Re: Constitutional Convention
Posted 10/9/2017 5:11:29 PM by ali120206


Posted by EclecticEsq10810


Posted by abcdefghi

Can teachers lose their pensions? how does it affect them?


No effect because the NYS Constitution doesnt afford them a right to pensions in the 1st place.

See below:


Collective bargaining. Many people would be surprised to learn that collective bargaining on the part of public-sector employees is not even guaranteed by the state constitution. That’s correct: although the state constitution protects the rights of employees to organize and collectively bargain, it contains no reciprocal obligation on the part of government employers to negotiate with worker organizations. Rather, collective bargaining for public employees is protected only by the Taylor Law, a legislative enactment that could be undone through the legislative process (single passage by a majority of both houses and approval by the governor). So in the case of collective bargaining, there is not even a constitutional right to take away.[1]

Pension benefits. The New York constitution makes public employee pension benefits contractual and protects them from impairment. In treating pensions as contracts between the state and the employee, as opposed to matters of legislative grace, New York’s position on this matter resembles six other states.[2] Unlike some states that only protect accrued benefits, New York’s provision protects both accrued and future benefits.


The most irresponsible assertion being perpetrated by convention opponents is that the pensions of existing and retired public employees could “vanish” if a constitutional convention were to be held. This is patently false. Existing public employee and retiree pensions are protected by both federal and state law.



http://www.rockinst.org/observations/galie/2017-08-09_galie.aspx



But that provision could go away if the constitutional convention is approved - since the constitution could be changed...

It also could impact civil service protections.
Print Post      Close Window