School supplies - do you buy exactly what is asked for?
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
|
Re: School supplies - do you buy exactly what is asked for? Posted by ali120206 Posted by LSP2005 Posted by cj7305 Yes. As a teacher I know that we usually ask for specific things for various reasons. Usually color coding for subjects, etc. or if we ask for certain brands, it’s usually because from experience, they work much better than others. For example Elmers works so much better than rose art or staples brand. Even pencils. The Ticonderoga sharpen so much better than any others lol. We have learned a lot over the years about supplies ??. I agree, crayola crayons are vastly superior to rose art. When my kids were in elementary school the teacher told me she would just throw out the rose art crayons before they made it into the share bin if there was only one kid who brought the brand in. Last year we ordered the box from the school and it had crappy glue sticks and pencils... I refuse to order the box now as DS threw out the pencils and glue since they didn't work. Ticonderoga, Elmers and Crayola are definitely worth the extra $$. That’s stinks! Ours had all crayola, elmers and Ticonderoga. I think that’s why I’m okay with buying it lol I refuse to pay for dollar store or store brand supplies |
|
Posted 9/8/21 5:20 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
School supplies - do you buy exactly what is asked for? My goodness - just spent $125 on DS kindergarten supplies (from the amazon wishlist) and I didn't even get all of them. Message edited 2021-09-09 00:53:25.647000. |
|
Posted 9/9/21 12:39 AM
|
|
|
Re: School supplies - do you buy exactly what is asked for? Posted by newlywedT My goodness - just spent $125 on DS kindergarten supplies (from the amazon wishlist) and I didn't even get all of them. Now I'm looking at the DD's second grade amazon list and its wacky. For example - 6 pack of special plastic folders is $16 plus $10 shipping (its third party, not sold by amazon) Pencil case - $13 bucks wtf Seems very overpriced. I just go to Target. The plastic folders and pencil boxes are super cheap there. My 2nd grader needed a ton of supplies (Crayons, pencils, pencil case, wipes, ziplock bags, folders, scissors, tissues, binder, Dry erase markers, sharpie marker, etc) and I don’t think I even spent $30. |
|
Posted 9/9/21 4:23 AM
|
|
|
Re: School supplies - do you buy exactly what is asked for? Posted by PitterPatter11 Posted by newlywedT My goodness - just spent $125 on DS kindergarten supplies (from the amazon wishlist) and I didn't even get all of them. Now I'm looking at the DD's second grade amazon list and its wacky. For example - 6 pack of special plastic folders is $16 plus $10 shipping (its third party, not sold by amazon) Pencil case - $13 bucks wtf Seems very overpriced. I just go to Target. The plastic folders and pencil boxes are super cheap there. My 2nd grader needed a ton of supplies (Crayons, pencils, pencil case, wipes, ziplock bags, folders, scissors, tissues, binder, Dry erase markers, sharpie marker, etc) and I don’t think I even spent $30. Yes - I got plastic folders for $0.50 at Target. Sometimes Amazon is ridiculously overpriced for items and you can do better elsewhere. Since it's being shipped to your house - you are better off ordering from elsewhere. I reused a lot of things since they came back in perfect shape (and I had duplicates from last year's hybrid learning) and I definitely spent less than $50 for two kids, including a $10 calculator. |
|
Posted 9/9/21 8:15 AM
|
|
|
NervousNell
Member since 11/09 54921 total posts Name: |
Re: School supplies - do you buy exactly what is asked for? Posted by LSP2005 Posted by cj7305 Yes. As a teacher I know that we usually ask for specific things for various reasons. Usually color coding for subjects, etc. or if we ask for certain brands, it’s usually because from experience, they work much better than others. For example Elmers works so much better than rose art or staples brand. Even pencils. The Ticonderoga sharpen so much better than any others lol. We have learned a lot over the years about supplies ??. I agree, crayola crayons are vastly superior to rose art. When my kids were in elementary school the teacher told me she would just throw out the rose art crayons before they made it into the share bin if there was only one kid who brought the brand in. Target brand crayons are pretty much Crayola without the label. They are the same quality. Way better than Rose Art. Of course, if we are using them to create priceless works of art, then yeah. But for some coloring in class, they are just fine. |
Posted 9/9/21 8:18 AM
|
|
|
School supplies - do you buy exactly what is asked for? Ended up getting everything for DD - $150. Message edited 2021-09-09 08:48:15.483000. |
|
Posted 9/9/21 8:36 AM
|
|
|
School supplies - do you buy exactly what is asked for? On the list is a box of dry erase markers (10 pack) - 20 kids in a class, thats 200 markers. Message edited 2021-09-09 08:41:32.337000. |
|
Posted 9/9/21 8:40 AM
|
|
|
Re: School supplies - do you buy exactly what is asked for? Posted by newlywedT On the list is a box of dry erase markers (10 pack) - 20 kids in a class, thats 200 markers. I assume they will not go through 200 markers in a school year, or maybe they do. They also asked for plastic sheet protectors - 200 pack. At 20 kids, thats 4,000 sheet protectors, wtf. I assume the teacher asks for a lot in case some parents do not buy Wow, what grade is this? That is A LOT of money IME for one kid. I had 2 kids and at the height of the school supplies, I spent about $90. Public school if that makes a difference. |
|
Posted 9/9/21 10:09 AM
|
|
|
Re: School supplies - do you buy exactly what is asked for? Posted by newlywedT On the list is a box of dry erase markers (10 pack) - 20 kids in a class, thats 200 markers. I assume they will not go through 200 markers in a school year, or maybe they do. They also asked for plastic sheet protectors - 200 pack. At 20 kids, thats 4,000 sheet protectors, wtf. I assume the teacher asks for a lot in case some parents do not buy Okay, I have 3 elementary school aged kids and I spent under $100 on all 3. That is ridiculous. I remember when my first son started kindergarten, his teacher wanted 30 glue sticks (x18 kids). At open school night, I jokingly (sort of) asked her if she was running an etsy sweatshop in there. What the heck was she doing with all of those glue sticks?! To answer your original question, I always buy the colors asked for. I try to buy the brands they request and as others said, they tend to be superior so worth the extra few cents. But sometimes I can't. For example, DS2's teacher wanted an 8 pack of crayons. They only came in 10 packs at Staples so that's what he got. |
|
Posted 9/9/21 10:29 AM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| where do you ladies buy school supplies... | jlk51496 | 8/22/11 | 4 | Parenting |
| Where do you buy school supplies | ria | 6/26/11 | 1 | Parenting |
| Where do you buy school supplies | ria | 6/26/11 | 2 | Parents of School-Aged Children |
| When you are asked to send in old magazines to school | CathyB | 7/28/11 | 3 | Parents of School-Aged Children |
| She asked me to buy her a boyfriend | Bxgell2 | 10/22/08 | 13 | Parenting |
| Exactly what breastfeeding supplies are eligible by FSA? | MrsBurtch525 | 4/7/11 | 0 | Parenting |






