Re: Michael Cohen Testimony
Posted 3/4/2019 11:56:37 AM by starbrightgirl8


Posted by Christine2

Ok, so by that logic, if you support Islam, are you then a terrorist? Meaning, some elements of Islam can be radical. So, thereby if you support the whole, you must then support all the parts?

ETA: As a general rule, if you are going to make a character attack on someone, you need to cite specific evidence. You cannot assume that all supporters agree in totality with the person they support.



This isn't really the right comparison. Islam doesn't support terrorism. Some to it's followers do (as do some supporters of all the worlds major religions, not just Islam). This would be more appropriate comparison if some of Trump's supporters were racist, but he himself and his policies weren't racist, but this is not the case.

The more appropriate comparison would be if you support ISIS, then are you a terrorist? If someone said they support ISIS because of its politics - maybe they support that the West should not be involved in the middle east, but they don't agree that members of ISIS should engage in terrorism to achieve their goals. They're still supporting a terrorist organisation even if they don't agree with the specific terrorist acts.

Or how about Hitler? Plenty of people supported his politics without necessarily supporting his antisemitic views. If you support Hitler without being antisemitic, then are you in the right? With your support, you help him come to power even though you don't personally have a problem with the Jewish people, but you're still enabling the person who does and giving him the power to do great damage.

So whether you support racist actions or not, just by supporting Trump you're helping him grain the power to implement and normalize his racist views. If you're supporting someone who is racist and your support helps put them have more power, power which gives them the opportunity to oppress groups, doesn't that make you partially responsible? It's not about whether his supporters agree with every views point he has, it's that they're supporting him and giving him power, so what he does with that power is on them regardless of their personal beliefs in their heart.

Also, most people are racist to some extent, even non-Trump supporters. It's the knee jerk reaction of "HOW DARE YOU CALL ME RACIST WHEN I SUPPORT A RACIST WHITE NATIONALIST FOR THE HIGHEST OFFICE, I HAVE A BLACK FRIEND" that drives me nuts.

Print Post      Close Window