All these drownings

drowning is a very real fear for my family. My sister had the back door locked in 2 places and the ladder to the pool on the other side of the yard...and my poor nephew still found his way in. she left him watching his favorite show to answer the front door for a delivery...and he got both locks undone and pulled a chair up to the pool. my sister was only away from him 2 or 3 minutes.

so please don't fool your selves that a gate will be enough. no matter how much supervision your children have, it only takes a minute. and you need to be honest with yourself, you can't be with them all of the time. you will go to the bathroom, or fold the laundry or run out to get the mail.

we should all be teaching our children to swim...with their clothes and shoes on...and teach them how to get out of the pool.

my nephew did know how to swim, but the medical examiner determined that he hit his head on the pool filter and that is most likely why he drowned.

I feel for the families that are dealing with these most recent loses...because I know that the pain never ever goes away. its always there and time does NOT make it better

Posted 6/25/10 9:19 PM