A few questions about Catholic "rules"

Posted By Message

scarletbegonia
Mr. Handsome

Member since 5/06

13481 total posts

Name:
V

A few questions about Catholic "rules"

We will be baptizing James at the end of May.

I was born and raised Catholic, DH was born and riased Methodist - or so we thought....Chat Icon

My brother and his sister are going to be the godparents. With my brother, there is no issue since he is Catholic through and through. The woman in the parish office said that he needed his baptismal certificae and a letter from his home parish stating that he is in good standing with the church. Fine. No problem there at all. She also asked if he was confirmed in the Catholic faith (he was) and this is where it gets tricky....

Apparently, my DH and SIL were baptized Catholic, but raised Methodist. (they are soooooooo not-practicing and DH essentially wants nothing to do with religion in any form - he's just going along with my wishes to baptize James). Don't ask me why this happened or why DH didn't kow he was baptized Catholic, my IL's are strange strange strange people.

Apparently, my MIL has SIL's bpatismal certificate through the Catholic church. Is it going to be a problem that she wan't confirmed in the Catholic faith? I'm only wondering this because the woman made it a specific point to ask if my brother was confirmed.

Are we gonig to run into problems because of this? I'm afraid to call my parish and ask because I don't want to raise any flags (and besides, they scare the crap out of me Chat Icon Chat Icon )

Posted 2/25/10 9:04 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

bpmom
Feeling Blessed

Member since 6/07

2963 total posts

Name:

Re: A few questions about Catholic "rules"

I don't know the 'official' answer, but I was raised Methodist and DH was raised Catholic. We're raising DCs as Catholic.

You need to have at least one currently practicing, confirmed Catholic be a Godparent. The other, non-Catholic person you choose can only be termed, 'Christian witness'.

They both still participate in the ceremony and will be part of the child's life, but the church won't recognize the non-Catholic people as true 'God'parents.

HTH.

Posted 2/25/10 9:08 AM
 

oneday
<3

Member since 5/05

4319 total posts

Name:
Pam

Re: A few questions about Catholic "rules"

I think it may depend on the particular parish, but I am my nephew's (my brother's son) godmother. I am not Catholic - or religious of any sort. My godson's godfather is Catholic (a Franciscan monk actually - I figure that makes up for me Chat Icon ) and there seemed to be no issue. My brother wanted to have me and my husband, but one of godparent had to be a practicing Catholic.

Posted 2/25/10 9:10 AM
 

scarletbegonia
Mr. Handsome

Member since 5/06

13481 total posts

Name:
V

Re: A few questions about Catholic "rules"

Thank you - we know about the witness part, I was just wondering if it was going to be a problem since she was actually baptized Catholic, but raised in a different religion. Maybe I'm not explaining it right? Chat Icon

Posted 2/25/10 9:11 AM
 

JennZ
MY LIFE!!

Member since 8/05

25463 total posts

Name:

Re: A few questions about Catholic "rules"

I am The LEAST religious person in the world. I am also Godmother to my little cousin and they did hers in St Lawrence in Sayville. No one asked me if I was even Catholic. And St Lawrence is pretty particular. I think you should be fine. I had no communion, and was NOT confirmed.

Posted 2/25/10 9:12 AM
 

bpmom
Feeling Blessed

Member since 6/07

2963 total posts

Name:

Re: A few questions about Catholic "rules"

Posted by scarletbegonia

Thank you - we know about the witness part, I was just wondering if it was going to be a problem since she was actually baptized Catholic, but raised in a different religion. Maybe I'm not explaining it right? Chat Icon



No, I think it's fine. I really think as long as they believe in Jesus you're going to be fine. For ex, my best friend can't be either a Godparent or Christian witness now that she's converted to Judaism. Chat Icon

Posted 2/25/10 9:14 AM
 

kerrycec03
Mom of 2 beautiful boys!!

Member since 6/06

13519 total posts

Name:
Kerry

Re: A few questions about Catholic "rules"

our parish, only one of the godparents had to be confirmed Catholic, the other just had to be Christian of some sort. You should be ok.

Posted 2/25/10 9:16 AM
 

lucyloo
nope

Member since 1/06

9758 total posts

Name:

Re: A few questions about Catholic "rules"

Message edited 2012-01-17 10:50:40.443000.

Posted 2/25/10 9:24 AM
 

ReiRei13
Life is Good!!

Member since 1/08

6460 total posts

Name:

Re: A few questions about Catholic "rules"

My DH originally wanted his brother to be the Godfather but since he wasn't confirmed in the Catholic church we got to have mhy brother (which is of course what I wanted)Chat Icon

Posted 2/25/10 9:32 AM
 

Peainapod
Peanuts are here!

Member since 1/09

13591 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: A few questions about Catholic "rules"

i think these things are different with every diocese.

we are both catholic, raised, confirmed married in a catholic church. my brother is as well and so is DH's sister. I still had to provide letters from both god parents parish that they were registered and practicing. So a few months before, both my brother and sister in law had to register at their respective churches, donate $$ via the tithing envelopes, then get their letters. a bunch of crap if you ask me.

some churches allow just one god parent to be fully catholic; some dont care;

Posted 2/25/10 9:34 AM
 

scarletbegonia
Mr. Handsome

Member since 5/06

13481 total posts

Name:
V

Re: A few questions about Catholic "rules"

Posted by MrsP747

My DH originally wanted his brother to be the Godfather but since he wasn't confirmed in the Catholic church we got to have mhy brother (which is of course what I wanted)Chat Icon




This is what I'm wondering - she was BAPTIZED Catholic, but not CONFIRMED Catholic.

Being that she WAS baptized Catholic, but confirmed as a Methodist.

I'm assuming she'll jus thave to be a witness.

Oy, the church and their rules. Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/25/10 9:36 AM
 

LulaBell
:)

Member since 1/06

3508 total posts

Name:
J

Re: A few questions about Catholic "rules"

Posted by kerrycec03

our parish, only one of the godparents had to be confirmed Catholic, the other just had to be Christian of some sort. You should be ok.



Same for us - and to be honest they barely even checked on that. This was Holy Name of Mary in Valley Stream.

Posted 2/25/10 9:36 AM
 

Sassyz75
Turning a new page

Member since 5/05

9731 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: A few questions about Catholic "rules"

I think as long as SIL says she is methodist and has been baptized she should be OK- however, if she says she is Catholic, then yes, she will have a problem that she isn't confirmed.

Posted 2/25/10 10:01 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Catholic Baptism Questions maria430 4/14/09 30 Parenting
More Catholic School Questions..... Gail80 8/21/08 3 Teachers