| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
|
Message edited 2010-05-18 08:18:47.533000. |
|
Posted 5/17/10 7:56 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: My turn for a "Would you be annoyed?" Post I run a tight ship with Alex too, and I've run across a few comments, or looks, from people who think that I may be overdisciplining, and YES, it annoys the ever-living-crap out of me |
|
Posted 5/17/10 7:59 AM
|
|
|
Re: My turn for a "Would you be annoyed?" Post Posted by Bxgell2 I run a tight ship with Alex too, and I've run across a few comments, or looks, from people who think that I may be overdisciplining, and YES, it annoys the ever-living-crap out of me But do you get annoyed when they interact with your DC's in the opposite way without you knowing? Not in defiance? Just because that's what they do with their kids? |
|
Posted 5/17/10 8:31 AM
|
|
|
Re: My turn for a "Would you be annoyed?" Post Posted by lipglossjunky73 Now, I'm a pretty easy going person, but do you think it's weird that she was rough housing with someone else's kid when the parent wasn't there? Im sure they were just "pretend fighting" because that's what Cailen loves to do, but as a mom, wouldn't she think he was there for the class and not to play with her? I dunno - I guess it was also her tone as I reprimanded him.... I just thought it was weird and annoying..... If you had been in the class with him, then I would have thought it was weird but since you weren't, I just think she was playing with him and probably playing with him in a way that he was probably leading. If he play fights on a regular basis, then rough housing is kind of the norm in some ways. As far as being in the class, he may not have been participating since he was kind of young for the class and he may have been engaging her. Was she the only other person in the room not participating in class? If so, that may be why Cailen gravitated towards her; because she could play what he wanted to play. |
|
Posted 5/17/10 8:38 AM
|
|
|
Re: My turn for a "Would you be annoyed?" Post Posted by lipglossjunky73 (Diane was there and said hello to me - great seeing you Diane!) . I think you mean Diana(1215) To answer your question, I don't ream my child in public. It isn't fair to him and in this situation, it would have made the other Mother feel awkward as well. |
|
Posted 5/17/10 8:41 AM
|
|
|
Re: My turn for a "Would you be annoyed?" Post I would think it's weird another women who isn't a teacher in the class is playing rough and joking with my son if she never met me. I have no problem with DS going and playing around, but I wouldn't get too involved with another kid if their parents aren't around b/c I wouldn't want someone doing that to my son. |
|
Posted 5/17/10 8:47 AM
|
|
|
Re: My turn for a "Would you be annoyed?" Post Posted by EricaAlt I would think it's weird another women who isn't a teacher in the class is playing rough and joking with my son if she never met me. I have no problem with DS going and playing around, but I wouldn't get too involved with another kid if their parents aren't around b/c I wouldn't want someone doing that to my son. Also, she has no right how to tell you how to discipline your child. That would bother me Maybe I read it differently, but I didn't how the woman told her how to discipline Cailen? I read it that she told Liza that Cailen was being good and she was playing with him, as in, trying to explain why he did what he did |
|
Posted 5/17/10 8:48 AM
|
|
|
Re: My turn for a "Would you be annoyed?" Post I would probably be taken back by her rough housing with my son, even if I was there. I'm not a fan of "pretend fighting" in general though. |
|
Posted 5/17/10 9:07 AM
|
|
|
Re: My turn for a "Would you be annoyed?" Post Posted by KateDevine Posted by EricaAlt I would think it's weird another women who isn't a teacher in the class is playing rough and joking with my son if she never met me. I have no problem with DS going and playing around, but I wouldn't get too involved with another kid if their parents aren't around b/c I wouldn't want someone doing that to my son. Also, she has no right how to tell you how to discipline your child. That would bother me Maybe I read it differently, but I didn't how the woman told her how to discipline Cailen? I read it that she told Liza that Cailen was being good and she was playing with him, as in, trying to explain why he did what he did I skimmed quick, but just responding to the fact that she was looked at like a bad mom. This is what happens when I'm on LIF at work. Don't fully read the long posts. LOL! I guess I can see both point of views. Mason is also 11 months old so I'm not really there yet and I do realize at daycare other moms play with him and I don't care too much. |
