Re: Free college? Cuomo budget passes
Posted 4/11/2017 11:01:28 AM by eroxgirl
Posted by Hofstra26
Posted by Blazesyth
Posted by Hofstra26
If you've been a NYS resident for years and years (or your whole life even) and then you get a tuition free degree and leave to pursue opportunities elsewhere, so be it. Isn't the whole point of this to help educate and better an individual's future??? If so, then giving these kids a degree on a string is utterly ridiculous, they shouldn't be indebted to the state after graduation. Doing that hinders their future, not every career path lends itself to staying in NY. Stupid rule IMO.
I'd think the majority of people taking advantage of this will be 18 year olds. So, while yes they have been NY residents for years and years, they aren't contributing to society or taxes, etc.
What degree that is given by a SUNY school doesn't lend itself to spending the first 4 years of your career in NY? Between upstate and downstate NY is diverse enough where someone could spend the first 4 years of their career in NYS.
I think its fair. If you do decide to leave, your 'free' education is converted to loans. And once again, no one is forcing anyone to take advantage of this program. If you dont like the requirements, then don't take the money.
They haven't been contributing to the state however, their parents have.
As for jobs, I'll give you an example based on my own life. My DH is an electrical engineer. NY, LI especially, isn't a hot bed of technology and engineering jobs. When we graduated college, he took his first engineering job in FL because the pay was great, the cost of living was low, and the opportunity was better. (We also considered MA, RI, and CT) Currently, we're looking to move off the island again, this time to MA because there is SO much more technology and better opportunities there. So IMO, to force someone to stay in NY to work and making them forgo other (potentially better) career opportunities isn't fair. A new grad should be free to explore whatever opportunity is best for them whether that is here in NY or elsewhere.
Also, to that end, LI and NYC are EXTREMELY expensive places to live and most 22 year old new grads would do better NOT staying in the area after college. Certain careers, like engineering, pay VERY well out of school but many careers do not. Good luck living on LI making $25-30K/yr. It's not easy.
Again, why hinder them for 4 years?? I think there should be residency requirements leading into attending but after that, I don't think they should be held to remaining in the state. JMO.
Just speaking to the "why hinder them" part.. I think that's off base. No one HAS to take the free tuition. They can instead go to private school elsewhere and be 'hindered' by 150k in student loans. That will also restrict where they can live and work, kwim?
|