Re: DiBlasio looking to offer free school for all of NYC's 3 year olds
Posted 5/1/2017 8:48:37 PM by alli3131


Posted by sourpatchkids


Posted by alli3131


Posted by Hofstra26


Posted by alli3131


Posted by ap123


Posted by Hofstra26


Posted by olive98


Posted by Katareen


Posted by Diane


Posted by Hofstra26

A 3 yr old doesn't need to be in school IMO. They'll have a YEARS and YEARS of schooling and education, at age 3............stay home, play, and be a kid.



totally agreeChat Icon Chat Icon



With all due respect Hofstra...I know you're a SAHM, previous teacher, that I'm sure provides a TON of enrichment for your children. Reading, cooking, playing games, talking to them all day. Going to the park, visiting friends, taking a trip to the zoo or aquarium. Your three-year-old would not need to be in a program like this because you're providing all of this at home. Not everyone is able to provide this kind of environment for their children.



Not everyone can do this for their kids. Most cant. Be happy that you can...



I'll start by saying that I am NOT a huge proponent of Pre-K in general. I don't feel like it's necessary and I don't like how we're pushing our kids into a structured school environment at a younger and younger age. I don't think it's necessary that a 4 yr old can write their name or count to 100. But that's just me. I didn't go to Pre-K and I didn't send my own DD to Pre-K and she's excelling in school despite not going.

To that end, Pre-K is age 4, not 3. Age 3 is a toddler therefore, this sounds more like state funded daycare to me than "school".

Lastly, while I am fortunate to be able to be a SAHM EVERYONE has the capacity to be a good, nurturing, involved, caring, loving parent who plays with their child, teaches their child, talks with their child, and encourages their growth and development. That is a parents job, not the states. Just my two cents.



I don't think being a caring, loving, nurturing parent has anything to do with this. While loving, caring parents are working long hours to provide for their kids, they are sometimes left with suboptimal childcare options. Caregivers that don't speak english, or don't read/play with the child.
I agree with you that 3 is too young for a full day in school, but that's because my kids are lucky enough to have access to books, language, and constant interaction at home.
I think this is a good thing for a specific population, not for every 3 year old.



I am a loving caring parent but I do not have the ability to stay at home with my DS nor do I even have 3 hrs to sprnd with my DS working on everything he learns at his daycare and now his pre K. I thank God every day I have a wonderful day care and Pre K to support my family.

So for Hofstra to even suggest that people who work long hours and need these services are not loving and nuturing is insane.

Everyone is entitled to their opinion on when to send a child to school but to say parents aren't loving and nurturing because they have to work and don't have the hours in the day is so judgmental.



You missed the point I was making ENTIRELY. The poster above said I should be thankful that I can provide an enriching environment for my kids and MY POINT was that EVERY parent can do that whether they work or not. My being a SAHM doesn't mean I'm doing something with my kids that is exclusive to my being home with them. EVERY parent can nurture their kids with whatever time they have, working or being home doesn't take away from the type of parent you are or can be.

MY POINT was this doesn't sound like SCHOOL he's proposing, it sounds like DAY CARE which shouldn't be funded by the state.

I wasn't judging anyone's parenting, you misread.



Daycare is school. And I do not feel I misread your post.




I am a teacher. Daycare is not school!! I am not a babysitter. Sorry I'm getting off the original topic, but this mentality makes me so mad. Do not send your child to school when he/she is sick as a dog with a fever, because you have no one to care for your child. It is not fair to everyone else in the class. (On that note you should not be sending your child to daycare suck either.) Sorry to hijack the post, but you completely misread what Hofstra was saying.



Whoa who said I was sending my kid anywhere sick. Daycare is childcare but every single one of his teachers is that a teacher. They are not. Abysitting my kid. I have way more respect for them than to ever call them that. The rooms are run like a school. There is curriculum and set schedules for age appropriate play and learning. And it has been that was since he was there as an infant.

So yes his daycare is a school.

Print Post      Close Window