Re: What's your witholding status?
Posted 2/25/2019 10:22:48 PM by JennP
Posted by jellybean78
Posted by mrsrainbow
Posted by jellybean78
Posted by mrsrainbow
Posted by jellybean78
Posted by ChristinaM128
We claim 0 single and are getting back 60% of what we had gotten back the past 7 years. I’m devastated - we are both teachers who don’t have an option at work of 12 month paychecks ans basically we won’t be able to pay the mortgage this year. The monthly increase in paycheck is nominal compared to the refund difference. I’m sick to my stomach and rip roaring mad at anyone who ever supported a republican. Imo, republicans stand for rich and racist.
This is such an ignorant statement and coming from a teacher no less. SMDH.
Were you depending on your refund to pay your mortgage?? If so I hope you don't teach economics.
OP: We claim married 0. This year our estimated refund is slightly less than years prior.
Jellybean, care to back up why you think she's wrong?
Because she's not.
Republican politics - factually, historically, morally, ethically, literally (not figuratively) - are for the wealthy, the white, the racist, and the people who believe that you just need to work hard and pull yourself up by your bootstraps because everyone has the same chance in life and if you have it hard, well, it's you own damn fault.
So as oppose to what? Should you not pull yourself up by your bootstraps and make a better future for yourself and your family? What do you suggest that people live off the system and continue to be victims? I'm not saying that there are not injustices because of course there are they will ALWAYS be but by far and large Americans have vast opportunities in this country to make something of themselves. Why do you think so many people want to immigrate here? Why do we have so many immigrants here who have built successful businesses? I hate when people push the victim mentality.
I personally refuse to make sweeping generalizations of people according to their political party but I will say this, both parties historically have implemented policies and beliefs that have disadvantaged people. Historically Democrats were the ones that opposed abolishing slavery. This is a historical fact.
In addition Democratic states impose super high taxation on the middle class and upper middle class that put us at disadvantages in order to over promise things to people who don't pay taxes. That is also a fact. That is why there is such a mass exodus of people out of NY, NJ, etc. It's the high taxes imposed by the state. Recently Cuomo even admitted that there is a huge budget gap and he doesn't know how they plan to remediate that. Those are your democratic policies so turning around and saying that being republican is only for the rich and the racist is ignorant.
If you think bootstrap politics is a hill to die on, I invite you to check out some really great resources:
https://radicalscholarship.wordpress.com/2017/02/03/the-bootstrap-lie-and-the-politics-of-privilege/
http://ideas.time.com/2012/09/07/the-myth-of-bootstrapping/
If you think I'm making sweeping generalizations so are you; you think everyone has the same opportunities while I contend that that line of thinking means that you, or I, or that a baby born addicted to heroin to a teenage mother in Kansas has exactly the same access to education, familial support, healthcare, financial opportunity, resources, food/nutrition/wellness, housing, etc, etc, etc. Do you think we all have the same start in life now?
That's really all I have to say.
No we don't and I know this first hand because I was not raised in a middle class suburb with good school districts and a mommy and daddy who helped me out.
I'm Hispanic, I was raised by a single mom, economically disadvantaged in a neighborhood that was sketchy at best. No good schools, no free ride from anyone, no extras, struggle all around. This was not unique to me..many of my friends came from similar backgrounds. Some had it better than others some worse. We are all minorities and guess what..every single one of us decided to make decisions to better our future. period. Was it easy, no but we made conscious choices to get better, do better. We made different choices in life but we made sure the choices led us to a better future.
Of course life isn't fair, it never ever will be. Yes some people have it better than others but pushing a victim narrative to fit an agenda is exactly why so many people never do better. So no we don't all have the same start to life and we all may not have the same opportunities but that absolutely does not mean that you are unable to move forward. Progression...
I should have really quoted your first post because your personal anecdote means absolutely nothing in the grand scheme of things - just because you don't see it, doesn't mean it isn't out there - but your allegation that people who do not pay taxes are promised things is simply not true and has been debunked a million times over.
And FYI the parties pretty much switched platforms over the middle portion of the 20th century, at least over social issues, for reasons I don't have time to get into but are well documented. So the fact that Republicans abolished slavery has no bearing on what is going on today. They were a very different party then.
The modern Republican party, if you (general you) read their platform, is truly a different animal from even 15-20 years ago. They're a dangerous anachronism, caring only for themselves, swimming against the current of logic and progress, and threatening to suck us all down with them.
|