|
Posted 5/17/10 9:09 AM
|
|
|
Re: My turn for a "Would you be annoyed?" Post Posted by EricaAlt Posted by KateDevine Posted by EricaAlt I would think it's weird another women who isn't a teacher in the class is playing rough and joking with my son if she never met me. I have no problem with DS going and playing around, but I wouldn't get too involved with another kid if their parents aren't around b/c I wouldn't want someone doing that to my son. Also, she has no right how to tell you how to discipline your child. That would bother me Maybe I read it differently, but I didn't how the woman told her how to discipline Cailen? I read it that she told Liza that Cailen was being good and she was playing with him, as in, trying to explain why he did what he did I skimmed quick, but just responding to the fact that she was looked at like a bad mom. This is what happens when I'm on LIF at work. Don't fully read the long posts. LOL! I guess I can see both point of views. Mason is also 11 months old so I'm not really there yet and I do realize at daycare other moms play with him and I don't care too much. I do that and I'm not at work, that's why I responded to make sure I read it correctly
|
|
Posted 5/17/10 9:10 AM
|
|
|
Re: My turn for a "Would you be annoyed?" Post Posted by lipglossjunky73 But do you get annoyed when they interact with your DC's in the opposite way without you knowing? Not in defiance? Just because that's what they do with their kids? Obviously you feel the way you feel and can't help that.... But I can't understand being annoyed that she interacted with him in the opposite way you do since she has no idea how you interact with him. If he was leading with "aggressive behavior" she likely thought he rough houses at home and went along with it. She was likely making an excuse for his behavior because she realized her misstep in allowing him to rough house and felt badly for it. I'll be honest though- I don't discipline harshly in public. I am firm so Mads knows I mean business, but I don't want to make others uncomfortable. That's just me though. But I can identify why the other mother might have felt taken aback as it would have made me uncomfortable for another mother to reprimand her child to the point of crying over something *I* might have done- KWIM? ETA: considering he was a full year younger than the required age, I'm sure she might have been helping the instructor out by keeping him occupied- which is why she was interacting with him in the first place. Message edited 2010-05-17 09:14:29.660000. |
|
Posted 5/17/10 9:11 AM
|
|
|
Re: My turn for a "Would you be annoyed?" Post I think the mother may have said what she did because she felt awkward after you disciplined your DS in front of her. I know I do when it's done in front of me, especially when they are getting in trouble for either doing something wrong to my kids or me (unintentional) Message edited 2010-05-17 09:27:17.113000. |
|
Posted 5/17/10 9:22 AM
|
|
|
Re: My turn for a "Would you be annoyed?" Post Posted by Porrruss Posted by lipglossjunky73 But do you get annoyed when they interact with your DC's in the opposite way without you knowing? Not in defiance? Just because that's what they do with their kids? Obviously you feel the way you feel and can't help that.... But I can't understand being annoyed that she interacted with him in the opposite way you do since she has no idea how you interact with him. If he was leading with "aggressive behavior" she likely thought he rough houses at home and went along with it. She was likely making an excuse for his behavior because she realized her misstep in allowing him to rough house and felt badly for it. I'll be honest though- I don't discipline harshly in public. I am firm so Mads knows I mean business, but I don't want to make others uncomfortable. That's just me though. But I can identify why the other mother might have felt taken aback as it would have made me uncomfortable for another mother to reprimand her child to the point of crying over something *I* might have done- KWIM? ETA: considering he was a full year younger than the required age, I'm sure she might have been helping the instructor out by keeping him occupied- which is why she was interacting with him in the first place. ITA with all of these points. |
|
Posted 5/17/10 9:30 AM
|
|
|
