Re: Unemployment question
Posted 1/19/2018 12:30:07 PM by jlm2008


Posted by LuckyStar


Posted by Pomegranate5


Posted by LuckyStar


Posted by Pomegranate5

Wow everyone is taking this so personally for some reason. It's amazing to me that some of the same women who continually complain about the maternity benefits in this country are so outraged that a new mother is trying to use UE as a crutch until she can find work that fits her needs and wants. The hypocrisy is truly baffling.



Because the government doesn’t have to support you for the sole reason that your previous job doesn’t “fit your needs or wants.” What person (I’m removing “mom” because that’s irrelevant here) wouldn’t prefer a job with, say, a shorter commute or more convenient hours? That doesn’t mean someone can quit because they’re sick of the LIRR and expect the government to pay for that choice.



She and her boss negotiated 3 days a week, which she was happy with. Now, before she got the chance to come back, they have told her that either she accommodates something else, or she has no job. Would your opinion change if she was already back working at 3 days and then they changed it on her? How is this different than a FT job being changed to a PT job? Who are strangers on a message board to decide the hours she can and cannot work?

All I was saying is that she should at least try, and in all likelihood her boss would not fight it.



No, my opinion would not change because she was never working part time. She worked full time, went on maternity leave and then came back to the same job she had before she went on leave. Legally they did what they needed to do. And, it is certainly different from a FT job changing to a PT job. The job offered upon return needs to be equivalent to the previous job. You couldn’t offer someone who previously worked a salaried position making $100k a part time hourly position making $15 an hour because that is not equivalent.

Of course strangers cannot decide what hours she can work. I don’t think anyone is implying that. What we’re saying is that SHE is choosing to not take the equivalent job offered to her. Therefore, she would not be entitled to UE benefits without some type of fabrication, which is illegal.

I fundamentally disagree with someone applying for benefits not intended for them. IMO, no one should be paid for choosing not to work. And that is what seems to be getting lost in translation here- choice vs need. But, I’m not the ethics police, so have at it.



You are exactly right! I am not sure if things are getting lost in all the posts but the fact is she worked 5 days a week, went on maternity leave, while on maternity leave boss & she agreed to 3 days. before she came back, boss said no, I need you for 5 days that you always worked. SHE changed the job, NOT the boss. What aren't people getting about this??? I can GUARANTEE you I cannot tell my job I decided to just work 3 days from now on and if they don't accept that, since I am a full time employee that I would get unemployment.
Print Post      Close Window