Anyone else's family not do baby showers??

Posted By Message

JustBrowsin
LIF Adult

Member since 2/07

1147 total posts

Name:

Anyone else's family not do baby showers??

I was just wondering because in my family its always been that you dont have a shower. Its like an old Irish superstition that its bad luck to get gifts before you have the baby....Just wondering if anyone else skips showers also?

Posted 5/9/07 5:32 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

nbc188
Best friends!

Member since 12/06

23090 total posts

Name:
C

Re: Anyone else's family not do baby showers??

Well, I've heard some Jewish families don't do showers for the same reason, superstitious. Do you still make a registry though, and people buy you things after the baby is born? Or is that superstitious to do the registry first too?

Posted 5/9/07 6:19 PM
 

DanaRenee
Fitness Junkie!

Member since 6/06

6470 total posts

Name:
Dana

Re: Anyone else's family not do baby showers??

I've heard of people not doing it...But I couldn't even imagine being that superstitious and not allowing family and friends to buy me gifts!!! Especially when I'd have to otherwise lay out the $$!

I just think that if anything is going to happen, its going to happen regardless of if you have a shower or not!!!

Posted 5/9/07 6:23 PM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: Anyone else's family not do baby showers??

Posted by nbc188

Well, I've heard some Jewish families don't do showers for the same reason, superstitious. Do you still make a registry though, and people buy you things after the baby is born? Or is that superstitious to do the registry first too?




I am Jewish and my family would not have a shower for me. It is not a tradition we have. It is also a major superstition not to bring anything into the home for the child until it is born. Some people will not buy anything for a baby at all. Some people will register and/or if they are given gifts before the birth, they are stored at someone else's home. There are stores that will allow a couple to choose a layette for a boy AND/OR a girl and once the child is born, someone else picks it up and has it washed. When my sister had my nephew nothing was done in advance for his room except the paint so it could dry without exposure to fumes for anyone. He was in a bassinet in her bedroom until everything was assembled and decorated.

Most of the time, furniture is purchased by either the couple or the grandparents. It too is ordered and not delivered until after the baby is born.

If the child is a boy, many of the gifts are purchased and given at the bris. If it is a girl, it depends on when the parents plan a baby naming ceremony and then gifts can be given then. Plenty of gifts are mailed. The child doesnt go naked.

Posted 5/9/07 6:45 PM
 

JustBrowsin
LIF Adult

Member since 2/07

1147 total posts

Name:

Re: Anyone else's family not do baby showers??

Posted by nbc188

Well, I've heard some Jewish families don't do showers for the same reason, superstitious. Do you still make a registry though, and people buy you things after the baby is born? Or is that superstitious to do the registry first too?




I dont think that Ill make a registry, but thats not part of the superstition since registries werent around way back then. Im pretty sure that my mom and Dh's parents will buy us most of our stuff since thats just how they are and they were ridiculously generous with our wedding gifts.
For us, its still "OK" to have baby things before the baby is born, its just the idea of having a big event like a shower beforehand. So we can have the room set up and stuff before the baby is born. Like the above poster said, for our family a baby shower just isnt a tradition--its just not something we do.

Message edited 2007-05-09 19:02:32.683000.

Posted 5/9/07 7:00 PM
 

Kerie-is-so-very
versatile!

Member since 5/05

13535 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Anyone else's family not do baby showers??

I am Jewish and I probably will not have a shower. My mom does not care whether I follow the Jewish tradition of not having a shower, but she is not a "party person" and not into celebrations. My in-laws are also Jewish but they just threw my SIL a huge baby shower. So, it is really just my choice to follow the Jewish way. My grandmother always told me to avoid the evil eye, and a shower is said to invite the evil eye (weird to explain, but maybe someone else who is Jewish can do a better job of explaining than I can).

My sister would throw me the shower if I wanted it. I do not think that I would get equivalent gifts for a bris or baby naming but that will just be a consequence I will have to bear if I don't want a shower. Plus, there are things I will need to buy on my own before either of those 2 events.

I've seen some showers cancelled because the person had to go on bed rest or had early labor. That weighs heavily on my mind.

Posted 5/9/07 7:05 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Anyone else's family not do baby showers??

I will not have a shower for other reasons. My family lives overseas and both of DH's parents are deceased with either family members he is not in contact with or not on LI.

We still did a registry for ourself at first. As a "list" of items we needed.

Actually we found a few peple bought us items from the registry. Friends, co-workers. We were very pleasantly surprised because we did not expect much.

I may have a work shower.

Message edited 2007-05-09 19:44:38.760000.

