So where should we go to eat today?

DH & I and my BIL and SIL are going to see Rock of Ages for an afternoon show.

We want to go out to dinner afterwards.

While I personally don't mind hopping on the subway to get good food, we are driving in, and with the snow DH is already griping about not wanting to "go too far".

We eat Italian all the time so give me good suggestions other than that. And nothing too "fast food".