Super Shuttle or private car to get to JFK?

Has anyone used Super Shuttle to get to/from JFK from Suffolk County? If so, did you feel they were reliable, and would you recommend using them, or a similar service? It's much less expensive than getting a private car service, but I'm wondering if it's worth the savings. If you've used Super Shuttle, did you have to make a lot of stops along the way to pick up other passengers, and were they far out the way? We don't really mind making a few stops, but we're worried they will take us far out of our way and add a lot of extra travel time.

Any recommendations for any car or shuttle service are welcome! Thanks!

Re: Super Shuttle or private car to get to JFK?

I've used them a bunch of times with no issues. They recommend what time to pick you up based on your filght. I think they guarantee no more than 3 total stops per van.

Re: Super Shuttle or private car to get to JFK?

I've used Super Shuttle from JFK, they're alright. I usually use Prime Time Shuttle, their similar in price but I find them much more reliable and efficient. However, for this situation I would look into Go Sedan. They're private luxury car and cheaper than a taxi.Prime Time Shuttle Go Sedan