Re: My turn for a "Would you be annoyed?" Post Posted by KateDevine Posted by lipglossjunky73 (Diane was there and said hello to me - great seeing you Diane!) . I think you mean Diana(1215) To answer your question, I don't ream my child in public. It isn't fair to him and in this situation, it would have made the other Mother feel awkward as well. Yes - I meant Diana - I made a typo sorry. Not sure how you answered my question, but it sounded a bit judgmental to me. Just an observation - nothing that I'll lose sleep over. I do "ream" my child in public if I feel it is necessary. I have a child in daycare who sees all types of behavior during the day and it is a goal of mine to raise a well-behaved, polite child. I can not address a behavior later because it would not make any sense. When I ream I mean reprimand firmly. I know my child knows better when he gets a reaming. I don't reprimand things he doesn't understand. Cailen is bright as a whip and always pushing the envelope. I take him to restaurants, and he sits the entire time quietly. I just came home from a shiva where he sat quietly while all the adults prayed in the living room. When I say we run a tight ship, this is what is involved. Everywhere we go we are told we have the best behaved child. And DH and I always give each other a wink. We aren't "lucky" to have a good kid. If anything, he is lucky we are on him and consistent as parents. And if the parent is rough housing my son, then she should feel awkward if a parent does not want her child to be handled in that way. |
|
Posted 5/17/10 10:34 PM
|
|
|
Re: My turn for a "Would you be annoyed?" Post Posted by Porrruss Posted by lipglossjunky73 But do you get annoyed when they interact with your DC's in the opposite way without you knowing? Not in defiance? Just because that's what they do with their kids? Obviously you feel the way you feel and can't help that.... But I can't understand being annoyed that she interacted with him in the opposite way you do since she has no idea how you interact with him. If he was leading with "aggressive behavior" she likely thought he rough houses at home and went along with it. She was likely making an excuse for his behavior because she realized her misstep in allowing him to rough house and felt badly for it. I'll be honest though- I don't discipline harshly in public. I am firm so Mads knows I mean business, but I don't want to make others uncomfortable. That's just me though. But I can identify why the other mother might have felt taken aback as it would have made me uncomfortable for another mother to reprimand her child to the point of crying over something *I* might have done- KWIM? ETA: considering he was a full year younger than the required age, I'm sure she might have been helping the instructor out by keeping him occupied- which is why she was interacting with him in the first place. she wasn't helping - she was sitting there. I don;t mind people playing with Cai - the kid is a charmer like you wouldn't believe, but allowing him to hit her with objects is a bit much, IMO But oh well - that's life. And LIF I knew what I was getting myself into by starting a "would you be annoyed" thread All that matters, really, is that mama got one HELL of a workout
|
|
Posted 5/17/10 10:38 PM
|
|
|
Re: My turn for a "Would you be annoyed?" Post It sounds to me like this woman and your DS were playing together, and just as any child would, he misjudged the line between playing and potentially hurting. I totally get that you would want to address that behavior right then and there, but I don't think I'd be annoyed with the woman in this situation. As a pp said, she was probably a tad embarrassed that she "caused" your DS to get yelled at, and just wanted to make sure you knew that he really was behaving just fine beforehand. |
|
Posted 5/17/10 10:52 PM
|
|
|
Re: My turn for a "Would you be annoyed?" Post Posted by InShock It sounds to me like this woman and your DS were playing together, and just as any child would, he misjudged the line between playing and potentially hurting. I totally get that you would want to address that behavior right then and there, but I don't think I'd be annoyed with the woman in this situation. As a pp said, she was probably a tad embarrassed that she "caused" your DS to get yelled at, and just wanted to make sure you knew that he really was behaving just fine beforehand. That makes sense. I get it. I'd tell her next time, but I don't think I'm sending him back to that class until he is 4... if ever. Not sure if Zumba will ever be his thing!