Posted 5/9/07 7:44 PM
 

bayla
Love my two kiddos :)

Member since 8/06

7178 total posts

Name:

Re: Anyone else's family not do baby showers??

i am jewish too and my DH is catholic and i am having a shower, although it is mostly family. My mom wouldnt throw it b/c shes jewish (but will attend), and my stepmom who is catholic wouldnt throw it either b/c her family just doesnt do it, so my DH decided to throw me one b/c he's italian and in his family EVERYONE who is having a baby has one and for him its tradition. I dont think b/c i am having one, it's bad luck or a bad thing, i am looking at it as a get together with a lot of family i may not see for a while after having the baby. We also have been setting up the room, my DH is not superstitous and we also dont have any storage to hold baby things until after he's born and my parents have no room either. Plus we are both BIG planners and we want things to be set and ready to go when he's born. My shower is going to be around 3 or 4 weeks before my due date, and if i go into pre-term labor, i dont think it will be b/c i had a shower
*plus my SIL didnt have a shower planned and she was put on bedrest at 6 months b/c of placenta previa

Message edited 2007-05-09 19:45:50.617000.

Posted 5/9/07 7:44 PM
 

Kerie-is-so-very
versatile!

Member since 5/05

13535 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Anyone else's family not do baby showers??

Posted by bayla

i am jewish too and my DH is catholic and i am having a shower, although it is mostly family. My mom wouldnt throw it b/c shes jewish (but will attend), and my stepmom who is catholic wouldnt throw it either b/c her family just doesnt do it, so my DH decided to throw me one b/c he's italian and in his family EVERYONE who is having a baby has one and for him its tradition. I dont think b/c i am having one, it's bad luck or a bad thing, i am looking at it as a get together with a lot of family i may not see for a while after having the baby. We also have been setting up the room, my DH is not superstitous and we also dont have any storage to hold baby things until after he's born and my parents have no room either. Plus we are both BIG planners and we want things to be set and ready to go when he's born. My shower is going to be around 3 or 4 weeks before my due date, and if i go into pre-term labor, i dont think it will be b/c i had a shower
*plus my SIL didnt have a shower planned and she was put on bedrest at 6 months b/c of placenta previa




I hope that you did not think that by my post I wanted to imply that the planning of a shower brought on the issues that caused the shower to be cancelled. I just meant that I would hate to see a party planned and then cancelled. That would cause stress on top of whatever the medical situation. Yes, I do have certain superstitions that may prevent me from having a shower (so far I have asked that no one throw me one). However, I attend them all the time (and I don't give the evil eye, I swear!!!!).

Posted 5/9/07 8:47 PM
 

hbugal
Lesigh

Member since 2/07

15928 total posts

Name:

Re: Anyone else's family not do baby showers??

It is a European belief..I believe that it is bad luck to buy anything before the baby is born....When I had my first daughter I never had a baby shower. To be honest with you I always felt like I missed out on something.

Posted 5/9/07 8:57 PM
 

bayla
Love my two kiddos :)

Member since 8/06

7178 total posts

Name:

Re: Anyone else's family not do baby showers??

Posted by ssdbk

Posted by bayla

i am jewish too and my DH is catholic and i am having a shower, although it is mostly family. My mom wouldnt throw it b/c shes jewish (but will attend), and my stepmom who is catholic wouldnt throw it either b/c her family just doesnt do it, so my DH decided to throw me one b/c he's italian and in his family EVERYONE who is having a baby has one and for him its tradition. I dont think b/c i am having one, it's bad luck or a bad thing, i am looking at it as a get together with a lot of family i may not see for a while after having the baby. We also have been setting up the room, my DH is not superstitous and we also dont have any storage to hold baby things until after he's born and my parents have no room either. Plus we are both BIG planners and we want things to be set and ready to go when he's born. My shower is going to be around 3 or 4 weeks before my due date, and if i go into pre-term labor, i dont think it will be b/c i had a shower
*plus my SIL didnt have a shower planned and she was put on bedrest at 6 months b/c of placenta previa




I hope that you did not think that by my post I wanted to imply that the planning of a shower brought on the issues that caused the shower to be cancelled. I just meant that I would hate to see a party planned and then cancelled. That would cause stress on top of whatever the medical situation. Yes, I do have certain superstitions that may prevent me from having a shower (so far I have asked that no one throw me one). However, I attend them all the time (and I don't give the evil eye, I swear!!!!).



no i understand you were just posting your opinonChat Icon I have met people who have said this though to me and it has always p***ed me off, b/c i feel like if someone wants a shower or their family wants to do it, negative stuff shouldn't be said to them, esp when your pregnant. Everyone has different beliefs and feelings esp when it comes to baby showers and things to do with the baby

Posted 5/9/07 9:40 PM
 

Mrs
LIF Adult

Member since 6/05

1652 total posts

Name:

Re: Anyone else's family not do baby showers??

