Re: Gardasil Event
Posted 11/20/2019 4:23:40 PM by LuckyStar
Posted by FirstMate
Posted by LuckyStar
Posted by FirstMate
Posted by SecretlyTTC14
I don't understand the logic. I guess "my body... my choice" only applies to abortions 
They say we shouldn't have a choice when public health is at risk, and I somewhat agree. I understand the MMR and other immunizations that prevent illnesses that are contagious through just breathing the same air as someone else, but this is an immunization against a sexually transmitted disease and there should be a choice no matter what. It does not pose a risk to the general public and kids in school will not catch HPV just by brushing arms with someone.
If you're all for it, then get it for your kids. Nobody is stopping you. You shouldn't be able to force it on everyone else. There is literally no reason this has to be mandated. It is possible to want this immunization for your kids while respecting the people that don't. It's not one or the other. Whoever wants it, can get it.
Agreed!! I'm all for vaccinations but I do not think there is any public safety concern for this that it should be mandated.
As for Hep B, I never really thought about the similarities. I guess because it's already mandated I just never gave it much thought. There are discreet differences though.
Certain strands of HPV could potentially lead to cancer if not treated. There are a lot of "may" and "could" and not as much definitive. Also, HPV is very treatable. I was diagnosed with it in 2000, had my treatments (not fun - first two were unsuccessful. Also, the treatments caused me to have problems during pregnancy.) and have not had a recurrence since.
On the other hand, Hep B can be transmitted other ways besides sexually. Also, it absolutely will lead to liver damage, treated or not, which can lead to a multitude of other health issues. It is a chronic and non-curable condition too. It can also be passed from mom to a fetus which is certainly concerning.
For this particular vaccine, I feel this should be left to the discretion of the patient and/or parent. I likely will get it for my kids but I can understand why others are against it.
The fact that you had “not fun” treatments and problems during pregnancy due to a virus you didn’t know was being passed to you is a public health concern. This happens to SO MANY women. It IS a concern.
Just like I wouldn't have known if HIV or any other STD was being passed along to me. It is a diagnosis reflecting a failure to use protection.
I don't think that makes it a public safety issue and I disagree with the government dictating the vaccination. I think that opens a pandora's box and at what point can we limit the government's power over our bodies? So many people are against the flu vaccination. Right here in this little LIF community you see it. The flu is super contagious and, in some cases, deadly. That is truly a public health concern. But if that vaccination was up for being mandated, people would lose their minds.
Condoms don’t always protect against HPV, it’s spread through skin to skin contact. A virus requiring invasive diagnostics and treatment that can subsequently lead to cancer, with no feasible way to avoid (abstinence is not a feasible option for the majority of the population) is a public heath concern. The amount of money and resources that are used to diagnose and treat HPV are a burden for everyone.
Whether or not you agree with the vaccine, HPV is a public health concern.
|