Re: Really torn on the HPV vaccine
Posted 7/5/2017 2:00:44 PM by NervousNell


Posted by Pomegranate5


Posted by Paramount


Posted by NervousNell


Posted by MichLiz213


Posted by Paramount

Just an aside...and I am TRULY not trying to start a debate. I am SHOCKED at the amount of people that don't get a flu shot.



My dad had serious, serious complications from the flu one year. He was in his late 40's at the time, no major health issues. Needless to say it was enough to scare all of us into getting it every year.



If only the shot worked. Half the time I hear of people getting the shot and getting the flu anyway.
They always seem to guess what strains are going to be prevalent that year wrong.
Terrible track record.
And the answer is always- well it's a guess.
Wonderful
I feel like it's a crap shot or pure luck on whether or not you get the flu. Shot or not.



And with MUCH respect your post shows how much misinformation there is about the flu shot and what people are "taught" to believe.

1. The flu shot has a GREAT track record.

2. The reason the flu is so bad every year is that there is not enough herd immunity.

3. The shot IS a guess. No question. The scientists have to guess what strain they THINK will prevail the next year.

4. That "guess" is very effective.

5. The flu will not, ever, period, give you the flu. All those people who say they got the flu shot after the flu? They were exposed to the flu before the shot. The shot does NOT cause the flu. AT all.

6. Complications from the flu can and will kill babies and those who can't get the shot.

7. Complications from the Flu are real. Its actually one of the biggest killers every single year. So when people say "its just the flu" they literally have no idea of what they speak. Its deadly and kills SO many people all over the world.

8. getting the flu shot can also dampen symptoms from strains not covered in the shot. So if you get a different strain you are MUCH more likely to have lesser symptoms because of the flu shot.

9. As with ANY vaccination, any tylenol, any medicine there is a risk. Every single medication carries a risk with it.



I'll preface this by saying I have nothing against the flu shot and have given it to my children when they were younger and at greater risk. I got it myself when I was pregnant and right after giving birth.

But where are you getting you basis for saying the flu shot has a "GREAT" track record? For the past three seasons it has been less than 50% effective. Three years ago it was less than 20% effective. Yes that's better than nothing, but it's nowhere near a guarantee. The herd immunity argument is pretty weak when you're talking about this kind of effectiveness, no?



This is exactly what I meant, thanks.
I think it has a pretty awful track record to be honest.
So many people I know who got the shot got the flu last year.
The doctors at both Stat Health and my daughter's ped said the same thing.
But if you want to get the shot, rock on.
Print Post      Close Window