Re: Turkey Panic!
Posted 11/10/2018 1:29:35 PM by PhyllisNJoe


Posted by SusiBee


Posted by LIRascal

I feel horrible saying this because I am very conscious about what goes into my familys' bodies, but every time I've had organic or free-range turkeys, they have been tough and terrible. I just really like the regular Shady Brook Farms fresh turkeys, brined, seasoned, and roasted. Idk if anyone else feels like this, but it's just from experience.



Same here.
I also find very large birds harder to cook evenly. I make two smaller birds if my guest list is larger.
Added bonus is more dark meat and drumsticks.



I agree

My sister swears by the bag. I usually buy butterball young turkey. Gone up to 17-18 lbs
2 sticks of butter slathered all over and under skin. Salt & pepper , cooked breast down covered the whole time. Then rest it for at least 30 minutes before carving.


I keep it covered because I don’t care about the skin getting Super crispy because it’s carved and put on platter before it hits the table - I feel like cooking it without the tent makes it dry out. Could be zero science to that but it’s just a feeling I get

Edited to add: I put chicken stock in the roasting pan to help steam it with flavor and use for basting just a couple times.
Turkey is on a rack not touching bottom of pan
Print Post      Close Window