LIFamilies.com - Long Island, NY


RSS
Articles Business Directory Blog Real Estate Community Forum Shop My Family Contests

Log In Chat Index Search Rules Lingo Create Account

Quick navigation:   

Bjs or costco sheet cake?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

MC09
arrrghhh!!!!

Member since 2/09

5674 total posts

Name:
Me speaks pirate!

Bjs or costco sheet cake?

Which do you prefer and why?

Posted 5/26/16 5:22 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

luvmykids8
LIF Adult

Member since 9/15

2050 total posts

Name:

Bjs or costco sheet cake?

I've only had from BJs and I like it!

Posted 5/26/16 5:29 PM
 

ANewDayHasCome
Love multiplies, not divides

Member since 11/12

14481 total posts

Name:
Me

Bjs or costco sheet cake?

Shop rite lol. Yes I know it wasn't an option but it is really good.

Posted 5/26/16 5:50 PM
 

chilltocam
LIF Adult

Member since 11/11

9141 total posts

Name:

Bjs or costco sheet cake?

If you need a full sheet cake, only BJs has that. Costco only has 1/2 sheet cakes

Posted 5/26/16 6:09 PM
 

MommaG
Yay Spring!

Member since 5/05

5133 total posts

Name:
Gloria

Bjs or costco sheet cake?

I've only had Costco cakes and they are delicious! Also, if the combination of cake/filling is not on the order form, they will special order for you at no extra charge.

Posted 5/26/16 7:08 PM
 

alli3131
Peanut is here!!!!!!

Member since 5/09

18388 total posts

Name:
Allison

Bjs or costco sheet cake?

Costco. By far!!!

Posted 5/26/16 7:28 PM
 

melbalalala
Little Lady

Member since 5/07

5014 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Bjs or costco sheet cake?

I always wind up getting BJs because they have so many more decoration choices, licensed stuff particularly. Costco has maybe 10-12 designs they use. I think they both taste the same.

Posted 5/26/16 8:43 PM
 

jlm2008
LIF Adult

Member since 1/10

5092 total posts

Name:

Bjs or costco sheet cake?

I like Costco much better! I know you didn't ask, but Stop & Shop, at least the one in New Hyde Park, is my favorite bakery by far!!!

Posted 5/26/16 9:52 PM
 

gina409
TWINS!

Member since 12/09

27635 total posts

Name:
g

Re: Bjs or costco sheet cake?

Bj's but like others have said I've gotten great ones from stop n shop

Posted 5/26/16 10:28 PM
 

Budjeg11
LIF Adult

Member since 4/11

2644 total posts

Name:

Re: Bjs or costco sheet cake?

Posted by MommaG

I've only had Costco cakes and they are delicious! Also, if the combination of cake/filling is not on the order form, they will special order for you at no extra charge.

Posted 5/26/16 10:31 PM
 

Budjeg11
LIF Adult

Member since 4/11

2644 total posts

Name:

Re: Bjs or costco sheet cake?

Posted by MommaG

I've only had Costco cakes and they are delicious! Also, if the combination of cake/filling is not on the order form, they will special order for you at no extra charge.



Really? which Costco? They have always told me that they cant change it- its just what is available.

Posted 5/26/16 10:32 PM
 

Mommyx03
LIF Infant

Member since 5/15

283 total posts

Name:

Bjs or costco sheet cake?

I know it wasn't an option but I got DDs Christening cake at Stop & Shop and it was so pretty and delicious!! Everyone was asking us where we got it!

Posted 5/26/16 11:20 PM
 

haveaquestion
LIF Adult

Member since 11/09

918 total posts

Name:

Re: Bjs or costco sheet cake?

BJs

Posted 5/27/16 6:11 AM
 

LoLaBlue
PARTY OF 5

Member since 6/10

6900 total posts

Name:

Re: Bjs or costco sheet cake?

Posted by ANewDayHasCome

Shop rite lol. Yes I know it wasn't an option but it is really good.



shoprite cakes are so good!

Posted 5/27/16 7:36 AM
 

mommy2be716
LIF Adult

Member since 1/16

2921 total posts

Name:

Bjs or costco sheet cake?

stop and shop cakes are actually really good!

Posted 5/27/16 7:41 AM
 

HomeIsWithU
Baby #2 on the way!

Member since 9/07

7816 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: Bjs or costco sheet cake?

Costco by far! They're sooo good!

Posted 5/27/16 8:57 AM
 

mnmsoinlove
Mommy to 2 sweet girls!

Member since 3/09

8585 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Bjs or costco sheet cake?

I've ordered both and think taste is pretty much the same. BJs just has more decoration options.

Posted 5/27/16 9:09 AM
 

MrsM84
LIF Adult

Member since 2/13

2352 total posts

Name:

Bjs or costco sheet cake?

