Re: Voting Yes tomorrow question
Posted 11/7/2017 2:00:05 PM by GoldenRod
Posted by blu6385
...
from what I am being told by people who say to vote no is that the pension are protected currently but they can vote to change the Constitution to no longer protect it anymore and that's why they are voting no and telling people to vote no!
http://www.lwvny.org/programs-studies/concon/2017/Press-Pension-reform_041117.pdf
Pension benefits. The New York Constitution makes public employee pension benefits contractual and protects them from impairment. Any attempt by a convention to reduce benefits to retirees or to take accrued benefits from current employees would almost certainly violate the Contract Clause of the national Constitution. Even if a convention eliminated the state constitutional protection for pensions, the U.S. Constitution would require that such changes applied only to employees hired after the effective date of any such change. The state has made numerous changes over the course of time to the pension system for future employees. The most recent revision was in 2012, when the legislature put in place a new Tier (Tier VI) and significantly altered the pension conditions for employees joining the retirement system on or after April 1, 2016 (while not affecting existing employees and retirees). In 2017, New Yorkers will vote on a constitutional proposition that would allow pensions to be taken from public officials who have been convicted of a felony related to their public office.
Basically, Federal law prohibits NY from touching the pensions of existing employees.
At ANY time, NY can touch the pensions of future hires, but not existing employees.
Voting no to protect your pension is fear-mongering and misinformation.
If someone wants to vote no, that's their right, but they should really know the actual facts of why they are voting.
|