Re: Amazon Pulls Out of Planned New York City Headquarters
Posted 2/14/2019 4:41:45 PM by MsSissy


Posted by mrsrainbow


Posted by NervousNell

I'm torn.
Yes, it would be great to bring more jobs.

But do I think a company as rich as Amazon NEEDS $3 billion in tax breaks? No.
I feel like that money could better serve the city and state in so many other ways.
Our infrastructure is a disaster, and them coming here would only stress it more.
And I am not sure it would help our young people be able to afford to stay here either. If anything, it might raise the cost of living in NYC.

There are plenty of jobs in NY that offer $150K salaries, but not everyone is qualified for them.
What kind of jobs were they offering at that salary? I would imagine that kind of salary was for management level positions. So the average person, or the recent college grad, wouldn't be walking into Amazon and commanding that kind of salary if I had to guess.
I don't think they would be offering salaries that are 2-3 times the average company, unless I'm wrong.




I think people are going gaga over the "idea" of Amazon but have no clue what it would mean in terms of an already crumbling infrastructure, environmental impact, sprawling gentrification and the fact that these jobs would not truly exist for the people already living here. Perhaps years down the road the job market would adapt but initially? No, they would be hiring outside of NY and bringing people IN.

Ultimately, I am glad they pulled out. The tax breaks alone were unconscionable to the state and quite honestly Amazon and Bezos should be ashamed of themselves for even attempting to burden NY like this. If they want to bring their business here then they have to do it on the up and up and pay their share.

But I think in a few years we will realize that we dodged a huge bullet. I think if people think LI living is bad now, it would have been unfathomably worse.



Yes! All of this!!!

Print Post      Close Window