Simplicity Cribs - what would you do?

I saw a crib by Simplicity on the Target website that I really like. Got great reviews by those who purchased it. But the Baby Bargains book gave them an "F" mostly because of a recall in 2005 I believe. Would you still get the crib (based on current user reviews and the fact that you like it) or keep looking because of the recall in 2005? Do any of you have a Simplicty crib? Do you like it? Thanks ladies!

edited for spelling - SORRY!

Message edited 3/3/2008 3:11:41 PM.

Re: Simplicity Cribs - what would you do?

I didn't let that bother me - we loved the Simlpicity crib above the others so we got it. I have no experience with it yet, but I'll let you know.

Re: Simplicity Cribs - what would you do?

Every crib has to pass the same tests, so whether your crib is $50 or $5,000 it still has to meet certain requirements.

If you love it and it works for you and has the features and style that you want, then go for it!

With all the people in this world, not one product will ever satisfy every single person out there!

Re: Simplicity Cribs - what would you do?

Have you checked the rating on consumer reports?

Re: Simplicity Cribs - what would you do?

Re: Simplicity Cribs - what would you do?

Re: Simplicity Cribs - what would you do?

no crib ratings for specific models/brands on consumerreports... I just logged in to see if they did anything brand-specific.....

they just advised to buy a new crib, avoid handmedowns, and make sure it's sturdy in the shop (rattle it, and see how well it's built)

I say if you like it and the online reviews are good, buy it.

Re: Simplicity Cribs - what would you do?

I fell in love with the Simplicity 4-1 crib set, after reading reviews we decided NOT to go with it...we found a beautiful crib and without the worry about the recall. For me, the recall was on my mind with the death of one child, I decided not to go with the brand. I don't want to deter you from buying it if you really like it but DH and I really loved that crib and looked forever to find another one we really like but we did find another one with great reviews and peace of mind.

Re: Simplicity Cribs - what would you do?

Sorry, I wanted to add a positive...consumer reports recommends that brand, Here is the info:
WHAT'S AVAILABLE

Major brands of bassinets and cradles are, in alphabetical order: Amby Baby (www.ambybaby.com), Badger Basket (www.badger basket.com), Eddie Bauer (www.djgusa.com), Kolcraft (www.kolcraft.com), Posh Tots (www.poshtots.com), Scandinavian Child (www.scichild.com), Simplicity for Children (www.simplicityforchildren.com), and The First Years (www.thefirstyears.com). Prices range from $40 for basic bassinets to $800 (and more) for custom-made deluxe bassinets decked out with elegant, flowing bed skirts and decorative ruffles and bows, or intricate wooden or ornate iron cradles. In general, you'll find a lot to choose from in the basic to slightly upgraded range--$70 to $175.

The hammock cradle, also known as a motion bed, by Amby Baby ($238), which is certified by JPMA, can be used for babies up to 25 pounds. Its angled, slightly upright sleeping position is designed to help babies suffering from colic and reflux.


RECOMMENDATIONS

First, decide whether or not you truly need a bassinet or cradle. If the crib you've selected fits in your bedroom, consider having your baby sleep in that from day one, then shift the crib into the nursery when your baby is 6 months old or so. If you do want a bassinet or cradle, consider how you'll use it and how portable you'll need it to be. If you just want a place for your baby to sleep nearby at night, buy a basic model, preferably one that's JPMA certified. (View other bassinets and cradles with some caution. Most likely they're also in compliance with the voluntary safety standard, but unless they've been officially JPMA certified, you can't be sure.)

Look for a model with a sturdy bottom and a wide, stable base. There should be no sharp points or edges on the inside or outside, or small parts that could be a choking hazard. If the bassinet or cradle is made of wood, it should be free of splinters. Check any folding mechanisms. If the legs or frame collapse for storage, make sure they lock into place when the unit is set up. Make sure the mattress and padding are smooth and extra firm, and fit snugly. The mattress pad should be no more than 11/2 inches thick.

Use only a fitted sheet provided by the manufacturer or one specifically designed to fit the dimension of the mattress. Buy at least three fitted sheets so you have one to use, one for the wash, and one as a backup. Don't use a pillowcase or another size sheet as a substitute. If you need any parts, get them from the same company that made the cradle or bassinet. To order, check the instruction manual.

Abide by the manufacturer's weight and size specifications and stop using the product when it's time. There are usually warnings on the product, sometimes a lot of them. A note about assembly: Some bassinets have as many as 13 parts, and you may need a Phillips screwdriver and a good half hour to put the puzzle together. Bassinets and cradles have a short life span. If budget is a consideration, it doesn't make sense to splurge on this item. Cradles and bassinets, especially those embellished with a flowing skirt and bows, can pull on your heartstrings but dent your pocketbook. Such window dressing is nice, but definitely not necessary.