Re: house hunting + property taxes grief..
Posted 5/17/2018 7:35:44 AM by DMDT087
Posted by Christine Braun - Signature Premier Properties
I mean, it's really a matter of what monthly payment you can qualify for (from a lender's standpoint), and what you can afford (from a personal comfort zone standpoint).
I hate when buyers have hard cut-offs of $10K in taxes or $x price. Both have to be taken into account for payment's sake. The price and taxes alone in a vacuum don't matter.
If a house is $400K and has $10K in taxes, it may be just as affordable as a less expensive house with higher taxes.
Likewise, if someone says their cut-off is $10K and they are looking in the $500K range, what if they find something in the low $400Ks with slightly higher taxes? It may balance out.
Taxes do tend to go up over time, but as others said, grieving them can help. And most people qualify for STAR.
You can also figure out whether taxes seem way out of line for the area (too high) and whether they haven't been grieved in recent years. That would indicate you would likely get a reduction. On the other hand, it's important to verify what the actual taxes are with NO exemptions, because many listings include the current owners' exemptions which may include senior enhanced STAR, veterans' exemptions. You may not qualify for them, and the bank won't take exemptions into account when factoring the taxes into your qualifications, debt-to-income ratio.
So my best advice is to look at the whole picture. Taxes are a huge factor in affordability, and usually have more impact than price. Adding $1K to a mortgage amount is like roughly $5 in your monthly payment. So going up $10K in price may equal about $50 more per month. But going from 10K to 12K in property taxes will add about $166 per month to your payment. But you shouldn't look at the taxes in isolation.
When I figure out what I'm comfortable with, I consider what the monthly mortgage would be - so I look at both components together. BUT, again, since taxes will inevitably increase, I'm wary about what I commit to from the beginning. And, especially if a home needs any kind of improvements (i.e, additional bathroom), I may be setting myself up for an increase from the get-go. This particular area has homes close with close to 10K taxes but only 1 bathroom and .25acre property which seems a little up there in comparison to other homes I've seen (and I'm pretty sure once you go north of the LIE, in the same town, the taxes decrease by 1K). We're going to go see one of the houses tomorrow, but the more I think about it, the more I don't think it'll be worth it.
My 10K limit is really from that being the cap on the SALT deduction. Though my loan officer believes that it'll probably change & slowly increase. But I also think anything over 10K is kind of ridiculous unless I have a huge amount of property. Maddening how much the taxes vary.
|