|
|
Posted 5/17/10 11:00 PM
|
|
|
Re: My turn for a "Would you be annoyed?" Post I wouldn't be annoyed, I agree that the woman was probably uncomfortable with being witness to and the cause of his punishment; she may have even exaggerated her role to take the focus off of your DS. I have done this with my siblings if I was involved in something that caused my niece/nephew to be spoken to. |
|
Posted 5/17/10 11:05 PM
|
|
|
Re: My turn for a "Would you be annoyed?" Post your DS sounds extremely well behaved, so noone should have anything to say to you! that being said, I personally do not like when people roughhouse with DS bc I don't want him learning that behavior and thinking it is ok. my father does it with him and it pizzes me off, a stranger would really aggravate me |
|
Posted 5/17/10 11:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: My turn for a "Would you be annoyed?" Post Please don't take this the wrong way....but do you think he might be getting mixed messages when he gets to watch movies like Iron Man and Transformers.....but then isn't allowed to rough house? |
|
Posted 5/17/10 11:21 PM
|
|
|
Re: My turn for a "Would you be annoyed?" Post Posted by Palebride Please don't take this the wrong way....but do you think he might be getting mixed messages when he gets to watch movies like Iron Man and Transformers.....but then isn't allowed to rough house? I talk with DH about this. Cailen really does see the difference. He is allowed to play these games and rough house with DH, and with me to some extent, but there are penalty moves Since we can have control over these penalty moves, he knows he can only rough house with us.I know he plays super heroes at daycare because he has transformed the whole class towards his passion, and it is monitored closely - they are not allowed to rough house at daycare. So they all come up with elaborate play scenes instead involving the super heroes. His creativity is amazing. He comes up with elaborate stories involving the characters with no actual aggression, and of course his super hero figures can hurt each other as much as they would like. If he was getting confused the movies would end. But really, Cailen is such a bright kid who always knows what the rules are - he just needs reminders on when we really are expecting him to follow them He is the most gentle soul. He loves to pretend to be the Hulk, Spider man, etc (he actually lost his interest in Transformers...) and give me kisses as them. OR much to dHs chagrin, makes the characters kiss each other. Ummm - don't ask don't tell? If I had a girl, I would be asking the same question. When I was pregnant (and thinking I was having a girl) I told DH if we had a boy he is never watching that stuff until he is 10. Well, I was off by about 8 years! But that's what makes my Cailen part of the kooky, amazing little guy that he is - right?
|
|
Posted 5/17/10 11:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: My turn for a "Would you be annoyed?" Post Posted by lipglossjunky73 Posted by KateDevine Posted by lipglossjunky73 (Diane was there and said hello to me - great seeing you Diane!) . I think you mean Diana(1215) To answer your question, I don't ream my child in public. It isn't fair to him and in this situation, it would have made the other Mother feel awkward as well. Yes - I meant Diana - I made a typo sorry. Not sure how you answered my question, but it sounded a bit judgmental to me. Just an observation - nothing that I'll lose sleep over. I do "ream" my child in public if I feel it is necessary. I have a child in daycare who sees all types of behavior during the day and it is a goal of mine to raise a well-behaved, polite child. I can not address a behavior later because it would not make any sense. When I ream I mean reprimand firmly. I know my child knows better when he gets a reaming. I don't reprimand things he doesn't understand. Cailen is bright as a whip and always pushing the envelope. I take him to restaurants, and he sits the entire time quietly. I just came home from a shiva where he sat quietly while all the adults prayed in the living room. When I say we run a tight ship, this is what is involved. Everywhere we go we are told we have the best behaved child. And DH and I always give each other a wink. We aren't "lucky" to have a good kid. If anything, he is lucky we are on him and consistent as parents. And if the parent is rough housing my son, then she should feel awkward if a parent does not want her child to be handled in that way. I wasn't being judgmental at all. I was telling you that I do not ream my child in public unless he was in danger. And my child behaves just as well as yours does. He has gone to funerals too, weddings, everything. I don't think that has ANYTHING to do with discipline. And I'm not "lucky" to have a good kid either. Liza, this is NOT a flame, but you left him alone in a class, someone was playing with him, you can't get mad at her for playing with him, it isn't fair to her! |