Stop and Shop's cakes are amazing! We got a 1/4 sheet cake for my daughter's first birthday and everyone kept asking where we got it. It was a yellow cake with the white traditional frosting. I brought in one of the paper plates to show them the theme and they matched the cake design perfectly. Best part - $21.99!

Posted 5/27/16 9:19 AM
 

ali120206
2 Boys

Member since 7/06

17790 total posts

Name:

Re: Bjs or costco sheet cake?

Posted by ANewDayHasCome

Shop rite lol. Yes I know it wasn't an option but it is really good.



They are my favorite as well - followed by Costcos and Stop and Shop. BJs are good as well.

I used to work in catering and thought the supermarket/wholesale club cakes tasted better than the expensive ones lol.

Posted 5/27/16 10:17 AM
 

summerBaby10
let's be nice

Member since 9/07

10208 total posts

Name:
Wifey

Re: Bjs or costco sheet cake?

Posted by MrsM84

Stop and Shop's cakes are amazing! We got a 1/4 sheet cake for my daughter's first birthday and everyone kept asking where we got it. It was a yellow cake with the white traditional frosting. I brought in one of the paper plates to show them the theme and they matched the cake design perfectly. Best part - $21.99!



wow, they really matched your design? Which S&S? I would love if they could match a little bit of my younger son's robot bday plates onto a cake. I used the S&S in new hyde park for my older DS bday cake & they were a mess. They didn't even have a pen for me to fill the for out, I had to dig a crayon out of my bag to fill it out.

Posted 5/27/16 10:57 AM
 

MommaG
Yay Spring!

Member since 5/05

5133 total posts

Name:
Gloria

Re: Bjs or costco sheet cake?

Posted by Budjeg11

Posted by MommaG

I've only had Costco cakes and they are delicious! Also, if the combination of cake/filling is not on the order form, they will special order for you at no extra charge.



Really? which Costco? They have always told me that they cant change it- its just what is available.




Melville. We spoke with someone in the bakery dept and they told us to just write what we want on the ticket. If you order, make sure you speak with someone first to make sure they still do that.

Posted 5/27/16 11:54 AM
 

JSDB
<3

Member since 1/13

1329 total posts

Name:

Re: Bjs or costco sheet cake?

Have only had BJs but love them. Super reasonable, taste great, great options -- you can have them screen a photo on free or choose from their book which has great designs. We have done it for 3 parties now

Posted 5/27/16 11:59 AM
 

MrsM84
LIF Adult

Member since 2/13

2352 total posts

Name:

Re: Bjs or costco sheet cake?

Posted by summerBaby10

Posted by MrsM84

Stop and Shop's cakes are amazing! We got a 1/4 sheet cake for my daughter's first birthday and everyone kept asking where we got it. It was a yellow cake with the white traditional frosting. I brought in one of the paper plates to show them the theme and they matched the cake design perfectly. Best part - $21.99!



wow, they really matched your design? Which S&S? I would love if they could match a little bit of my younger son's robot bday plates onto a cake. I used the S&S in new hyde park for my older DS bday cake & they were a mess. They didn't even have a pen for me to fill the for out, I had to dig a crayon out of my bag to fill it out.


Farmingdale! When I say they matched the design, the plates had butterflies and flowers on them - they had both drawn on the cake and did it in matching colors as the plates/theme.

Posted 5/27/16 12:00 PM
 

BabyHopes2
LIF Adult

Member since 4/13

1058 total posts

Name:

Re: Bjs or costco sheet cake?

I have had both, I am a BJ's member and like their cakes. I had one from Costco and I have to say it was much better it wasn't so overly sweet like BJ's.

Posted 5/27/16 12:32 PM
 

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: Bjs or costco sheet cake?

I've only had BJ's and it was great.
But I have a Costco membership too and now I want to try Costco to compare!

Posted 5/27/16 1:33 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Can BJs or Costco scan a picture on a sheet cake? beautyq115 10/3/10 7 Parenting
Does anyone have pics of a Christening/Communion cake from BJs or Costco? Shorty 9/19/11 6 Parenting
Can you share pics of your Costco/BJs birthday cake? Rycois 3/8/10 0 Parenting
Costco sheet cake MrsC614 2/1/14 11 Families Helping Families ™
BJs or Costco B-day cake donegal419 7/1/10 5 Parenting
Any tips for ordering a BJs sheet cake? LadyBugN2Buggies 2/12/11 4 Parenting
 
Quick navigation:   
Currently 268273 users on the LIFamilies.com Chat
New Businesses
1 More Rep
Carleton Hall of East Islip
J&A Building Services
LaraMae Health Coaching
Sonic Wellness
Julbaby Photography LLC
Ideal Uniforms
Teresa Geraghty Photography
Camelot Dream Homes
Long Island Wedding Boutique
MB Febus- Rodan & Fields
Camp Harbor
Market America-Shop.com
ACM Basement Waterproofing
Travel Tom

      Follow LIWeddings on Facebook

      Follow LIFamilies on Twitter
Long Island Bridal Shows