Im jewish but will have a shower.
I think its a great way to celebrate with friends and family.

Unfortunately I will be moving out of town from my friends and family and the shower is a great way for me to see them again and celebrate with them.

Posted 5/9/07 10:04 PM
 

LSP2005
Bunny kisses are so cute!

Member since 5/05

19461 total posts

Name:
L

Re: Anyone else's family not do baby showers??

My mom is adament that I not have a baby shower. I know my co-workers want to throw me a baby shower so the presents will be brought to my parents house directly after the party. (My mother felt that this was ok because she would not have to be there). We registered because my co-workers wanted us to. Had they not said something we probably would not have registered.

As for our home, we ordered the crib and changing table but it will not be delivered until the baby is born. We purchased a onesie but it is in the trunk of the car and not in our house.

Posted 5/9/07 10:18 PM
 

Kerie-is-so-very
versatile!

Member since 5/05

13535 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Anyone else's family not do baby showers??

Posted by bayla

Posted by ssdbk

Posted by bayla

i am jewish too and my DH is catholic and i am having a shower, although it is mostly family. My mom wouldnt throw it b/c shes jewish (but will attend), and my stepmom who is catholic wouldnt throw it either b/c her family just doesnt do it, so my DH decided to throw me one b/c he's italian and in his family EVERYONE who is having a baby has one and for him its tradition. I dont think b/c i am having one, it's bad luck or a bad thing, i am looking at it as a get together with a lot of family i may not see for a while after having the baby. We also have been setting up the room, my DH is not superstitous and we also dont have any storage to hold baby things until after he's born and my parents have no room either. Plus we are both BIG planners and we want things to be set and ready to go when he's born. My shower is going to be around 3 or 4 weeks before my due date, and if i go into pre-term labor, i dont think it will be b/c i had a shower
*plus my SIL didnt have a shower planned and she was put on bedrest at 6 months b/c of placenta previa




I hope that you did not think that by my post I wanted to imply that the planning of a shower brought on the issues that caused the shower to be cancelled. I just meant that I would hate to see a party planned and then cancelled. That would cause stress on top of whatever the medical situation. Yes, I do have certain superstitions that may prevent me from having a shower (so far I have asked that no one throw me one). However, I attend them all the time (and I don't give the evil eye, I swear!!!!).



no i understand you were just posting your opinonChat Icon I have met people who have said this though to me and it has always p***ed me off, b/c i feel like if someone wants a shower or their family wants to do it, negative stuff shouldn't be said to them, esp when your pregnant. Everyone has different beliefs and feelings esp when it comes to baby showers and things to do with the baby




Well, I am reserving the right to change my mind anyway. My sister says that she would not plan it until I am further along. I am going to register but I expect to just buy some of the items off my own registry. As for everyone giving an opinion, there are some people who will give me a hard time for NOT wanting a shower. Chat Icon And the unsolicited opinions are one reason that DH and I aren't discussing baby names with anyone.

Posted 5/9/07 10:41 PM
 

waterspout4
My loves

Member since 5/06

19150 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: Anyone else's family not do baby showers??

My mom (Irish) said I didn't need a shower. MIL (Italian) said I must have one. I'm going with the flow and I hear I'm having one. (It's the first child of the generation for his family.) I don't think my mom will be flying down for it.

Posted 5/9/07 10:46 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Anyone else's family not do baby showers??

Posted by hbugalla

It is a European belief..I believe that it is bad luck to buy anything before the baby is born....When I had my first daughter I never had a baby shower. To be honest with you I always felt like I missed out on something.



Which European country are you talking about?

It is actually believed not to buy any baby stuff BEFORE being PG, not once you are PG. It's VERY BAD LUCK to buy anything thinking you will/might be PG one day. There are no rules of the 12 weeks/1st trimester like here either. I had never heard of waiting for the 1st trimester until I moved here.

Message edited 2007-05-10 07:56:52.280000.

Posted 5/10/07 7:55 AM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Think I had an LIF mom & baby spotting today! (Seles81) MatteosMom 5/9/07 2 Parenting
Help from the BTDT Moms re: family visiting after Baby KateDevine 3/22/07 0 Parenting
SO the pressure to have a baby has started from my family........ beautyq115 12/13/06 53 Families Helping Families ™
Is anyone looking for a really good baby/child and family photgrapher? lipglossjunky73 10/4/06 3 Families Helping Families ™
My friend of the family had a baby boy and I need suggestions for juju 7/19/06 4 Parenting
ANOTHER baby welcomed to the family last night! jersee3380 2/11/06 3 Pregnancy