|
Posted 5/18/10 8:12 AM
|
|
|
Re: My turn for a "Would you be annoyed?" Post No flames at all.... I actually realized I was only mildly annoyed at the whole thing after talking about it |
|
Posted 5/18/10 8:18 AM
|
|
|
Re: Posted by lipglossjunky73 Posted by KateDevine Posted by lipglossjunky73 (Diane was there and said hello to me - great seeing you Diane!) . I think you mean Diana(1215) To answer your question, I don't ream my child in public. It isn't fair to him and in this situation, it would have made the other Mother feel awkward as well. Yes - I meant Diana - I made a typo sorry. Not sure how you answered my question, but it sounded a bit judgmental to me. Just an observation - nothing that I'll lose sleep over. I do "ream" my child in public if I feel it is necessary. I have a child in daycare who sees all types of behavior during the day and it is a goal of mine to raise a well-behaved, polite child. I can not address a behavior later because it would not make any sense. When I ream I mean reprimand firmly. I know my child knows better when he gets a reaming. I don't reprimand things he doesn't understand. Cailen is bright as a whip and always pushing the envelope. I take him to restaurants, and he sits the entire time quietly. I just came home from a shiva where he sat quietly while all the adults prayed in the living room. When I say we run a tight ship, this is what is involved. Everywhere we go we are told we have the best behaved child. And DH and I always give each other a wink. We aren't "lucky" to have a good kid. If anything, he is lucky we are on him and consistent as parents. And if the parent is rough housing my son, then she should feel awkward if a parent does not want her child to be handled in that way. I wouldn't rough house with someone else's kid, but I also wouldn't leave my kid unsupervised in a class for which he's too young and then get annoyed at a parent (who was there watching her own kids) for trying to help keep him entertained. So no, I wouldn't be annoyed. I also wouldn't be so quick to pat yourself on the back about how well behaved your kid is. He is 3-there is still a long way to go. My 2.5 year old is well behaved for her age too, but I recognize that it takes a lot of work and agility-what works now may not work when she is 4 or 5. I also recognize that there is more than one way to raise a good kid and I hope I don't always have to resort to being a tough guy to do it. Sometimes positive reinforcement works too. Here is where I get really judgmental (apologies in advance): Are you concerned at all about being overly critical of him? Do you ever think about the "praise in public, criticize in private" theory? Maybe it's just because of what you choose to post but when I read your posts I sometimes wonder if you are too tough on him. I'm tough on Claire when needed, but balance it out with lots of hugs and praise when warranted (I'm not interested in over-inflating her ego with false praise). Not saying to wait to deal with it him, but take him off to the side, where it is just the 2 of you and talk to him quietly about what just happened. |
|
Posted 5/18/10 12:30 PM
|
|
|
Re: Posted by CrankyPants Posted by lipglossjunky73 Posted by KateDevine Posted by lipglossjunky73 (Diane was there and said hello to me - great seeing you Diane!) . I think you mean Diana(1215) To answer your question, I don't ream my child in public. It isn't fair to him and in this situation, it would have made the other Mother feel awkward as well. Yes - I meant Diana - I made a typo sorry. Not sure how you answered my question, but it sounded a bit judgmental to me. Just an observation - nothing that I'll lose sleep over. I do "ream" my child in public if I feel it is necessary. I have a child in daycare who sees all types of behavior during the day and it is a goal of mine to raise a well-behaved, polite child. I can not address a behavior later because it would not make any sense. When I ream I mean reprimand firmly. I know my child knows better when he gets a reaming. I don't reprimand things he doesn't understand. Cailen is bright as a whip and always pushing the envelope. I take him to restaurants, and he sits the entire time quietly. I just came home from a shiva where he sat quietly while all the adults prayed in the living room. When I say we run a tight ship, this is what is involved. Everywhere we go we are told we have the best behaved child. And DH and I always give each other a wink. We aren't "lucky" to have a good kid. If anything, he is lucky we are on him and consistent as parents. And if the parent is rough housing my son, then she should feel awkward if a parent does not want her child to be handled in that way. I wouldn't rough house with someone else's kid, but I also wouldn't leave my kid unsupervised in a class for which he's too young and then get annoyed at a parent (who was there watching her own kids) for trying to help keep him entertained. So no, I wouldn't be annoyed. I also wouldn't be so quick to pat yourself on the back about how well behaved your kid is. He is 3-there is still a long way to go. My 2.5 year old is well behaved for her age too, but I recognize that it takes a lot of work and agility-what works now may not work when she is 4 or 5. I also recognize that there is more than one way to raise a good kid and I hope I don't always have to resort to being a tough guy to do it. Sometimes positive reinforcement works too. Here is where I get really judgmental (apologies in advance): Are you concerned at all about being overly critical of him? Do you ever think about the "praise in public, criticize in private" theory? Maybe it's just because of what you choose to post but when I read your posts I sometimes wonder if you are too tough on him. I'm tough on Claire when needed, but balance it out with lots of hugs and praise when warranted (I'm not interested in over-inflating her ego with false praise). Not saying to wait to deal with it him, but take him off to the side, where it is just the 2 of you and talk to him quietly about what just happened. Daaaanngggg - someone's pants are ESPECIALLY Cranky tonight! You make it sound like I was abandoning my kid - LOL - Zumba does crazy things to me! I think if you scroll up a tad I mentioned I was over it. Hence the reason I erased it. But I guess you weren't done with me yet!! I commend you for being aware that parenting is a fluid thing that changes all the time. DH and I are raising 3 kids - all different ages and personalities. It is quite a balance of dynamics - and it has been a challenge but we have done a good job with a teen, a pre-teen, and a toddler. We aren't back patters by any stretch of the imagination, but at the end of the day, we can say we are doing a pretty good job. As for critical.... telling my son "we don't hit" is not critical in my opinion but I guess it's always open to other's perceptions. I have such a happy, well-adjusted little boy. If you take one look at him (and us together) you can see how much fun we have together and how there is never "criticism". I guess you are one of the people who open up my hundreds of "I love my DS" threads or picture threads but never reply. I never see you ever post one thing o those - but these types of threads you are ALLLL over... So: I appreciate your concern for my son's well being - as your post seems so very caring. But tell me once in a while how dang cute he is to even it out a bit.Anyone who knows me and my parenting style knows what type of parent I am. I am firm but gentle. I don't yell and never act on anger. I never am critical of my child. As for positive reinforcement - I am a behaviorist, and I will give you a shiny new quarter if you can give me the TRUE definition of positive reinforcement. I think because you only read my posts, and don't know me, and tend to respond in similar ways to other people's posts, I will chalk this up to a personality thing. But I did not ask for your assessment on my parenting style - especially since you wouldn't know me if you tripped over me. I am a bit concerned, however, on how critical you are at times on here. Are you concerned at all about being overly critical of strangers who post online? Do you ever think about the "praise in public, criticize in private" theory? Maybe it's just because of what you choose to post but when I read your posts I sometimes wonder if you are too tough on people you don;t know from a hole in the wall. Soooo... Good job with your work with Claire. You sound very proud of your parenting, as you should be. As I am proud of my parenting of Cailen. When I need your advice, I will be sure to FM you in the future. Until then, I will continue to be the rocking mom that everyone who knows me, knows I am
|
|
Posted 5/18/10 8:05 PM
|
|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| My turn to post a belly pic! | JoJo2010 | 10/7/09 | 25 | Pregnancy |
| Spinoff to Babyonthebrain's post......It's my turn TOO!!! | juju | 1/11/09 | 29 | Pregnancy |
| my turn to post my deals of the day | SweetestOfPeas | 2/1/07 | 2 | Fashion & Beauty! |
| My turn for a bad mommy post... | Melbernai | 9/28/06 | 16 | Parenting |
| Alright my turn for a shameless post. | MrsMaz | 8/10/06 | 34 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Annoyed!!!! x-post from LIW | Blu-ize | 4/20/06 | 20 | Families Helping Families ™ |







Don't fully read the long posts. LOL! I guess I can see both point of views. Mason is also 11 months old so I'm not really there yet and I do realize at daycare other moms play with him and I don't care too much.




